farmbag72 Posted March 28, 2013 Report Posted March 28, 2013 I've been saving specifically for a Festool track saw. Is the extra cutting capacity of the TS75EQ worth the $150 more than the TS55EQ? I plan for this to be the 1 and only track saw I ever purchase so I don't want any regrets. Can either do something that the other can not or is it simply a matter of size & money? Quote
ScoFF Posted March 28, 2013 Report Posted March 28, 2013 I bought the TS75 because it wasn't thy much more money, I never wanted to regret not getti g the bigger saw and since I wasn't using it all day I didn't mind the extra weight to lug around. It also comes with the longer rail you have to consider. The 55 has a 4.58 foot long rail so ripping a 4 foot sheet of plywood and allowing for start/end overhang you'll barely have enough length. Speaking of buyers regret, you know the TSREQ is out? And I think the new 75 version is coming. 1 Quote
Imaginos Posted March 28, 2013 Report Posted March 28, 2013 Well, it's size and capability for the money. If it's worth it really depends on what you'll be doing with it, and, in all fairness you should be asking if you want the new TS55REQ (due out on May 1st) or a TS75. If you already have a table saw and will be using the TS to break down sheet goods, the 55 is the probably the way to go. I used a 75 for about two years as my only powered saw. Were I out starting again, I'd probably make the same decision unless I knew a joinery table saw was showing up very soon. The increased cutting capacity was vial to prepping stock for the Roubo build as well as some other projects, and completing those were worth more than the difference in price. Your mileage may vary if you already have a full production shop and just need something for a work site. Then again it could be a completely different story if, like me, you're a guerilla working out of a grarage for your own benefit and this saw is all you have. That said, head over to FOG and some of the other threads here and you'll see that, some say, the 75 doesn't cut quite a clean as a 55 and it's aledgedly not as good a tool to use on a MTF. If that's true then the 55 must be a friggin laser beam because I've never had any cut quality problems with a 75 (although, I don't have an MTF either). Also keep in mind that the Festool track saws don't exist in a vacuum. You're not buying a tool as much as a component of a system. You'll get more out of Festool the more of it you have (dust extractor, routers, so on), but it's a slippery slope since they mercilessly kill you for the acessories (blades, tracks, track clamps, splinter guards, so on...a $20 driver bit? C'Mon). Also consider that Festool isn't the only option. Take a serious look at the Dewalt and some of the other options and that'll either lead you to something else or validate that Festool is the best answer for you. It really depends on what you expect out of the saw. 1 Quote
jmaichel Posted March 28, 2013 Report Posted March 28, 2013 I have had both and currently have the TS75 and I like a lot more than the 55. The TS75 is much better at ripping hardwoods than the TS55. 1 Quote
pghmyn Posted March 28, 2013 Report Posted March 28, 2013 I have the TS 55, and I love it. I also have a full size table saw, so I really only use the ts 55 for plywood and heavy pieces. Even though I don't use it too often, the first project I used it on it paid for itself. Accurately ripping a sheet of plywood up into components in under 30 minutes, and then perfectly squaring up the 1.125" thick Maple top with no struggle or burning. That top was super heavy and putting it on the table saw by myself would have been difficult. If you don't have a table saw, get the 75, if you do have a table saw, get the 55. Quote
farmbag72 Posted March 28, 2013 Author Report Posted March 28, 2013 ,in all fairness you should be asking if you want the new TS55REQ (due out on May 1st) or a TS75. Can anyone tell me how the TS55REQ differs from the TS55EQ?? I've seen the notices on the Festool site about the REQ but couldn't find any spec sheets to see what they upgraded/improved. Thanks for the responses. I'm a hobbyist that also just loves the tools but I don't want to short-change myself or buy a tool that I'll never begin to fully utilize. I grew up with parents that collected Bristish antique cars. My dad & I did all of the mechanical work on them. My dad loves tools & spent the money to buy Snap-on. I know & appreciate the difference between a tool that will get the job done and a tool that will help perform the job at the highest level. Quote
Imaginos Posted March 28, 2013 Report Posted March 28, 2013 Can anyone tell me how the TS55REQ differs from the TS55EQ?? I've seen the notices on the Festool site about the REQ but couldn't find any spec sheets to see what they upgraded/improved. I handled the TS55REQ at a demo but was prohibited from actually running the saw until after it's officially released. It's not a dramatic difference. The REQ has a different depth stop that shows you above and below the track plunge depth, plus a micrometer so that you can really dial in a plunge to 1/256th of a milimeter's shadow or some such. The riving knife is bigger, like TS75EQ sized. The off-cut splinter guard is internal to the blade guard so that it can be used while cutting a bevel. The bevel angle goes from -2(?) to +47 with positive stops at 0 and 45. The blade guard itself has been narrowed a fair bit so that you can cut within 1/4" of an obstruction such as a wall. It left me with the impression that if I were installing flooring or countertops and needed to be very careful about cutting along baseboards/backslashes at a specific depth (for fear of putting the blade into cement), it'd be a total game changer. Short of that (or something similar), it's still a great saw but ultimately just an incremental improvement and most likely not worth upgrading if you have the current model. Oh, and there was an imperial plunge scale in the back of the instruction book with a drawing of how to stick on the saw. Like pghymn said, if I had a table saw already, I'd get the TS55REQ. If I had a track saw only, it'd be a TS75. 1 Quote
STL Woodguy Posted March 28, 2013 Report Posted March 28, 2013 One point I'd like to make is that while the TS75 is more powerful, the blade can make a difference too. Whenever I rip hardwoods on the TS55, I switch to a 30-T blade and it chews right through it. Likewise, one could get a higher tooth blade for the TS75 and have the cleaner cuts. I think what it will ultimately boil down to is how deep you plan on cutting and how often. Or how extremely dense the wood is, that would tip it towards the TS75. 1 Quote
JerrySats Posted March 28, 2013 Report Posted March 28, 2013 What your going to do with it has more to do with the right one to buy . I have the TS55 , my needs are breaking down plywood more then anything , so the 55 works great for my needs . If your going to be cutting a lot of hardwoods and thicker material then the TS75 might be what you need . Wait for the new 55 if you decide to get that one , if your not happy with it you'll be able to sell it easy . 1 Quote
shofestoolusa Posted March 29, 2013 Report Posted March 29, 2013 Hello, Shane Holland here with Festool USA. Saw the thread and thought I'd respond. I bought the TS75 because it wasn't thy much more money, I never wanted to regret not getti g the bigger saw and since I wasn't using it all day I didn't mind the extra weight to lug around. It also comes with the longer rail you have to consider. The 55 has a 4.58 foot long rail so ripping a 4 foot sheet of plywood and allowing for start/end overhang you'll barely have enough length. Speaking of buyers regret, you know the TSREQ is out? And I think the new 75 version is coming. Bob, the TS 55 REQ will be available on May 1st and there are no plans that I'm aware of to introduce an updated TS 75. I have a good read on what's on the pipe from Germany and have seen nothing about an update for it. Regarding choosing between the two saws. If you work with a lot of thick hardwoods and need the extra power or capacity of the TS 75 (2-3/4" vs. 1-15/16"), it may be worth a look. Remember, we offer a 30-day money back guarantee on our tools. So, get the one you think will best suit your needs and if after 30 days it does meet your needs or expectations, just return or exchange it. Thanks, Shane 1 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.