Recommended Posts

Posted

Most here know I am but a lowly novice with wood. My first project has me using the el cheepo Craftsman alum home router table more than I thought I would.

 

Looking over the tools I bought from my uncles estate years ago, a "table" that he had mounted an arbor press to and that I bought has this hole in the center of it. The table is cast iron and is about 3 feet square and sits on a giant cast iron set of legs. There is a set of ways connecting the legs and a block that is mated to them with a threaded rod about 1 1/2" in dia attached. It hit me then that this table was an old shaper! Most of it is still there but the lift mech will take a little work to get operating again. I can't see how the spindle was turned before as there is no place to mount a motor and I have not really looked well at it.

 

I have no use for a shaper that weighs in excess of 500 pounds but with a little imagining and some mill work, I will be able to mount a router motor to the machine and make it a really heavy router table. The bits will be a whole lot less expensive than the giant bits that the machine would need if used as is.

 

I need to buy a router motor for this project. I have 2 Porter Cable 690 motors but at 1.5 hp, they are under powered for what this table will be able to do. I really don't want to use a plunge router here as the lift mech is chain drive and is all there except for the chain, a plunge router would be hard to mount I think. I know that Porter Cable makes a 3.25 hp multi speed motor, is this a good one or should I look for something else? Am I barking up the wrong tree here and the 690 will be OK? Is this a fools errand and should I just cough up the money and buy a ROUTER setup and let this old industrial giant rest in retirement? I will get some pics up when I get the chance to take them.

 

Thanks in advance :D

Posted

I wish I had a shaper!

There must be a good use for that cast iron table top (assuming its flat) if you decide not to use of for a router table. Post a pic, I'm sure there will be lots of ideas generated!

As for a router, go for a big unit in a table. I used to use a 2.5 hp unit, and upgraded to a 3.25 HP router. Big difference in power and performance.

  • Like 1
Posted

7518  5-speed.  CPO has reman. 7518s for 280 now.   If I made cabinets or doors all the time I'd have a shaper too.  I've owned shapers before, up to a 7-1/2 hp Onsrud with a feeder that I bought at an auction.  They got used so seldom that I ended up selling them..

 

Someone gave me a cast iron wing for the tablesaw with a router plate.  I keep a 1/4" bit in it if I want to make a quick dado in something, but otherwise I don't especially like it either.  Dust collection never worked out too good.

 

I have a setup now making window sash that I have 4 router tops setup.  I call them router tops because they are neither regular motor up router, or router table.  The surface is phenolic bowling alley lane that's about the same thickness as a stock sub base.  I mount the router, plunge a 1/2" bit through it.  Take that bit out and install the one I'm going to use with the cutter above the top.  No dust gets to the motor, and I can build a fence with dust collection that gets 100% of it.  We haven't started running parts yet, but test pieces work out perfectly with dust only thrown out slightly at the end of a cut.

 

I do a lot with 7518s.  If I do have some raised panel doors to make, it's just for one kitchen once in a while.  I'd rather make a few extra passes for those rare occasions than have a shaper sitting there waiting.  The big Milwaukee looks like it might have a better depth adjuster, but I've never had my hands on one.

 

That cast iron thing would be too big for me.  I just clamp my "tops" to something, and put them away when I'm finished.

Posted
:) shaper are not just for cabinet doors. There is very few things you can't do with a shaper vs a router table. Even the easiest of operations like rounding edges is cleaner and faster on a shaper. But there is plenty you can do with a shaper that you cant with a router. A router table is an improvised shaper, for the typical shop there is no reason to own a router table if you have a shaper. A router table is only handy for oddball stuff if you own a shaper.
Posted

tastes great/less filling......

Cal....kinna depends on what you're going to be doing.  I have a Makita 1101 in a router table.  It's a 2 1/4 HP and does fine for all I need it to but I don't do any work with larger bits.  The router will take 1/4 and 1/2 shank bits and for what I use it for, the HP is fine. On the cheap, just buy your router, an aluminum plate, and make yourself a table and fence.  I did, it worked fine and when i could afford it, I upgraded to an Incra system.

Posted

I got a Milwaulkee 2-1/2 HP for my router table. And I have used it a fair bit. Did a lot of MDF milling with a spiral cutter.

 

Good controls, good value. I've played with door set, but have not made a set of cabinets yet. I have it paired with a Rockler branded lift and am EXTREEMLY happy with the combination.

 

I have never had a problem with not enough power. And have used some larger bits.

 

http://www.amazon.com/Milwaukee-5616-20-Max-Horsepower-BodyGrip-Router/dp/B00009LI4L/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1377095524&sr=8-2&keywords=Milwaukee+5616

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.