Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

getting dark maple

Featured Replies

i am trying to make a maple vanity.  i wanted it as dark brown as possible.  after various research i put down a coat of shellac. ( i could not find dewaxed at first) then i used dark walnut gel stain. the test board turned out okay though i would have preferred a little darker.  the next day prepped all the pieces with the shellac.  when i then tried to apply the gel stain, it simply would not take, and was very hard to rub off.  i have since found the bullseye sealcoat.  i have tried going over the shellac first,  scraping off the shellac and then the sealcoat, and even went back to bare wood.  other than my test board i have had mixed success.  my question is would i be more successful if i switched to a dye such as by general finishes and if so, how should i prepare the boards that have shellac already on them? scrape? sand? sealcoat.   

 

thank you

Welcome to the forums..

 

My first question would be why not start with walnut if that's what you're going for?

 

As for the dyes, I'll leave that for someone with much more experience than I for that.

Welcome to the forum .  You can use either the gel stain or dye . Dye stain is thinner so i will go deeper into the pores of the wood . Where gels are thicker and sit on top .  I don't seal wood first , many people use shellac or bullseye seal coat ( which is just a thinned down shellac ) to control the blotch that maple is known for . However as you found out doing this doesn't let the stain get deep enough to give you much of a color change .   Try forgoing the shellac and just use either the gel or dye stain on the bare wood . I get blotching but just blend  the light areas into the surrounding areas .  Then depending on your top coat you may want to lock that stain in with a coat of shellac .

I'm not sure if you have the ability to spray but that is the trick to staining maple dark without blotching. I would use a dye stain and spray it on without allowing it to get wet on the surface. (This is what causes the blotching as the softer wood absorbs the stain more) Multiple light coats until you get the color you want and it also makes it easier to keep it even. As you found out a wash coat of any kind hinders the stain penetration making it very difficult to get a dark color with out glazing or toning. For open pore wood you spray dye stain on very wet and for blotch prone wood you apply an even more dry application. This is difficult to describe so I have made a video demonstrating the technique.

 

  • Author

1. thanks for the welcome and the prompt replies

2.  i had ready access to maple. found out later my wife wanted very dark brown.

3.  all though will be a bit of work, i will try to  scrape off the shellac and then dye over bare and re sanded wood. 

The shellac should dissolve in alcohol.  That will save a lot of scraping.  The first piece I made with maple was a very large poster sized picture frame.  I wanted it a warm chestnut brown and it was a PITA getting it a color I liked and getting it even.  

 

My best results were with General Finishes gel stain.  I liked Candlelite for my medium color.  Java is a nice dark color you might like.  With a non blotching wood you put it on and wipe the excess off.  But for a wood like maple that doesn't take the color evenly I had to just leave it on the resistant areas and let it dry there while I wiped other areas to match.  It took many attempts.

 

I had tried wood stains and wood dyes.  Both gave terrible results for me on my maple piece.  I also tried sealing the maple but then nothing took particularly well and gave washed out looking results.  For sure don't use regular shellac to seal, it has to be dewaxed.  If you can't find dewaxed you can use the regular stuff that has been sitting for a long time.  Don't stir it up, the wax kind of settles to the bottom so the top liquid layer is mostly dewaxed.  But as I said I didn't find that sealing really helped. 

 

I am attaching a picture of my finished piece.  I don't know if I could reproduce the effect.  I had been keeping notes but after a while it got ridiculous and I was so sick of the project that I set it aside.  When I came back to it I didn't recall exactly what had been done to it but I just messed with it until I got something I liked and called it done. 

 

BTW, I think this was soft maple.  I don't know if hard maple behaves the same way or not.  Outside of turning I haven't gone near the stuff since.

post-5342-0-45213100-1401806572_thumb.jp

Couple of orientation questions to make sure I get the problem...

I believe the piece is already built

It's built from soft or hard maple? makes a diference...

You want a deep brown

 

==>i have tried going over the shellac first,  scraping off the shellac and then the sealcoat, and even went back to bare wood.

This implies that the wood is now stripped and back to your starting point... It passivly implies that the vanity is not assembled...

 

==>other than my test board i have had mixed success.

Could you please define 'mixed success'...

 

 

Some general comments:

Maple has the dual issue of being blotch prone and yet hard to color... There are several long threads on finishing maple -- not 'poping the grain', but just finishing maple... The further complication is that there's more than one species labeled 'Maple' and they take color very differently, are more/less prone to blotching and more/less hard to darken.

 

Gel Stains can work, but they muddy the wood's natural figure. For me, they are a product of last resort... I don't use them unless I absolutly have to... They are a product with a purpose.  BTW: I've got a shelf-full of Gel stains, but can count on one hand the number of times I've actually used them... I want to repeat this point for emphasis: Gel stains are a purpose-made product. Their use is intended for a limited to certain fields of play. They muddy the woods natural figure and grain pattern. For general furniture finishing, they are a product of last resort. Unfortunately, they are 'easy', so woodworkers tend to overuse them...

 

Alchohol Dyes are your best bet, but they can be tricky to apply. Spray is best, but you can hand-wipe if you work fast/smart... I'm "assuming" you are familiar with alcohol-based dyes... If not, you should do some reading... They are a very different animal from other colerants... They are very powerful, penetrate more deeply and dry faster than any other kid on the block. Unlike stains, these will add color with each subsequent application... This means that drips/runs will place you directly in finishing hell -- no passing Go and no collecting $200... It is highly recommended that you spray dyes, but if you work fast and always keep a wet-edge, then you can hand-apply...

 

BTW, they are also the dye of choice to pop figure -- they penetrate Maple like nothing else...

 

Here is a schedule to get Maple to a faux-Walnut:

 

This schedule works best for spray, but it also works wipe-on/wipe-off if you work quick.

Sand Maple faces to 150/180 and edges to 320/400

One coat of Charles Neil's blotch control

Second coat of blotch control on edges

Mohawk Medium Walnut Alcohol NGR

Let Dry

Mohawk Light Walnut Alcohol NGR

Let Dry

You may need a barrier coat depending on how your going topcoat it.

 

The final result is very close to Walnut. From ten feet away, you can't tell it's not Walnut...

 

Sometimes two coats of Light Walnut may be closer than a Medium+Light. 

 

BTW: Mohawk is only sold in 1gal or 5gal quanities. You can get Behlan Solar Lux in quarts (maybe even pints) -- it's essentially the same product... Mohawk is sold primary into pro cabinet cabinet shops and Behlen into lutiers.

 

BTW: if you've ever wondered how lutiers get such pronounced figure on guitars -- well, Behlan is part of the schedule... One other thing, a quart of dye is going to last you a long time -- while not as concentrated as Transtint, this stuff is still plenty powerful and many dilute it for use.

 

BTW: Many pros tint a #2ct Super Blonde with Mohawk/Behlan (both are alchohol-based) for a tone/glaze equalizer tint coat for Cherry panel glue-ups -- just evens things out a bit... With the added dye, the cut is reduced to #1.5ct --- which is perfect for an equalizer spray.

 

Good luck.

  • Author

thanks cindy and triple h

 

yes the vanity is not assembled.  mixed success. the maple is hard, however, i suspect my test piece was not as hard as some.  i have tried the gel on scrap pieces since and not particularly getting dark.  a few of the boards i scraped the shellac off and was able to get one to darken after about 6 coats, but not as dark as i would like.  the others just yellowed a bit.  i have no real issue with scraping, alcohol or sanding to remove the shellac and then trying dye.  i just would like some chance of success.

==>i just would like some chance of success.

The schedule I posted works... It does so because metal-complex alchohol dyes are very powerful and penitrate deeply in Hard Maple... Got yourself some off cuts from the same stock you built the vanity, get yourself a couple of pints of Behlan and have at it...

Excellent information TripleH.  Wiping the gel stain and any of stains and dyes I tried caused unevenness on my project and would be a even bigger problem on something like a cabinet.  I will try your techniques next time I attempt something like that now that I have a compressor. 

 

Before I was a woodworker I had done many refinishing projects and had no problem with stains  It turns out they were oak and were super easy to work with.  Who knew.  I sure didn't.

  • 4 weeks later...

This schedule works best for spray, but it also works wipe-on/wipe-off if you work quick.

Sand Maple faces to 150/180 and edges to 320/400

One coat of Charles Neil's blotch control

Second coat of blotch control on edges

Mohawk Medium Walnut Alcohol NGR

Let Dry

Mohawk Light Walnut Alcohol NGR

Let Dry

HHH, when you reference the dye in this schedule, I assume you are referring to Spraying? This is similar to what I am planning for my finish, but was debating if I should use the blotch control or not (i purchased it thinking i would hand stain, but ended up buying a sprayer). 

  • Author

i will post some pics later. i am nearly done with the vanity. it is framed, just have to do the shelves.  i softened the shellac with alcohol, scraped it, scrubbed it with alcohol and sanded it.  then used general finishes dark brown dye with just a foam brush.  put on three coats and it is now a very deep brown that we were looking for.  it then got two coats of varnish thinned 1/3 varnish, 2/3 thinner. followed by 2 coats varnish with 2/3 varnish, 1/3 thinner and a teaspoon of dye.  

==>when you reference the dye in this schedule, I assume you are referring to Spraying?

Yes and no... The preferred method is spray-on/wipe off. However, if you lack spray gear, you can wipe-on/wipe-off, but you've got to keep a wet edge and avoid drips/runs/etc. Gravity is your enemy -- drips run down the piece, so you apply dye wiping up the piece...

 

==>debating if I should use the blotch control or not

Depends on the specific species of 'Maple' -- some blotch quite badly... As often as I write long explanatory posts, I'd really rather avoid it here... Actually, I'm considering stopping the practice all together...

 

Shoot a wet coat of alcohol, then shoot the NGR. If that doesn't do it, CN's BC.

Experiment on off-cuts... Make your decisions from there...

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,009 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Joseph b Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.