Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Worked great on oak, not so good on Pine. Help to a noob?

Featured Replies

I acquired a 1940's wood, yes real wood, desk from my employer that she was going to pitch.  I though I could refinish it and so far everything has been great.  The desk is surrounded by large oak panels and the drawer faces have the same panels on the face with solid wood making up the rest of the drawer.  I sanded the face of one drawer as an experiment.  I took it down to 220 and it looked really nice.  To finish it I used 2 (or 3?) coats of Minwax Polyshade  (really dark Bombay something) following by 3 coats of Polyurethane  Satin.  The result was really nice.  I moved on to the rest of the desk and everything turned out the same way.  Really nice.

 

Now for the top.  The original top was garbage.  It had been replaced with a particle board formica junk panel that I removed and pitched.  I don't have the tools to cut a 4x8 cabinet grade oak panel to size and when I talked to the Home Depot dude, he said their saw would chip the edges so I should stick with pine.  Also that when stained you wouldn't be able to tell the difference.

 

Moving on.  I finish sanded the top with 220 just as I had with everything else and when I started laying the stain, lightly I thought, The overlap areas (which I tried to avoid) were getting wide streaks of buildup.  I switched over to the other side of the top and started again with super super dry brush stroked which left streaks that slowly filled in, but I still had over lap lines.

 

Of note, I've used sponge brushes with this stain since the beginning of the project with great success. So....

 

How do I fix this?

Is my stain to old?  I've had the can for a couple months and maybe the solvents are evaporating....

Is it drying to fast?

 

If I have to , I can pitch the top and start over, but I'd rather not.

 

Any advice is greatly appreciated.

Thanks

Crusty.

Go back to Home Depot and hit the guy with the desktop...  Only kidding!   Violence is never the answer.

 

Pine is not easy to stain dark.  The varying hardness in pine growth rings allow different absorbtion rates, causing a problem known as "blotching"...  The only way to truly get pine to "match" a stained oak finish, is to seal the surfaces and spray a stain.  In this case, the stain is essentially acting like a transparent or "candy" paint.   This is similar to how Polyshades works, but some of the first coat still penetrates, and brushing causes "lap" marks.  It's very difficult to get the product to spread evenly, and it's more obvious with darker colors.

 

I might be wrong, but I seem to remember Polyshades being available in spray cans.  If you can find it, sand the ugly finish back, and build a finish with even coats from the spray bomb.  It'll be more expensive, and spray bombs need a number of coats, due to a thinned product, but I think the result will be better.

 

An alternative is to treat the top like a secondary wood feature.  Strip it down and refinish to either a light color close to natural, which won't show blotching or lapping as badly, take it ultra dark, or even paint it.

I've heard nothing but crap about Polyshades. I will at all costs never use such a product. Sand this useless product all down to bear wood. Then get a gel stain with a similar colour and apply your poly after that. No blotching at all.

  • Author

Go back to Home Depot and hit the guy with the desktop...  Only kidding!   Violence is never the answer.

 

Pine is not easy to stain dark.  The varying hardness in pine growth rings allow different absorbtion rates, causing a problem known as "blotching"...  The only way to truly get pine to "match" a stained oak finish, is to seal the surfaces and spray a stain.  In this case, the stain is essentially acting like a transparent or "candy" paint.   This is similar to how Polyshades works, but some of the first coat still penetrates, and brushing causes "lap" marks.  It's very difficult to get the product to spread evenly, and it's more obvious with darker colors.

--What if I sand this down, then find a NON-polyshade version, thin it with mineral spirits, then stain?  Also, I sanded to 220, what if I only sand to 120?  bigger pores would take the stain easier, correct?

 

 

 

I might be wrong, but I seem to remember Polyshades being available in spray cans.  If you can find it, sand the ugly finish back, and build a finish with even coats from the spray bomb.  It'll be more expensive, and spray bombs need a number of coats, due to a thinned product, but I think the result will be better.

--Spray bomb will create so much overspray I'll be covering my motorcycle with a hermetic barrier....  Not sure I can do this one with the kiddo's around....

 

 

An alternative is to treat the top like a secondary wood feature.  Strip it down and refinish to either a light color close to natural, which won't show blotching or lapping as badly, take it ultra dark, or even paint it.

--I want it to be consistent so this one isn't really an option.

 

Using a regular home center stain may blotch worse than the Polyshades, or if the wood is sealed enough, it may not penetrate, or may not dry at all.   If you're going to try this, I'd suggest Tkf's tip of a gel stain.  Sanding to a larger grit can help grab the pigment particles, but will also encourage more blotching, and if not done correctly, the stain will accentuate sanding scratches. 

 

General Finishes makes an excellent gel stain, but you'll have to find a woodworking store, such as Woodcraft or maybe Rockler.  Try your zip code on the GF site.

 

Practice on the bottom face, until you get the look you want.

 

Unfortunately, getting two very different woods to match can be a real pain, and is much harder than it might seem, especially with hand applied home center products.

  • Author

Ok... I'll Run to HD and look for a Gel Stain... BUT.... what is the best way to apply this to a 72x42 desktop (in inches).  

 

What should I sand with? 120?  220?  I don't want to go too far down cuz I'll go through the venier on the ply.

 

Finish sanding still a 220?

 

And Thanks for the advice to both of you dudes (dudette?)

 

Rich.

Ok... I'll Run to HD and look for a Gel Stain... BUT.... what is the best way to apply this to a 72x42 desktop (in inches).  

 

What should I sand with? 120?  220?  I don't want to go too far down cuz I'll go through the venier on the ply.

 

Finish sanding still a 220?

 

And Thanks for the advice to both of you dudes (dudette?)

 

Rich.

 

Try sanding to different grits on the bottom surface, see what works best.

 

BTW...  I do not like Minwax Gel Stain.  Good luck with it if you choose to use it.  I've tried it several times, and as an experienced finisher with formal training, I could not get results with it that made me happy.    I'm not much of a fan of Minwax products in general, although I do occasionally use their Natural stain, wiping poly, and spray can lacquer with decent results.  As far as home center / paint store stains go, the best I've used is Zar, but I don't think they make a gel product.  

Your not going to make the pine look like oak not even close. Take the pine and go back to home depot and do Barry suggested.  

Before you jump on the Minwax haters bandwagon, realize the only thing wrong with minwax is their advertising of how simple the products are to use. Poly shades is just a shaded poly finish and if applied properly works very well. You mention sanding to 220 but no mention of sealer. First 220 is to fine especially for pine 150/180 is where you want to stop for stain but your not staining with poly shades. A shaded finish wether its minwax polyshades or a custom blend from sherwin williams which happens to be the same company need to be properly sealed before you start the shading process. With pine you would need to apply something like minwax sanding sealer then test for streaks. Keep adding sanding sealer until the streaking is gone. You may find that just one coat of sealer is needed for oak but 3 or 4 coats for pine. 

If you want to stick with the pine you can make it more of a solid finish hiding the fact that it is pine... well somewhat any ways. You can use a similar colored stain of pretty much any flavor just to darken up over a coat of sanding sealer. Reseal over the stain and follow up with the poly shades to build the final color. Your not going to get spray finished results but you will get better than a gel stain.

  • Author

I think what I'm going to do is Sand this sucker down with 120 until I get uncomfortable with the look (it is a veneer so I'm concerned about over sanding) and test on the scrap pieces using what I'm reading here...   then try again.  If this doesn't work I'll go back to a piece of oak ply sanded at 220 like the rest of the desk is sanded to.  AGain, testing on the scraps...

 

Crazy thing is I tested on the scrap and it worked good.  I think I only sanded to 120 though....   might be the big difference....

 

Thanks all

Rich.

Another option may be an Oak Veneer on top of the pine.  

 

I have no idea what this would cost, but it should give you a decent match.  

 

The panel saw at HD will chip, but for future reference, you can just buy a roll of painters tape and tape the seem where the blade cuts, and beg the operator to CUT SLOW!  I have had some jam the saw through wood, while others who actually know how to use it, can make a very nice cut.  You will have to do some clean up, but very manageable if HD is your only option for plywood.  A mill will sell you better grade material, and cut with a much higher grade saw if there is one in the area. 

  • Author

Another option may be an Oak Veneer on top of the pine.  

 

I have no idea what this would cost, but it should give you a decent match.  

 

The panel saw at HD will chip, but for future reference, you can just buy a roll of painters tape and tape the seem where the blade cuts, and beg the operator to CUT SLOW!  I have had some jam the saw through wood, while others who actually know how to use it, can make a very nice cut.  You will have to do some clean up, but very manageable if HD is your only option for plywood.  A mill will sell you better grade material, and cut with a much higher grade saw if there is one in the area. 

There is a wood supplier right around the corner from my office.  Their sheets of Oak ply are 50% more expensive than the HD which is why I've been hesitant to go there... plus I hear their customer service stinks....  

 

I just returned from the HD by my office with a good quality stain brush and some mineral spirits.  I'm going to try and use 0000 steel with the spirits on the really bad spots and then sand again, but with the 120 instead of the 220.  This is a last ditch effort before I use it for scrap.

 

THEN, I'll go back and do the whole thing over again with OAK and test on the scraps like I did this time and use the same sanding, etc...  Maybe I can make this work....  

The panel saws at home centers will chip a lot less if your remember they are handheld circular saws on rails.   When cutting with a circular saw that isn't equipped with some sort of zero clearance foot, put the show face DOWN (away from the saw). 

 

The best cuts come when the cutting teeth enter the work on the show face.  On a table or band saw, cut face up, on a circular saw, cut face down.

  • Author

I think I have discovered a big part of the problem.  I invested in a nice big stain brush and sanded the table almost white again with 80, then 120.  The veneer was starting to look pretty bad so I figured it was a write off..  I trudged on anyway and tried laying down some layers of stain taking it easy with a dry-ish brush.  This worked for a bit but I think the brush started loading up too much and the stain was really thick.  I stirred up the stain with a screw driver instead of a stir stick and when I pull the screw driver up there was a thick slime on the blade..  this wouldn't stir out.  I poor some into a bowl and chunks started coming out.  Could the can not have been sealed very well and the solvents partially evaporated?

 

By the time I got to the middle of the surface the overlap was so thick I couldn't get it off...   Then I decided to thin out the stain a bit and wow what a difference.  suddenly I could put a couple rows down before it started to get tacky.  more came off the brush evenly.....

 

120-150 grit and newer stain?  Could that be my answer?  I'd be happy to switch to a regular stain but when I looked I couldn't find the same color in a stain only.....

Crusty, I would definitely suggest that any time you are using a stain, or any other finish that you are not accustomed to, always work on samples to get just the finish you desire. Once you have figured out all the unique characteristics of that stain or finish on samples, it's much easier to accomplish what you wish on the project. Polyshades is notorious for having large hunks of sediment in the bottom of the can. I don't know if that's because they don't sell it fast enough, or because that's the nature of the beast. Either way, it's a bear to work with. Stirring doesn't get it, and straining is futile. I've used the Bombay Mahogany Polyshades before and stuck with it to the bitter end, only because my customer insisted on it. It was a nightmare, and I'll never do it again. Best of luck on your effort.

  • Author

Crusty, I would definitely suggest that any time you are using a stain, or any other finish that you are not accustomed to, always work on samples to get just the finish you desire. Once you have figured out all the unique characteristics of that stain or finish on samples, it's much easier to accomplish what you wish on the project. Polyshades is notorious for having large hunks of sediment in the bottom of the can. I don't know if that's because they don't sell it fast enough, or because that's the nature of the beast. Either way, it's a bear to work with. Stirring doesn't get it, and straining is futile. I've used the Bombay Mahogany Polyshades before and stuck with it to the bitter end, only because my customer insisted on it. It was a nightmare, and I'll never do it again. Best of luck on your effort

Troy,  I tried the mahogony on the scrap from the original piece of 4x8.  It turned out really well... then again, it was a small section and not 6 feet long.  Different beast altogether I'm learning.  

 

I've learned to have the Homedepot dude turn the working face of the wood down so the saw blade doesn't come UP through the work surface, but down.

I've learned that the stain I have has lost a lot of it's chutzpah becuase it's A. not very good anyway, B. has some age on it.  C. not very good anyway. 

I've learned that the HomeDepot dudes can be lazy and thus their advice we facilitate the laziness...  

 

I need something to match that Bombay mahogony.  The whole piece is done in that shade, albeit, each piece was small.  Now I'm doing the top and it's all one piece.  It appears that there are several things going wrong with this top and I'm at the point where I"m going to pitch it and start over with oak.  Any suggestions?

Crusty, if it were me, I would use oak for the top as well. I would also make sure that I put at least two coats of sanding sealer or de-waxed shellac on the top, to help build a thick finish and to eliminate the wood soaking up the stain solvents too fast on the Polyshade. Thin your finish slightly, not too much or you loose the tint, so it flows better, and use a GOOD 4" brush to apply. When I say a good brush, I'm talking about a $30 Purdy made for oil based only. Do not over-brush. Get it on and leave it alone. Don't try to go back and brush out air bubbles. They should work their way to the surface before it skims over. Let the surface dry for twenty four hours and wet sand the top with a sanding block and 400 grit wet-dry paper. If additional coats of finish are needed, in order to achieve the desired color, repeat the sanding between coats.  Once you have achieved the desired color, top coat with an oil based satin poly.

I second the good brush.  Don't sweat the price of a good brush.

 

 

My dad has been doing painting for the past year at my grandparent's estate.  Just last month, he had to throw out a brush and replace it.  He's notoriously frugal, and doesn't like to spend a lot of money, but he buys quality brushes.  He's not a young guy, having learned painting back in the 60's-70's, but that brush he had to throw out he was a little grumpy on.  

 

Apparently, his timeframe on a quality brush is five years.  This brush was about twelve years past that.

 

Good care and cleaning immediately afterwards will prolong the tools you use.  also selecting the right brush, not just the cheap one or the one at the end of the rack.  (Can't tell you how many times I've fallen for that one, and it's bitten me badly, causing a strip and refinish process on my own stuff.)

  • Author

Troy and "J""

 

I'm already on the bandwagon for the good brush.  I have one specifically for oil based stains.  I firmly believe in the care of my tools.  I have had the same craftsman ratchets and sockets for 25 years now.  I bought them once, and never again.

 

As far as the wood goes, I'm pitching it.  My birthday was yesterday and my mother usually sends a fat home depot gift card.  I'm going to use it to purchase the oak ply and the trim.  Plus a NEW can of stain....

 

It sounds like you (Troy) are telling me I should go ahead with the same stain (new can obviously) AND that I should thin it.  To what percent?

 

Also, the more I think about it, the more I realize that the stain wasn't behaving correctly.  It was definitley drying to quick and wasn't staying fluid like when I was doing the other pieces, albiet the other pieces weren't nearly this big....  

 

Ok... we're going to try again.....

I agree with PB on having them mix your finish, but don't rush home and use it right away. Poly tends to hold bubbles in suspension for a while. I usually wait a day before using any poly that has been shaken and then stir before using.

  • Author

I agree with PB on having them mix your finish, but don't rush home and use it right away. Poly tends to hold bubbles in suspension for a while. I usually wait a day before using any poly that has been shaken and then stir before using.

Ok, so my current problem is going to come down to the Polyshade.  It's the color I used on all the other surfaces and they turned out great.  However, I'm concerned about using the polyshade on the much larger top to the desk.  I can buy a can, have it shaken, then use it, but will it behave the same?  I don't know.  Perhaps I should get the new can, shakeit. and use it on the underside of the horrid Pine surface after prepping.  Perhaps that would give me an idea as to weather the previous can was bad.

 

Another solution is to try another stain, NOT Polyshade, but the closest color match I can find is the Minwax Wood Finish Red Mahogany, vs. the PolyShade Bombay Mahogany.  Should I just thin out the Polyshade from the new can and how much?

Crusty, I would start with a 5 to 1 ratio (five parts poly). Just mix up a small amount for testing purposes and see how it flows. The biggest problem I had with the Polyshades was that it didn't flow well, and pigments would build up in the brush. Thinning helps. Whatever you do, don't try to spray it. What a mess. There are other companies that make similar shades of stain and most are called "Dark Mahogany".

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,011 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • bobtjanitor Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.