Recommended Posts

Posted

What are you going to sharpen? Turning tools, plane plades or axes? ;-)

Stumpy Nubs has a video for enhancing the capabilities of a Worksharp 3000. My Worksharp showed up yesterday and I will be starting my build in a few days. I can buy a lot of wood for the difference in price.

BRuce

Posted

Hi WW. I have toyed with the idea of a Tormec but for me I find a Veritas MK2 honing jig, some self adhesive sandpaper of varying grits, a slab of granite and a few Japanese water stones suffice. Chisels and plane irons are very easy to hone and touch up. I have a bench grinder for lathe tools and a few slipstones to hone them.

All for much less than the outlay for T7, T5 or even a T3

Posted

==>Are tormeks systems really worth the hefty pricetag?

Depends on what you want to sharpen...

 

As I keep saying, ask 10 woodworkers about sharpening and you'll get 11 answers... :)

 

Some folks swear by the Tormek and use it for establishing a primary bevel, secondary honing, polishing -- i.e. anything and everything sharpening... For them, the Tormek is the bee's knees... There are quite a few in this camp as indicated by two decades of robust sales...

 

Some folks use it to establish a primary bevel only and use some other method for secondary honing and touch-up (myself included). I like a hollow-grind primary bevel -- it makes freehand touch-up very very quick.

 

Some folks give it a whirl and think it's too slow for their needs... I was in this camp and about to sell mine, then they introduced a Japanese waterstone wheel for the unit... The speed improved dramatically, but it's still slow for my liking. I suspect a diamond wheel is in the works, that may cure Tormek's speed issue completely...

 

In terms of 'value'... It's hard to say -- the unit is well made and would last you basically forever. You might have to buy a new wheel every five years, but that's about it...

 

I'd spend some time on Ron Hock's Sharpening Blog: http://hocktools.wordpress.com/ -- all things sharpening in one place . 

 

There's a new thread on sharpening:  that hopefully more folks will add to.

Posted

I have one and it just sits in a box most of the time. But when I do use it I sharpen moulder knives and it the greatest thing since sliced bread. It only does euro knives which I didn't know when I bought it so I have to do corrugated knives on a sheet of glass. Other than that I never sharpen anything else so can't comment on its other uses.

Posted

So many methods to choose from!

I'm leaning towards getting a whetstone grinder, mainly due to the amount of time I've spent sharpening chisels and planer blades after hours of using hardwoods.

So with that in mind, surely in terms of time saving, meaning more productivity during the day, I should opt for a powered atone rather than some oilstones and a honing guide which I'm using at the moment?

Cheers for the informative posts as ever guys :)

~WW

Posted

==> So with that in mind, surely in terms of time saving, meaning more productivity during the day, I should opt for a powered atone rather than some oilstones and a honing guide which I'm using at the moment?

 

Well, oil stones are slow -- it's perhaps their biggest drawback. But don't count them out -- my father uses a set of per-war Arkansas stones and he loves them... And many woodworkers agree...

 

Don't assume because a method adds power, it's faster... Something like a Tormek is faster than oil stones, but certainly slower than ceramic water stones. If they come-up with a Chosera 1K Tormek Wheel, it would become my system of choice -- but the wheel alone would probably cost a grand...

 

One thing, if you really do need to do a lot of sharpening, then something like a Tormek with a water stone wheel may be useful. You can batch-sharpen an entire set of chisels without any hand fatigue... Another point -- Tormek is 'idiot proof' (almost). When I use High Schoolers for cheap shop labor, one job I give them is 'sharpening-slave'... Even with no experience, they can master the Tormek after a few minutes... That's a big benefit for me... and probably why I still keep the unit around...

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

I don't have a whetstone grinder and have often wondered whether they would be beneficial to me. I do have a high speed dry grinder which I use with an aluminium oxide grinding wheel to hollow grind my blades. I then use a Veritas Mk1 honing guide on water stones to sharpen the blade.

 

What I have found is that (once I learned how to use the dry grinder) I spend most of my time using the water stones rather then the grinder and rarely have to go back to the grinder to re-establish the hollow grind. Now since I'm a hobbyist this works quite well for me, and at this time I don't feel the need to get a whetstone grinder. Your mileage may vary. 

 

I hope this helps  :)

Posted

==>I spend most of my time using the water stones rather then the grinder and rarely have to go back to the grinder to re-establish the hollow grind..... Your mileage may vary.

+2 ... That's a very good point...

 

Assuming the woodworker uses a hollow-grind for the primary bevel and stones for the hone, most hobbyists will only need a grinder occasionally. With many tools, you can re-hone five+ times before re-grinding -- so for a hobbyist, that translates to very occasional use. In this case, investing in one of the high-end systems is more of a luxury than a necessity...

 

But... Even if a hand-tool user doesn't desire a hollow-ground primary bevel, they do need access to a grinder of some sort -- high-speed, low-speed, wet, dry, powered, hand-crank -- really doesn't matter -- but something... Grinding an 8" radius on a jack plane iron using stones would take hours; re-establishing an edge after dropping an A2 chisel on the concrete floor with stones is just too painful to think about; etc...

 

So you can get an inexpensive bench grinder on eBay for $30 and $50 for a Norton wheel and have at it... That being said, some folks do the opposite and dive into systems like Tormek with both feet and never get a single stone. With all the attachments, you can sharpen just about anything you want... The 'single system' approach isn't for me, but it isn't wrong either... If folks tend to 'batch-sharpen' a bunch of tools at once, then something like Tormek may well fit their needs...

 

Some of the newer dry systems with slow-speed diamond wheels look very attractive... If I didn't already have a Tormek, that's probably the direction I'd go...

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   2 Members, 0 Anonymous, 39 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined