Recommended Posts

Posted

I tried to prep a qr sawen white oak dining table with only planes and a card scraper. My smoother pulled some awesome shavings. I finally feel my camber and plane adjustments were spot on.There were some trouble areas that needed card scraping. I was also a little nervous of track marks so I card scraped everywhere.

I really thought the stars had aligned. Untill I applied my top coat. I assume that there are marks left from the card scraper all over the table. There is a rippel effect on the surface. Start and stop marks?I believe the surface would have been better left alone after smoothing. Or I could have final sanded with fine grit on the orbital followed up with a hand sand.

I hate sanding. I hate it even more now that planes have entered my craft. Any advise to perfect my surface prep would be great.

Posted

uggg dont like card scrapers they are too difficult for me to sharpen. spent hours trying to get it right and the people on youtube have huge mounds of shaving after a few seconds of work....how do they do it. also read in a book a fun scraper is to use a spoon grind down the edge and curve it over and you can scrape on concave surfaces.

Posted

Card scrapers blow my mind. It's an amazing tool.

The trick is rolling the burr nice and easy. You also have to true up all the flats on a stone and grab some good corners. Roll that burr the wrong way first with 2 light passes with the burnisher almost flat to the scraper and moving it toward you and off the edge. Next, tip the scraper on edge and roll the cutting burr with the burnisher on a baby angle 1-2 times Nice and easy. Nice and easy. Did I mention nice and easy.

Posted

Sounds like you may have overworked the surface a bit. I think a plane will always leave a nicer surface and the scrapers just tackle the nasty spots. The difficulty comes when you have blend the scraped and planed surfaces and honestly this is where a little 220 or higher grit can be useful. If I have a tough spot I'm more prone to trying to fix it with a plane than go to the scraper. Make sure the mouth is tight and ligthen up your cut if necessary. Of course a quick hones will always help. If you are worried about plane tracks then you either haven't cambered the blade enough or you are taking too heavy a cut to the point where your cambered corners are projecting. Long story short, try to fix the surface with a single tool. Once you switch you will get a different look and that has to be blended.

  • Like 1

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.