nateswoodworks Posted November 21, 2012 Report Posted November 21, 2012 Thanks to a delay on starting my next project I am going to start my Roubo in a couple weeks and was wondering what thickness you deem adequate? I am bouncing back and forth between what I am going to use for the top, I have Rock Elm that I bought a boat load of years back and Hard Maple from a few trees I harvested several years ago. I think I would prefer the Maple because of the lighter color but the Rock Elm because I have more of it. With the maple I could harvest without much waste a 3 1/4" top but I was planning on 4", do you think I would notice the difference? The bench will be a little shy of 8' with a tool tray at the back and designed for handtools. I think I already know the answer but sometimes you have to hear it when you are thinking in terms of waste. I have Schwarz workbench book coming but with my brain going in circles I just have to ask. I would greatly appreciate any input you may have. Have a very Happy Thanksgiving! Quote
Eric. Posted November 21, 2012 Report Posted November 21, 2012 If you're using the Benchcrafted hardware you'll want to shoot for 4" since the tail vise installation is designed around that thickness. You can still deviate from that thickness but you'll have to do some modifications if you deviate too much. If you're not using the BC hardware, it's up to you...and IMO 3 1/4" is probably adequate. That said, the thicker the better, right? At least to a point...5" is probably overkill. If I were you I'd just use the elm since you have it laying around and you can get the full 4 inches out of it. Quote
Jfitz Posted November 21, 2012 Report Posted November 21, 2012 Hmm....thats a tough choice. Poor you My first thought is to use the elm for thicker top and because you have more of it.....but the hard maple is almost twice the hardness of the elm. Now, rock maple might be too hard for a bench but is elm too soft? Just something to think about..... Also, elm is not as stable as maple. Quote
nateswoodworks Posted November 21, 2012 Author Report Posted November 21, 2012 I'm not going with the Benchcrafted hardware, instead of a leg vise I am sticking with my old Record vise, i love it and wouldn't want to be without it! That being said I do want to keep my options open for adding one in the future. I am adding a Wagon vise but am not sure about which hardware yet. I am having a second quick release vise on the tail vise side, my kids love making stuff the there are two of them so having two vises is a great thing. I thinki am going to go with the maple, this will be my "forever bench" and I don't want any regrets-at least that's where I am at today! Thanks for the input, greatly appreciated, any other input would also be super. Quote
Barbancourt Posted November 22, 2012 Report Posted November 22, 2012 I've seen posts and articles stating that "standard" holdfasts (I.e. Grammercy) lose there grip if the top gets much thicker than 4", so that 4" seems to be a commonly mentioned target thickness. Quote
Mike M Posted November 23, 2012 Report Posted November 23, 2012 The elm would be a good choice for the base of the bench. Quote
nateswoodworks Posted November 26, 2012 Author Report Posted November 26, 2012 Well I decided since this is my "forever bench" that I am going with the maple for the top. I took stock the other day and I have just enough long boards for the top, worse case I would have had to buy one. I still have several 6' boards left for another project, one of which will be a moxon vise. I got all the pieces rough cut for the base the other night and hope to start on the top this week, just waiting for the wagon vise hardware. Keep ya posted. Quote
tim0625 Posted February 6, 2013 Report Posted February 6, 2013 How about the bench Nate? Do you have some pictures? Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.