Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Oil finishing recipes

Featured Replies

  • Author

Sadly the library does not seem to have anything by Charles Neil in it. It does, however, have three Bob Flexener titles - Wood Finishing 101 (which I have checked out), Understanding Wood Finishing (on hold) and, Applying Finished (also on hold). 

 

Ace, do you have any favorite recipes/combinations?

Sadly the library does not seem to have anything by Charles Neil in it. It does, however, have three Bob Flexener titles - Wood Finishing 101 (which I have checked out), Understanding Wood Finishing (on hold) and, Applying Finished (also on hold). 

 

Ace, do you have any favorite recipes/combinations?

 

As far as oil finish goes, nope I keep it simple and it works. I apply General Finishes Seal-A-Cell on items that don't require a lot of protection and General Finishes Arm-R-Seal on items that require a lot of protection, such as tables. 

 

 

-Ace-

Understanding Wood Finishing (on hold)

I think this is the best book of the bunch, because Flexener spends a lot of time explaining the chemistry of the various types of finishes whit out goinginto details. It's the reason why I use Pratt & Lambert 38 now. Even though its 10-20% more expensive than Arm-R-Seal and a lot harder to find, it better because it's an Alkyd/soya formulation vs. Arm-R-Seal that is supposedly either a alkyd/urethane & BLO, or urethane & tung oil formulation. I pretty much avoid general finishes at all costs, because they won't tell you what it really is. The MSDS is a complete joke.

I think this is the best book of the bunch, because Flexener spends a lot of time explaining the chemistry of the various types of finishes whit out goinginto details. It's the reason why I use Pratt & Lambert 38 now. Even though its 10-20% more expensive than Arm-R-Seal and a lot harder to find, it better because it's an Alkyd/soya formulation vs. Arm-R-Seal that is supposedly either a alkyd/urethane & BLO, or urethane & tung oil formulation. I pretty much avoid general finishes at all costs, because they won't tell you what it really is. The MSDS is a complete joke.

 

Hey now....your picking on GF :)  :) If you like the taste of Colonel Sanders chicken and ask them for the recipe which they reply with a no. Are you going to stop eating the Chicken? 

 

-Ace-

I think this is the best book of the bunch, because Flexener spends a lot of time explaining the chemistry of the various types of finishes whit out goinginto details. It's the reason why I use Pratt & Lambert 38 now. Even though its 10-20% more expensive than Arm-R-Seal and a lot harder to find, it better because it's an Alkyd/soya formulation vs. Arm-R-Seal that is supposedly either a alkyd/urethane & BLO, or urethane & tung oil formulation. I pretty much avoid general finishes at all costs, because they won't tell you what it really is. The MSDS is a complete joke.

 

You must be a PC guy.  Mac guys can deal with proprietary formulations and secrecy. :)

 

I agree on flexner's book - the overarching theme is that most finishes are commodity products so don't get caught up in the marketing spin - it is designed to (in his words) "make you think you are getting something special"

 

GF is probably the guiltiest party of this.  Salad Bowl Oil, Arm r Seal, Seal a Cell.   Its like going to a sandwhich shop and ordering the "all american."  Can't they just call it a ham and cheese?  Because that is what it is.  I get pissed off having to read the fine print.

 

But I use GF stuff because its predictable and it works and is not that much more expensive than the alternatives.   Sometimes I mix my own oil/varnish blends with regular old Minwax poly and BLO or Tung Oil and the results seem similar to me - maybe a little nuttier color in the Tung Oil mix.   I would probably save a few dollars mixing my own but I don't go through enough of it to make it matter.  Arm R Seal makes it easy.    Same goes for their stains.  Their thickened stains are super easy to apply and their water base dye stains are all mixed and ready to go.  I have a whole bunch of lockwood powders but by the time I get to finishing the last thing I want to do is get out my kitchen scale and wait 12 hours for the stuff to dissolve. 

 

But I see where you are coming from.  As flexner says, 90% of the frustration in finishing is because manufacturers want  you to believe that their stuff is something other than shellac, lacquer, oil, varnish, or a handful of other standard finishes.  That it is somehow some magical pentrating oil that will get into the cell structure and feed it and nurture and make it impervious to life's harsh realities.  Heck, if that were the case I'd start drinking the stuff :)

If you like the taste of Colonel Sanders chicken and ask them for the recipe which they reply with a no. Are you going to stop eating the Chicken?

I'm not sure about this analogy, I can reproduce generals chicken in my kitchen, I can't do that with a finish, I'd need a small chemical plant to do that.

 

GF is probably the guiltiest party of this.  Salad Bowl Oil, Arm r Seal, Seal a Cell.   Its like going to a sandwhich shop and ordering the "all american."  Can't they just call it a ham and cheese?  Because that is what it is.  I get pissed off having to read the fine print.

I can deal with the marketing hype, it's the fine print that gets to me, check the msds

http://generalfinishes.com/sites/default/files/file_downloads/MSDS-GF-Arm-R-Seal-080808.pdf

it's 35 - 70% MS, 1% Trimethylbenzene and then everything else is Proprietary. I'll never understand why companies do this, the end user isn't going to steel the formula because they have no means to produce it themselves, and any competitor can send a can to their lab and figure out whats in it. As far as I can see the only thing not telling the consumer does is annoy the informed consumers.

O well back to writing php/js/mysql code on my PC.  :D

Search google for "Dave knifed rude crude". He posted a number of years ago on a recipe and process. I've used it many times and am happy with the results. Not recommended for things that need a lot of protection though.

Adam

Search google for "Dave knifed rude crude". He posted a number of years ago on a recipe and process. I've used it many times and am happy with the results. Not recommended for things that need a lot of protection though.

Adam

 

No results found for "Dave knifed rude crude".

 

I found "Knipfer Rude and Crude" which is about using shellac as a sealer coat, no oil recipe mentioned other than Sam Maloof's.

Autocorrect changed Knipfer into knifed. There are posts out there with the recipe...I remember reading them, and posting commentary back to Dave. I haven't searched for them in a few years so I wonder if they aged out from the original website - woodworking.org.

The recipe was 3 items in equal parts - an oil, a poly, and .... I'll see if I can dig it out. I wrote it down at least 5 yrs ago. Might have it around here somewhere.

Adam

Found it in a drawer..basically what you have already read...start with a shellac seal coat and then follow with a Maloof style topcoat - Tung oil, BLO, and poly - all in equal parts.

Adam

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,011 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • bobtjanitor Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.