Recommended Posts

Posted

Of course, I'm thinking of the Lie-Nielsen versions of both tools :)

Seems simple. There are some over lapping functions with both planes. Is one inherently more preferable over the other? I am leaning towards the Skew block plane.

Thoughts? :)

Posted

I have the Rabbet Block Plane from LN, and I love it.  I don't have a skew so I can't comment on them too much.  However, the advantages of the rabbet block plane I see over the skew is that it is not as expensive as the skew, and that it is useable on both sides.  The LA does help with end grain.  The advantage I see with the skews is that it would do better with weird grain and end grain.

Posted

The Skew plane looks good to me because of the fence, and the ability to field panels.

The rabbet plane would need a fence, and still doesn't have the skew. It looks like a wider shoulder plane. I have the medium shoulder plane from LN.

Posted

Have you held the LN skew. Its a pretty big block plane? If your set on LN I'd go with the rabbet block....that is if you are planning to use it for block rabbet plane tasks (e.g. cleaning rabbets and tenons)

 

If you want something for cutting rabbets/fielding panels, then yes you want (though don't need) a fenced rabbet plane.

 

There aren't a lot of times where I'll flat out say go LV over LN but this is one of them, mainly because LN doesn't make a full sized rabbeting plane...and honestly...even if you go with a skew block, the LV really is a better plane.  

 

Now you know I'm a self admitted LV fan boy, but I can't think of any other situation where I would flat out say I think LV is the all around better choice than the LN. But if you want a full sized fenced rabbet plane, LV or vintage are your only options, and if you want a skew block and want to use it for things like fielding panels, the adjustable mouth on the LV skew, in particular, is a feature you want.  Additionally, even if you generally find set screws unnecessary (I generally can live with or w/o them) a skewed rabbeting plane is one place where they are an absolute boon.  This is because when you set a plane for rabbetting you want the leading edge to protrude past the side just a hair, and dialing in just the right protrusion can be a bit fiddly (particularly with a skew blade), so once you get it you want to be able to hold that setting and find it again right away when putting the blade back in for sharpening. 

 

Finally, if you want to use a skew block for 1-handed trimming tasks, the LV skew block is a bit smaller than the LN and VERY VERY comnfortable.  The LN skew block is more the size of the LV regular LABP, perhaps a little bigger, whereas the LV skew block is the size of the LN 60 1/2 and 60 1/2R (BTW I'm not saying that the larger size of the LN skew is inherently a bad thing...in fact, it you plane to use it mostly two-handed for things like sinking rabbets, the size would be advantageous)

 

Now if you just want a plane for cleaning rabbets and cheeks, the 601/2R is great plane, and the fact it is open on two sides can be nice....and of course, if you really want the LN skew block, it will do what you want it to do and I'm sure you'll find it a joy to own.  BUT again, this is one case where the I really believe the LV variety is an objectively superior plane...of course, that's just my opinion and you are free to ignore it....have fun buying a new toy!

 

(BTW my use of these tools....Own the LV Skew Rabbet, Friend owns LV skew block and I have used it in his shop a few times, same friend owns LN Rabbet Block and I have used it in his shop a few times, have only used the LN skew block at shows)

  • Like 2
Posted

I was mainly looking at the skew plane because of its ability to make clean rabbets. I have a Stanley #45 and that does a lot of what I would assume the larger LV tool does. Admittedly not as nicely as the LV.

I use my shoulder plane for trimming my tenons and such. I also use a large LN router plane for shaving tenons when needed. The router plane is pretty versatile. I also use it for dadoes, which is just awesome at.

I'm really not against the LV on this one. After all, the Schwarz said it's the best one. He even said it on a Lie-Nielsen DVD.

Posted

Yeah, router planes are awesome..I love mine...use it for all sorts of stuff.   If you want something for cutting rabbets a full sized rabbeting plane is really the way to go.  You'll still get some tearout and stuff with the LV when you are cutting against the grain while taking heavy cuts, and getting consistent results does take some practice, but if you want a fenced rabbeting plane for sinking rabbets by hand there's not much out there that will beat the full sized LV skew rabbet...the larger size will make it better for hogging out material especially in harder woods.  If you feel you are set for hogging out rabbets with your 45...and want something with a bit more versatility that can still be used to sink rabbet the LV skew block is the way to go.  The adjustable mouth will be worth its weight in gold the first time you are smoothing a fielded panel against the grain, and unless you plan to get 2 skew planes you will be going against the grain 50% of the time (well 50% of the time on long grain...0% of the time on cross grain, so really 25% of the time)

Posted

Let's complicate matters a bit.

 

Lie-Nielsen is coming out with a full size rabbet plane, similar to the LV model. Perhaps I should wait. There are a few other tools on my list that will hold me over. 

Posted

Oh well. Probably won't kill you to own one LV plane....you might even find that you like it  :)

 

Just make sure your keep it in a separate cabinet from your LNs...I believe that keeping LNs and LVs together in the same cabinet poses a severe risk of explosion.

  • Like 2
Posted

Yeah, I have that same issue.  I got several Millers Falls planes a couple months ago and now the fact that my 7 is a Stanley bugs me...not to mention the fact that my 8 is a Sargent.

 

Here's the solutions.  Get rid of your LN router and LN shoulder, and replace them with the LVs...BUT continue to buy LN bench and block planes.  That way if you keep all your joinery planes on one shelf and all your bench planes on another each shelf will have matching planes.   ;)

 

I really do get OCD about that too...I'm learning to ignore it though....this one place where you really would do well to ignore it as well.  If you want to sink rabbets by hand the full size LV skew rabbet is the way to go (though haven't tried the LV BU jack rabbet  :) )

 

I freely admit to having a slight bias towards LV but in this case it really is the best option..LN just doesn't make a comparable plane to the full sized skew rabbet.

Posted

LN makes a Jack Rabbet. :) I think it's overkill for what my intentions are though.

 

I can't get rid of my precious LN planes. Not going to happen!

 

I really love the LN router plane. Some guys love the Veritas version, and I'm sure someone here would be glad to tell me how it's superior in their opinion. :)

 

My OCD really is bad. I want to buy a Bad Axe saw, and I just can't do it. I really want one, but I'd have to replace the LN saws I already have. It's my curse.

 

I have an idea! I can hide the Stanley and (possible) LV planes, and make a better home for my LN planes :) They will have a nice place to live in the Shaker workbench I'm building. I plan on starting this week. Hopefully I can get the base done before the weekend, and then get to the top during the weekend. 

Posted

Yeah jack rabbet is overkill.  

 

Router planes. One brand isn't superior to the other. The LV (which was my very first premium plane) has more blade options,  and a more versatile fence, both of which are nice if you want those features, but if you don't care about those feature there is nothing inherently superior about the LV router or LN router.  The superiority of one equivalent plane over the other lies mostly in the hands of the user. For example, many people will argue that the LV medium shoulder plane is superior to the LN. Well I do have the LV version and having used the medium LN can say I prefer the LV, but they are different planes, that are designed to be gripped differently.  The superior one is the one that is gripped easiest in the way you like to hold/use the plane.  I think the way to grip the LV is more obvious which is why so many people say its ergonomically superior, but if you grip the preston style planes correctly they are actually very ergonomic.  Also, worth noting is the the LV med is a good bit smaller than the LN med..somthing that people often fail to note, which is probably one of the biggest reason why its easier to wield one handed. It really falls right in between the LN 041 and LN 042 in size and in use the LV medium actually feels/handles more the the LN 041.  I'm glad I have the LV and actually don't care much at all for the LN medium (I do really like both the LN smalls), but I would never say that the plane I prefer is universally superior. Again different planes, different size, very different design. 

 

The skew rabbet is another matter though. Just buy it and hide it somewhere.  If LN ever comes out with one then you can sell it and buy the LN. Until then you will have plane that is very very nice to use for rabbetting.  If you really really want the LN I'm sure the skew block will work for cutting rabbets, but I think most people would agree that a larger dedicated plane is superior for that task (regardless of brand)

  • Like 1
Posted

I agree with what you are saying.

 

I think some people get hung up on small details, and fixate on them in order to make their favored brand seem superior. It's all in the hands of the user. In the end, we vote with our dollars. I have been tempted to buy the fancy version of the LV block plane. Ya know, that nice shiney one. :) But, I just don't need it. I am sure there will come a time that after I have all I need, I will buy the things I want. That plane will be on the list. But everyone here knows I am a Lie-Nielsen fan. Hell, I even have the apron :) Having said that, I wouldn't hesitate to buy the LV tool. Sure, there will be some OCD that delays that, and I'm sure there will be an awkward integration (similar to when our dog met our cat). But, as time goes on, they both get petted and just walk by without too much commotion. 

Posted

As far as the OCD goes. I find the first time I use the mismatched tool and see how great it works my worries go away. Same thing with the first ding in a new tool. I'll obsess over it until the next time I put the tool to use...than when I see how great the results are I forget the ding (or mismatch) is there and just smile at how dang good the tools works.

  • Like 1

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.