calblacksmith Posted August 14, 2013 Report Posted August 14, 2013 Most here know I am but a lowly novice with wood. My first project has me using the el cheepo Craftsman alum home router table more than I thought I would. Looking over the tools I bought from my uncles estate years ago, a "table" that he had mounted an arbor press to and that I bought has this hole in the center of it. The table is cast iron and is about 3 feet square and sits on a giant cast iron set of legs. There is a set of ways connecting the legs and a block that is mated to them with a threaded rod about 1 1/2" in dia attached. It hit me then that this table was an old shaper! Most of it is still there but the lift mech will take a little work to get operating again. I can't see how the spindle was turned before as there is no place to mount a motor and I have not really looked well at it. I have no use for a shaper that weighs in excess of 500 pounds but with a little imagining and some mill work, I will be able to mount a router motor to the machine and make it a really heavy router table. The bits will be a whole lot less expensive than the giant bits that the machine would need if used as is. I need to buy a router motor for this project. I have 2 Porter Cable 690 motors but at 1.5 hp, they are under powered for what this table will be able to do. I really don't want to use a plunge router here as the lift mech is chain drive and is all there except for the chain, a plunge router would be hard to mount I think. I know that Porter Cable makes a 3.25 hp multi speed motor, is this a good one or should I look for something else? Am I barking up the wrong tree here and the 690 will be OK? Is this a fools errand and should I just cough up the money and buy a ROUTER setup and let this old industrial giant rest in retirement? I will get some pics up when I get the chance to take them. Thanks in advance Quote
rodger. Posted August 14, 2013 Report Posted August 14, 2013 I wish I had a shaper! There must be a good use for that cast iron table top (assuming its flat) if you decide not to use of for a router table. Post a pic, I'm sure there will be lots of ideas generated! As for a router, go for a big unit in a table. I used to use a 2.5 hp unit, and upgraded to a 3.25 HP router. Big difference in power and performance. 1 Quote
dwacker Posted August 14, 2013 Report Posted August 14, 2013 3.25 is the only router motor id put in a table. Shaper cutters can be had for cheap. Id take a shaper over a router any day. Quote
Tom King Posted August 15, 2013 Report Posted August 15, 2013 7518 5-speed. CPO has reman. 7518s for 280 now. If I made cabinets or doors all the time I'd have a shaper too. I've owned shapers before, up to a 7-1/2 hp Onsrud with a feeder that I bought at an auction. They got used so seldom that I ended up selling them.. Someone gave me a cast iron wing for the tablesaw with a router plate. I keep a 1/4" bit in it if I want to make a quick dado in something, but otherwise I don't especially like it either. Dust collection never worked out too good. I have a setup now making window sash that I have 4 router tops setup. I call them router tops because they are neither regular motor up router, or router table. The surface is phenolic bowling alley lane that's about the same thickness as a stock sub base. I mount the router, plunge a 1/2" bit through it. Take that bit out and install the one I'm going to use with the cutter above the top. No dust gets to the motor, and I can build a fence with dust collection that gets 100% of it. We haven't started running parts yet, but test pieces work out perfectly with dust only thrown out slightly at the end of a cut. I do a lot with 7518s. If I do have some raised panel doors to make, it's just for one kitchen once in a while. I'd rather make a few extra passes for those rare occasions than have a shaper sitting there waiting. The big Milwaukee looks like it might have a better depth adjuster, but I've never had my hands on one. That cast iron thing would be too big for me. I just clamp my "tops" to something, and put them away when I'm finished. Quote
dwacker Posted August 15, 2013 Report Posted August 15, 2013 shaper are not just for cabinet doors. There is very few things you can't do with a shaper vs a router table. Even the easiest of operations like rounding edges is cleaner and faster on a shaper. But there is plenty you can do with a shaper that you cant with a router. A router table is an improvised shaper, for the typical shop there is no reason to own a router table if you have a shaper. A router table is only handy for oddball stuff if you own a shaper. Quote
tim0625 Posted August 18, 2013 Report Posted August 18, 2013 tastes great/less filling...... Cal....kinna depends on what you're going to be doing. I have a Makita 1101 in a router table. It's a 2 1/4 HP and does fine for all I need it to but I don't do any work with larger bits. The router will take 1/4 and 1/2 shank bits and for what I use it for, the HP is fine. On the cheap, just buy your router, an aluminum plate, and make yourself a table and fence. I did, it worked fine and when i could afford it, I upgraded to an Incra system. Quote
LoneRider Posted August 21, 2013 Report Posted August 21, 2013 I got a Milwaulkee 2-1/2 HP for my router table. And I have used it a fair bit. Did a lot of MDF milling with a spiral cutter. Good controls, good value. I've played with door set, but have not made a set of cabinets yet. I have it paired with a Rockler branded lift and am EXTREEMLY happy with the combination. I have never had a problem with not enough power. And have used some larger bits. http://www.amazon.com/Milwaukee-5616-20-Max-Horsepower-BodyGrip-Router/dp/B00009LI4L/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1377095524&sr=8-2&keywords=Milwaukee+5616 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.