kevin Posted March 26, 2014 Report Posted March 26, 2014 I have been using 12 ½" delta lunch box planer and 6" jet jointer for years. I'm sick of the limitations. I was looking at Rikon 12" combo with carbide cutters. I have talked with other people and have been told stick with two machines less hassle switching over. Is anybody using the combo machine and do you like it and would you buy the same thing or separate machines? Quote
Trip Posted March 26, 2014 Report Posted March 26, 2014 Over the past decade or so, I've switched between individual stationary power tools and combo units -- twice... To go combo, there are some pretty-important considerations: First things first, you have to purchase a quality unit. Combo units are more complex, have more parts and more can go wrong than their purpose-made stand-alone brethren... Many of the parts on combo machines are purpose-made. Worst case: twenty years from now you can go to a machine shop and have just about any part for a stand-alone joiner fabricated for a reasonable cost (or purchase a used unit for parts).... However, some of the parts on combo units would cost quite a bit to have custom fabricated. So after end-of-life, that shiny new combo unit could simply become a paperweight if the wrong parts go. Which brings-up to service life… Mfg’s keep products for a given market life, then provide parts and service for a given number of years (service life). For some brands, it’s three years, for many more its five and top-shelf kit it’s twenty-five. Again, if the wrong part breaks after service-life.... it’s the machine shop or the scrap yard… Along with service life, service response is critical... At some point, something will break... Whatever brand you purchase, the mfg must have a sizable US parts depot. True story: Had a Euro bandsaw for three years and a key component failed. No problem, it’s got a five-year warranty. Called and placed the part order, no problem… A couple of weeks go by and no part – so I call and was told, “It’ll be three months before the part is made”… You know, the expletive f*ck can be used as a noun, verb, adverb, adjective and just about any other part of English language syntax that you care to mention*… Side note: The mag reviewers never address long-term quality/reliability/etc of combo units... They mention, almost in passing, that the inherent complexity makes combo units more prone to failure, and then spend the remainder of the review highlighting which unit is the quickest to change-over. Along with quality, service response is critical... At some point, something will break... Whatever brand you purchase, the mfg must have a sizable US parts depot. The second most important factor in considering combo is organization/workflow. Individual stationary tools facilitate a more organic workflow. An efficient workflow with a Combo requires planning and binning operations into discrete batches... If you're the kind of guy who thinks-through the workflow before putting steel to wood, then you'll be OK in a combo world… However, if you're the kind of guy who walks into a shop and just starts milling away, then a combo unit will drive you crazy... *Side note: there is a great scene from "The Wire" where an entire conversation is held between the two lead characters as they reconstruct a crime scene that had been previously analyzed (incorrectly, as it happens) by earlier detectives... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LN5eYFH8HZ8 Also, The Wire is a great series, if you didn't catch it the first time around... Quote
Chuck Melton Posted March 27, 2014 Report Posted March 27, 2014 I've been researching a combo machine to put on my medium-term purchase list. In my case, I just don't have a lot of shop space, so I am drawn to not having another machine. The Hammer combo machines look great, but I'd probably look harder at the Grizzly to make sure I'd be able to service it. It's also over $1,000 cheaper. Quote
goodsh Posted March 28, 2014 Report Posted March 28, 2014 I just got the Rikon 12" (straight blades). I haven't used it enough to really say a lot about it. Probably have only run about 30 - 50 board feet through it. Hopefully over the next week or two I'll have a lot more time with it. So far I am pretty happy with it. Getting great results on walnut and hard maple with no tear out and no snipe at all. The fence is tough to set (but I've never set another one so maybe it's no worse than any jointer fence would be). The fence on mine is not perfectly flat (has a 0.006" curve along the length) which I was a little concerned with. I called Rikon after setting it up and right away they said if there was any issues after testing it out they'd replace it. I edge jointed a number of boards for a panel glue up and the results were perfectly square and the glue up went great. The curve doesn't seem to affect the results at all (at least not with 3' long boards, I need to test out some longer boards). The tables were flat and co-planer from the store with no need for any adjustments. Checking with a straight edge the worst spot I could fit a feeler gauge in was .003" Of course the Veritas aluminum straight edge I use is accurate to .003" so within the tolerances of my measuring tools the results are basically perfect. I was getting a tiny bow in the boards I jointed (maybe .005" in the middle) but I've never had a jointer and that was my first time using one. After doing some research I'm pretty sure it's my technique and I haven't had a chance to try it again yet. Can't really say much more about it at this point but I will I'll do a detailed review once I have used it more. I got it because it was in the price range, available locally (I'm in Canada with very limited local tool suppliers) and I have limited space so a combo machine is perfect. In my opinion the complaints about the hassle of changeovers is totally overblown. It doubt it takes me 30 seconds to change it over. If you joint everything first and then plane it is not a big deal at all. You have one change over and it takes 30 seconds. I don't know what there is to complain about. For that matter I also don't understand why woodworking magazines always make a big deal out of it and use a stop watch to compare different machines as if saving 5 or 10 seconds on a changeover has meaningful benefit. If I'm in the shop for a couple of hours and have to change back and forth a few times it's still never going to take more than a few minutes. I suppose if you don't plan anything at all and just do one board at a time as you need it then it might be a pain but it's really not that hard to accommodate the small amount of planning it takes so I'd say that for all of the benefits of the combo machine the changeover issue is trivial. The combo machine is great for saving space but even more than that I love having a 12" jointer! I've already used 10" of that capacity with boards I would otherwise have had to do by hand, with a jointer sled or some other work-around method. Sweet! I see that as the biggest benefit. Most people are never going to have 12" of jointing capacity if they have separate machines. Quote
Marco Divetta Posted March 29, 2014 Report Posted March 29, 2014 Here in Europe those combos are a lot more common. I have my elecktra beckum for over ten years and I've never had a problem http://www.dbkeighley.co.uk/masters/hc260.htm it's a bit smaller than the one your looking at but similar in ways. In this model I have to remove the out feed table for the changeover and it only takes a minute but it gets annoying if I have to do it a few times a day, but so would rolling out two separate machines.The setup and alignment can be a bit time consuming and awkward aswel but I've only had to do a full alignment ( blades, outfeed table, infeed table, planer bed, infeed roller, outfeed roller and chip breaker ) twice since I have it and I've put a lot of wood through it. I found recently that a lot of these machines are made the same with standard parts for example the cutter head and blades in my machine are the same in two others ( metabo and kitty ) these machine are practically identical and I can use parts from any of them. I think this is true of the bigger machines aswel, if you look at the similar models from the various manufacturers you'll find that they are quiet similar, you'll obviously be voiding any guaranties if doing this. Like I said before combo machines are very common here so I'm quiet comfortable with them and I can't complain about this machine after such a long service.... If I were to replace it I think it would just come down to size price and quality with a respected brand, the fact that it's a combo would be more of a plus for me personally. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.