DaBear Posted May 23, 2013 Report Posted May 23, 2013 I've got a Delta 14" bandsaw (with riser) running with a 3/4 hp motor. I find this pretty sluggish to be honest. I use my BS for a lot of cuts, rips, trimming large bowl blanks, and I'd like to do a bit of veneer and resawing, but the little bit I've done gets painful as soon as I go beyond about 2" stock. For my 'big' cuts, I'm using a sharp 3TPI blade with coolblocks, so I THINK I've got that much right.. Upgraded to a segmented belt a while back and that drastically improved vibration, but didn't do anything for the power (not that I'd expect it to).. I'm looking at upgrading the motor to a 1.5 hp (TEFC) and wondering what your thoughts were. Anyone do something like this? Is this 'too much' power for this frame? Any 'gotchas' to think about? Thanks in advance.. Quote
DaBear Posted May 23, 2013 Author Report Posted May 23, 2013 Good question, don't really know, just whatever the saw started with. I'll get the RPM of the current motor and do some math and get back to you.. Tnx, Quote
wilburpan Posted May 23, 2013 Report Posted May 23, 2013 I find this pretty sluggish to be honest. I use my BS for a lot of cuts, rips, trimming large bowl blanks, and I'd like to do a bit of veneer and resawing, but the little bit I've done gets painful as soon as I go beyond about 2" stock. Is this true if you slow down your feed rate? Michael Fortune, who probably uses bandsaws in professional work as much as, if not more than anyone else, says that you should be able to do most things a 14" bandsaw has the capacity to do with a 1/2-3/4 HP motor. I've posted this before, but as an example, here's my old bandsaw. It has a 1/2" HP motor and a 1/2" 3 tpi blade, and I was able to resaw this 9+" wide piece of cherry without problems. The key for me was that I took my time feeding the board. If you feed a board too fast, you'll cause the gullets of your bandsaw blade to fill with sawdust, and it will stop cutting. You'll feel this as the motor bogging down. Quote
dwacker Posted May 23, 2013 Report Posted May 23, 2013 The advantage of HP is being able to feed at the proper rate. Feed with enough pressure to cut the wood rather than make dust and dull the blade. Most blades today have a high beam strength so you can feed at some fairly fast rated if you have the HP. Quote
wilburpan Posted May 23, 2013 Report Posted May 23, 2013 I would think that using higher horsepower to power a blade so that it can cut the wood instead of making dust as you describe is really using a more powerful motor to overcome dullness in the teeth of the bandsaw blade. It does make sense to me that a higher blade speed can help in allowing a higher feed rate. With a higher blade speed, the tooth and gullet will spend less time in the wood, lessening the chance that the gullet will become packed with sawdust. And it is true that bandsaws that run at higher blade speeds tend to be bigger, necessitating the need for a higher HP motor and allowing the use of wider blades. But it is also true that you can resaw with a smaller bandsaw and get better results with a slower feed rate. Most of us are hobbyists, so production speed is not an issue. If you were in production, you might want the added speed. But as I mentioned above, Michael Fortune is a professional woodworker who uses bandsaws a lot, and he's on record as saying that HP is not as critical a need in your standard 14" bandsaw compared to other factors in getting good results. One other point that I think about: back in the 1930's-1950's, your standard 14" (or so) bandsaw came with 1/3-1/2 HP motors. They could resaw capacity of 6-10". I'm sure that woodworkers back then also resawed boards the same way that we do today. If HP was so important, why didn't bandsaws come with more powerful motors back then? I agree that it's nice to have a more powerful motor on a bandsaw. I just think there are a lot of other things you can do to improve your results before getting a bigger motor. Quote
Mike Frank Posted May 23, 2013 Report Posted May 23, 2013 get a regular v groove belt has more in contat with pully wont slip cool blocks are crap put steel ones back in and tune your saw really good you should not have any issues you are reporting Quote
dwacker Posted May 23, 2013 Report Posted May 23, 2013 But it is also true that you can resaw with a smaller bandsaw and get better results with a slower feed rate. Most of us are hobbyists, so production speed is not an issue. If you were in production, you might want the added speed. But as I mentioned above, Michael Fortune is a professional woodworker who uses bandsaws a lot, and he's on record as saying that HP is not as critical a need in your standard 14" bandsaw compared to other factors in getting good results. One other point that I think about: back in the 1930's-1950's, your standard 14" (or so) bandsaw came with 1/3-1/2 HP motors. They could resaw capacity of 6-10". I'm sure that woodworkers back then also resawed boards the same way that we do today. If HP was so important, why didn't bandsaws come with more powerful motors back then? I agree that it's nice to have a more powerful motor on a bandsaw. I just think there are a lot of other things you can do to improve your results before getting a bigger motor. I find Michael fortune a great woodworker but his word is not gospel and times have changed. The OP is seeing his saw as sluggish when fed at the rate he wants not what Michael Fortune finds suitable. He stated his blade is sharp and is only cutting 2" thickness. If he is feeding at a rate that is stalling his motor there are only three things that will cause that dull blade, underpowered motor or to slow blade speed. Can he slow his feed rate? Of course but he is asking how to get better performance without the saw sounding like its in pain. If the blade is sharp and running at the right speed the only way to increase feed rate is to get a bigger motor. Michael Fortune may find that for him a slow feed rate works best but there are many folks that might like to feed at a faster clip than Michael fortune. Saws that are fed to slow just like any other tools be it a table saw or router cause excess heat due to unnecessary friction. This dulls blades thus why a resaw running a 1" blade will outlast by many times a conventional saw running the exact same blade at the exact same speed. The difference is the feed rate that the 20 hp motors can handle. Back in the 30's and 50's the 1/2 hp motors had more power than what we call a 1hp motor today? They still had the same issues if they wanted to move faster they had to buy bigger saws. Bigger saws with more HP so they didnt stall the motors. Today we have high beam strength blades that are narrow and can handle pretty fast feed rates well above what the motor on the saw can handle. Many of us like to take advantage of that high beam strength and feed at a rate that we prefer not what Michael fortune prefers. Quote
wilburpan Posted May 24, 2013 Report Posted May 24, 2013 The OP is seeing his saw as sluggish when fed at the rate he wants not what Michael Fortune finds suitable. He stated his blade is sharp and is only cutting 2" thickness. If he is feeding at a rate that is stalling his motor there are only three things that will cause that dull blade, underpowered motor or to slow blade speed. Can he slow his feed rate? Of course but he is asking how to get better performance without the saw sounding like its in pain.My read of the OP's post is that he was looking for help in improving his results. Based on his description of the problem he was having, slowing down the feed rate will do that, and he didn't state that he was unwilling to push the wood slower. Maybe I resaw at a rate that is slower than some people would like. But I get great results.If you read my post, you'll see that I do say that having a higher HP motor is nice to have. But for your typical 14" bandsaw, there are many other things you can do to improve performance before needing to swap out your motor.Tool catalogs from the 1930's-1950's show that motors were available from Delta, Walker-Turner, etc. up to 2-3 HP. But they didn't put them on 14" bandsaws. Quote
wdwerker Posted May 26, 2013 Report Posted May 26, 2013 I put a 1 1/2 hp motor on my 14" Delta bandsaw with a riser kit. My motor died after someone tried to cut 8" of particle board until he smoked the windings. I was going to get a 1 hp but it was out of stock and the 1 1/2 hp was the same price. Both motors were the same rpm and I just swapped the pulley and bolted it up. Never had it bog down on me since, resawing is easier but you have to use the right blade especially on thicker stock. Quote
DaBear Posted July 3, 2013 Author Report Posted July 3, 2013 Thanks to all for the feedback. To answer the previous question of 'how fast', the current motor is a 1750RPM one, and with the pulleys, it runs the bandsaw wheels at about half that, so if you were looking for FPM, it should be (14*(1750/2)*3.14)/12 = ~3200 FPM currently (assuming my math is right).. To expand on the current 'user experience', I can cut with a VERY slow feed rate, but anything above a snails pace is simply not possible right now. I don't believe it's a case of the blade binding due to sawdust however, as I don't think I get moving fast enough for that, it just feels like the machine is 'grinding' the wood off instead of cutting.. Hard to describe I guess.. Current plan it to do some more tests to ensure I'm not just hitting a case of the belt slipping, and try to do some more investigation on the blade end of the equation as well. Assuming neither of those directions yield results, I plan on swapping the motor out for a 1.5 HP one, same RPM. I'll then use the existing motor to built myself a low speed grinding rig (currently only have a 3500 RPM grinder), so I'll be reducing the 'waste' if I go that route.. Comments welcome.. Quote
DaBear Posted July 9, 2013 Author Report Posted July 9, 2013 Likely the final update on this, but some good news, I have been able to significantly improve performance by simply tightening the belt a bit. Mike's comment about segmented belts is likely a very germane one, as well as the fact that in my case, the pulley on the motor appears to have a slightly smaller groove than the pulley on the lower wheel. This causes the belt to not seat as low as I'd like in the lower pulley (seems to sit fine in the upper, fully in the groove without bottoming out). This in turn likely was causing it to slip when under load. Tightening the belt a bit seems to have resolved this, but I'll keep an eye on it. Note that I didn't really tighten it a lot, just enough to get the slack out.. It's still only a 3/4 HP motor, but I think I'm getting all it can provide now at least Thanks again to everyone's input, and let me know if you have any questions about what I'm seeing or what I've done.. Regards, David Quote
wilburpan Posted July 9, 2013 Report Posted July 9, 2013 Glad to hear that you figured it out. Having the belt slip under load sounds like a much more likely cause of your resawing woes than not enough HP. If you want, you can also replace the pulley wheel on either the motor or the bandsaw so you don't have that groove mismatch. It's a pretty easy thing to do. Replacement pulley wheels can be had from http://www.surpluscenter.com for about $10-20, depending on the size you need. You could even take this opportunity to buy a different sized pulley to speed up your FPM a little, which should help your reawing as well. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.