Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Oil finishing recipes

Featured Replies

So in preparation for my first finishing job I’ve been doing some research and I’ve come up with three potential recipes to use. I’ve got three ideas so far, but the first two are from Fine Woodworking, and I’m nervous that they may be harder than the articles let on. In no particular order, the three recipes are:

 

1-Apply 2-3 liberal coats of oil (linseed or tung), waiting two days between coats; wait two days, then apply and buff a wax coat

 

2-‘Wet’ (don't flood) the surface with BOL; while oil is still wet, wipe on a coat of amber shellac (thinned to a 5:2 shellac:alcohol mix); wait 24hrs and apply paste wax using 0000 steel wool

 

3-Alternatively, I was thinking I could simply apply a couple coats of Danish oil or varnish oil, then use a coat of clear varnish to protect the wood afterwards

 

How durable are these recipes? More importantly, how difficult are they? (re: how easy is it for me to screw up)? It's going on white ash. 

#1 is easy to do but won't be very durable. plan on reapplying every year or so.

#2 is probably the most difficult (but doable for a beginning) and will be more durable than #1. water will leave marks and hard alcohol will damage the finish. it will be a little more difficult to refinish that # 1 but not much.

#3 is the most durable and in my experience easier to apply than #2.

Is this for you Ash table? Ash is a lot like oak and wont take color real well unless you dye or stain. However, if you want natural. Use a good drying oil such as General Finishes Arm-R-Seal that has good solids. Solids will give you the extra protection for your table. 

 

Take some scraps and try various methods. 

 

-Ace-

  • Author

It's for the ash table. I think it looks pretty good already, so I don't feel a need to make any radical colour changes. I'm going to Lee Valley tomorrow to grab a couple of items and see if anyone on staff has finishing advice. Looking at the catalog I see Tried & True Danish oil and Arm-R-Seal on the same page.

 

I am thinking three coats of oi, followed by a coat of Arm-R-Seal (and possibly a second coat for the tabletop itself). Thoughts?

If you like the wood as it is now? No color use a waterbased clear topcoat. An oil will make the ash an amber tone. To the above question. Yes you can. Just make sure the danish oil has had a week, maybe two to dry (longer the better) before you topcoat with ARM-R-Seal. Follow the directions on the can of Arm-R-Seal. I usually apply 3 coats. That gives you a good build of solids for protection.

 

-Ace- 

If you don't want to wait as long for the oil to dry, you can try some walnut oil. Every time I have used it - it dries within the day. I have left it in the sun to speed the drying process with no ill effects. It depends on how much you use, so if you are to top coat it, just make very sure that it is dry!! Certainly no more than 2-3 days if you applied a light coat.

  • Author

To clarify, I like the colour, but feel that it will look better with some sort of oil on it to make the wood stand out. As is in my living room it feels light but dull (if that makes sense). 

Do you need to sand in between apply coats of oil and/or Arm-R-Seal?

1. Very easy, takes a long time

2. Very easy and you don't have to be particular with the DNA/shellac ratio. The oil makes the shellac easier to apply (I just suggested this in another thread actually). Shellac is plenty durable for a tabletop if you use coasters and take care of your furniture. I have 3 end tables topped with shellac that are over a decade old. A drunk relative slopped a mixed drink on one once but it was an easy repair job; otherwise they've held up just fine. 

3. The most work, takes about as long as #1, fumes for days, but is also the most durable. You'll need to sand between coats.

 

BTW, which issue of Fine Woodworking has that article?

On #2, They are making the process far to complicated.  Mix the Oil, Shellac, and DNA together and simply apply all at once.  Just mix them on a 1:1:1 ratio.  Apply liberally, wiping away the excess that isn't absorbed in a minute or so.  Let dry for +30 minutes, and re-coat with mixture.  This coat should absorb very little of the solution.  Once dry (~2 hours), apply wax, however you prefer to do so.  You can do it with steel wool, or a cloth, or high grit sandpaper.  Let the wax setup (<1 hour) and buff, reapply, and rebuff to desired sheen.

1. Very easy, takes a long time

2. Very easy and you don't have to be particular with the DNA/shellac ratio. The oil makes the shellac easier to apply (I just suggested this in another thread actually). Shellac is plenty durable for a tabletop if you use coasters and take care of your furniture. I have 3 end tables topped with shellac that are over a decade old. A drunk relative slopped a mixed drink on one once but it was an easy repair job; otherwise they've held up just fine. 

3. The most work, takes about as long as #1, fumes for days, but is also the most durable. You'll need to sand between coats.

 

BTW, which issue of Fine Woodworking has that article?

 

Here is the FWW article.  http://www.finewoodworking.com/how-to/article/one-fast-finish.aspx

  • Author

The book I have from the library is "Best Finishing Techniques" by Fine Woodworking. Sadly, it does not list the issues he articles are from. However, finishes 1 & 2 are respectively entitled "An Oil-and-Wax Finish" by Charles Shackleton, and "One Fast Finish" by Jeff Jewitt. Recipe #3 was something I proposed based on my reading of the above book, as well as "Wood Finishing 101" by Bob Flexner. 

At Lee Valley, I talked to a couple of staff about finishing. The one who knew what he was talking about sold me on General FInishes Gel Top Coat. It's a labeled as 'wipe on urethane' (is there any practical difference between urethane and polyurethane??). That said, I know granddad has a some BOL kicking around, so I will test the scraps with the Gel Top Coat, and Gel top coat-over-BOL before I make any final decisions.

Ummmm....the General Ginishes Gel Topcoat is a thin finish and wont offer much, if any protection. If your were coating a picture frame or something that sits on a shelf.Then  Its a very good finish for that.

 

Your table requires more protection in my book. The Gel topcoat gets wiped on and then needs to be wiped off. Thus leaving very little solids behind for protection. Rob towards the end of the video even says it!

 

Here is a link from General Finishes.

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0HPvbE592Bg 

 

-Ace-

Doomwolf

check out My end tables.

http://www.dans-hobbies.com/2013/10/18/the-end-of-end-tables/

I used to following finishing regime.

1. sanding the surface with 120, 180, 220 grit sandpaper.

2. One coat of boiled linseed oil wet sanded into the surface with 400 grit wet/dry sandpaper.

4. four coats of satin Pratt & Lambert 38 thinned with 50% mineral spirits so it can be wiped on.

5. wet sanded with 1500 grit Mirlon to remove dust nibs.

6. four more coats of the thinned P&L.

7. another round of wet sanding with 1500 grit Mirlon.

8. One coat of natural Liberon Black Bison wax.

I think it's pretty much what you're looking for. It's and oil to pop and warm the grain, and a good varnish to protect it.

Doomwolf

check out My end tables.

http://www.dans-hobbies.com/2013/10/18/the-end-of-end-tables/

I used to following finishing regime.

1. sanding the surface with 120, 180, 220 grit sandpaper.

2. One coat of boiled linseed oil wet sanded into the surface with 400 grit wet/dry sandpaper.

4. four coats of satin Pratt & Lambert 38 thinned with 50% mineral spirits so it can be wiped on.

5. wet sanded with 1500 grit Mirlon to remove dust nibs.

6. four more coats of the thinned P&L.

7. another round of wet sanding with 1500 grit Mirlon.

8. One coat of natural Liberon Black Bison wax.

I think it's pretty much what you're looking for. It's and oil to pop and warm the grain, and a good varnish to protect it.

Dan, the end tables are amazing, great design and color. Eight coats of varnish though.... How long did it take to dry between coats? At what coat did you stop seeing any change in depth of finish?

Dan, how long did that take to accomplish?

it depended on my schedule, as I finished different parts at different times. I let the BLO dry for 2-3 days before applying the varnish, and 6 hours between each varnish coat. I then let it dry for a week before the last sanding. You could probably get it done in a week excluding the final sanding and waxing, but a week and a half is a lot more realistic I think.

  • Author

Sorry for keeping radio silence the past couple days, things have been busy.

I am going ahead and using just the Gel Topcoat on the table. In my defence, I am using the argument I saw on a different forum that can be summarized as "if it looks good, do it", and it does, so I will. Worst case scenario, I learn how to refinish, which is a useful skill in and of itself. 

That said, I am filing the various recipe suggestions away for future projects, so please don't feel like you've wasted your breath. 

Sorry for keeping radio silence the past couple days, things have been busy.

I am going ahead and using just the Gel Topcoat on the table. In my defence, I am using the argument I saw on a different forum that can be summarized as "if it looks good, do it", and it does, so I will. Worst case scenario, I learn how to refinish, which is a useful skill in and of itself. 

That said, I am filing the various recipe suggestions away for future projects, so please don't feel like you've wasted your breath. 

 

Rock on brother...I like your style!

 

-Ace-

Sorry for keeping radio silence the past couple days, things have been busy.

I am going ahead and using just the Gel Topcoat on the table. In my defence, I am using the argument I saw on a different forum that can be summarized as "if it looks good, do it", and it does, so I will. Worst case scenario, I learn how to refinish, which is a useful skill in and of itself. 

That said, I am filing the various recipe suggestions away for future projects, so please don't feel like you've wasted your breath. 

 

Good for you.  Seems a lot of people fall into the "no pain, no gain" finishing trap.  It is one of those rabbit holes where you can spend 90% of your effort getting a result that is 5% better.   Whenever I hear the term "finish recipe" I think "over complicated."  For hand applied finishes, a few coats of arm r seal or BLO then poly will get you a great looking finish that is almost foolproof.   I am sure the gel top coat will look just fine.   It might not be as durable as other finishes, but the less build you put on something the easier it is to refresh.  in a year you might just need to scuff sand and and recoat.  That is not so bad.  

  • Author

Rock on brother...I like your style!

 

-Ace-

As in, "the less time I spend on finishing the more time I can spend on fun stuff"? I'll take that as a compliment.  

Someone earlier in this thread mentioned a 1:1:1 mix of oil, shellac, and mineral spirits. I think I will try that one out, but down the road on something built to higher standards. Not that the table is poorly made, but, it's the first time I did any sort of joinery, so I do not expect it to outlast me. 

As in, "the less time I spend on finishing the more time I can spend on fun stuff"? I'll take that as a compliment.  

Someone earlier in this thread mentioned a 1:1:1 mix of oil, shellac, and mineral spirits. I think I will try that one out, but down the road on something built to higher standards. Not that the table is poorly made, but, it's the first time I did any sort of joinery, so I do not expect it to outlast me. 

 

Yes that was a compliment!!!!!!

 

Hey man its all about the journey. Finishing isn't really that difficult. That's a nice table you built. You can handle finishing. Sometimes you have to push yourself. If you have a few hard earned dollars in the beer fund? Check out the new book by Charles Neil on finishing. I think the "looks good is good" thing is him.  ;)

 

-Ace-

Someone earlier in this thread mentioned a 1:1:1 mix of oil, shellac, and mineral spirits. 

 

Oil, shellac and denatured alcohol. It's used in turning for things that don't need a lot of wear resistance.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,009 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Joseph b Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.