Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Staining a hard wood maple mantle

Featured Replies

I recently order an unfinished hard wood maple fireplace mantel with the intent of staining it the same color as some recently installed cabinets.  Rather than trying to color match the stain, I went ahead and purchased a quart of the cabinet stain directly from the cabinet manufacture.  To my surprise they sent me a quart of solvent-based "NGR" (non-grain raising based on internet searches) and a quart of solvent-based "Wipe Stain", with directions stating that I should let the NGR dry for 5 minutes before applying the Wipe Stain.  Additionally, the mantle manufacture strongly suggested that I treat the maple mantle with wood conditioner prior to applying stain in order to mitigate blotching.  Would you happen to know:
 
(a) Is "NGR" considered a conditioner, in which case my steps would be: (1) sand, (2) "NGR", (3) "Wipe stain", (4) sand sealer, and (5) lacquer.  Or should I still use a condition prior to the"NGR" application, in which case my steps would be (1) sand, (2) conditioner, (3) NGR, (4) "Wipe stain", (5) sand sealer, and (6) lacquer.
 
(B)  If "NGR" is not conditioner, do I need a conditioner that is specifically compatible with the solvent-based NGR and solvent-based Wipe Stain that they sent me?  Do you have any recommendations?
 
I really appreciate any clarity you could provide given that I'm a novice at this with only one shot at staining the hard wood mantle and I can't seem to get any solid answers from the internet or the manufactures.

First, get yourself some scrap to practice on... With alcohol-based dyes, you get one shot at this...

 

Maple is notoriously hard to color to a specific tone... so practice practice practice until you get to what you want. Also, manage your expectations -- it's very difficult to match existing...

 

Are the cabinets also maple? If the cabinets are not maple, there is almost no hope to match them without a great deal of trial and error...

 

NGRs are almost always alcohol-based metal complex dyes. They dry incredibly rapidly. Unlike stains, a second coat of NGR dye will darken the wood. The combo of traits means that pros almost always apply NGRs with a spray gun to get it onto the wood quickly, then wipe-back with a staining-pad.

 

The reason he recommends a conditioner is (most likely) to even-out/mute/control the application of the dye. The trick is to work from bottom-up to prevent drips/runs creating darker-regions.

 

There are many ways to 'condition' the maple. The easiest is to pre-wipe the surface with denatured alcohol, then apply the dye.

 

One thing, fireplace mantles are a rather highly-visible item to DIY if you don't have the experience. For this one, you may want to hire a pro. NGRs are one of the few things to penetrate Maple -- if you screw-the-pooch, there is not much recourse. 

 

Good luck --- and did I mention practice? :)

Do not sand maple too fine a grit before staining. Maybe stop at 150 grit. If I use an orbital sander I hand sand with the grain before staining.

NGR, when wiped on will show rag marks when you stop. It's best when sprayed to produce an even colour. I would like to know if using a condition will help even out the color with NGR.

And wear gloves with a NGR lol. Won't come off for a while. ;)

You need to determine if the stain your calling ngr is a lacquer stain before doing anything. If it is that would be your equalizer or wood conditioner if you want to call it that. BUT it will have to be sprayed because they use solid pigments not dyes.

==>lacquer stain...your equalizer

That's a good point. I completely forgot about lacquer-based as an equalizer. Cabinet shops may well do that - I rarely think along the lines of a pro cabinet shop... Since lacquer-equalizer would have to be sprayed, doubt they'd send it to an end-user without asking, but you never know... Good catch.

==>lacquer stain...your equalizer

That's a good point. I completely forgot about lacquer-based as an equalizer. Cabinet shops may well do that - I rarely think along the lines of a pro cabinet shop... Since lacquer-equalizer would have to be sprayed, doubt they'd send it to an end-user without asking, but you never know... Good catch.

 

Its usually the opposite. Most of us send out exactly what we used and it is assumed that you either know what your doing or hired a trim finisher that does. I send out a bunch of extra finish for trim finishers but never go through the trouble of educating them on how to use it. 

I can help..But alot of typing  lets have a phone chat,   Email me   Charles@charlesneilwoodworking.com ... be glad to help, then you can do all the typing :D

 

BTW ..NGR means its an alcohol based dye ( well sorta) , then they do a stain over it, large manufactures do this all the time, because they typically use "less than" furniture grade woods. Not to say the wood is not sound and solid, many use "soft maple", and so forth , then use a sprayed base dye to establish a base color, then a stain.. . Ever noticed how you see commercial furniture and cabinets labeled  "cherry finish",  "oak finish", etc,. They didn't say it WAS cherry or oak, but it was finished to look like it .

  • Author

Thanks to everyone for all advice and guidance thus far, it has been tremndously helpful and enlightening.  I'm quickly realizing that I may be in well over my head on this "DIY" project.  Here are answers to the questions posed in the various posts thus far:

- Both the cabinets and the unfinished mantel are maple

- The mantel manufacturer did include 5 unfinished pieces of the maple to play with...so I have to practice wisely!
- The mantel and cabinets are in the same room, along the same wall about 4 feet apart
- I attempted several times to clarify with the cabinet manufactuer what there "NGR" actually is; on one phone call I was told it was a "solve-based sanding sealer" and on  another phone call I was told it was  a "solvent-based conditioner"...hence why I am now completely confused and reaching out to the Wood Talk exports!  The cans that the NGR and Wipe Stain came in did not include any useful labels about their chemical makeup.

- Thanks for the offer Charles, I will certainly send you an email to discuss further.

Thanks again!

Give it a sniff if it smells like lacquer thinner or acetone its lacquer stain and explains the conditioner statements. If it smells like alcohol its dye and not a conditioner. Or check for sinking solids lacquer stain will have pigments that settle out. Is this a dark color or is it closer to natural? Who is the cabinet manufacturer.?

I gave it a sniff and it definitely smells like alcohol, so that answers that one!  Thanks.  Hey Charles, is Charles@charlesneilwoodworking.com the best address to reach you at?

It likely just dye.

What's the chance of carrying the mantle to the cabinetmaker that finished the cabinets, and get them to spray the mantle?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,009 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Joseph b Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.