emrhappy Posted May 12, 2014 Report Posted May 12, 2014 I recently acquired an Oneida 2 stage dust collection system at an estate sale. I currently have a HF single stage dust collector. The HF is 2HP and the Oneida has a 1.5 HP Lesson Motor. Obviously the Leeson is a better quality motor, but the HF is 2HP instead of 1.5HP. I got the oneida primarily for the plethora of 4/5 and 6" metal piping, blast gates and the 2 stage setup. I'm thinking about taking the 2HP motor off the HF and putting it on the Oneida if it performs better... I have a digital anemometor and got the following CFM results off the HF: (converted from MPH cause I can't get the dang anemometor to set on CFM). Freshly cleaned, no cake (yet) 5 micron bag at unit 97 mph with 2.375 radius = 1050 CFM - No hoses attached. (1550 CFM... Yeah, Right! They're all liars!!) one blast gate open and a 10' flex hose - 76 mph with 2.0625 radius = 620.68 CFM two blast gates open and two 10' flex hoses open - 60 mph with 2.0625 radius = 490.01 CFM I'm going to check the Leeson with the same conditions and see which one performs better. I would expect the Oneida, but like I said above, I think they all exaggerate and it is .5 less HP. Another thing about the Oneida is it has the internal filter instead of external and I think that hurts the CFM as well. Anyone know if I could simply switch the motors? Put the HF motor on the Oneida setup? Quote
wtnhighlander Posted May 13, 2014 Report Posted May 13, 2014 Check this before you worry too much about the HP of your dust collector:Building a dust collector blower: Quote
emrhappy Posted May 13, 2014 Author Report Posted May 13, 2014 yeah... I've seen that before. I guess the only reason to add HP is if you add a larger impeller. The larger the impeller, the more air you move, but you have to have more HP to move larger impellers. I wonder how much CFM he's getting off that 4" hose?! Dude is a freakin' genius. Quote
Trip Posted May 13, 2014 Report Posted May 13, 2014 You need to be a bit careful about electric motor HP. Unfortunately, it's become somewhat of a Marketing spec --- Ie. More HP is 'better' than less, so folks can get a bit 'creative' in spec methodology. Looking at the plate on the motor housing will give you a better baseline. You'll get service rating, kw, etc. you may find that one person's 2HP is another's 1.5HP. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.