Pbmaster11 Posted March 20, 2012 Report Posted March 20, 2012 Can you make shop made inserts or is that special locking insert the only thing that will work? Quote
CessnaPilotBarry Posted March 20, 2012 Report Posted March 20, 2012 Can you make shop made inserts or is that special locking insert the only thing that will work? Sure! Just like any other saw. I've made a slew of reversible dado inserts, as well as a reversible dual-blade tenon inserts for my ICS. The reversible inserts have a different slot in each direction, say... a 1/4" tenon and a 3/8" tenon, or a 3/4" dado and 5/8" dado. My inserts are made from 1/2 baltic birch, with plastic shims or 1/4" set screws installed to set the insert level with the top. I don't use the riving knife with the inserts, as it really doesn't do anything in the situations where the inserts are used. My local woodworking school has a full range of inserts for all three of the SS ICS examples there. I don't use an insert at all when using a sled. I've noticed this improves dust collection on all of the table saws I've owned. 1 Quote
Jfitz Posted March 20, 2012 Report Posted March 20, 2012 I don't use an insert at all when using a sled. I've noticed this improves dust collection on all of the table saws I've owned. I had never thought of that! I've always been frustrated with the DC when using the sled. Quote
Joraft Posted March 20, 2012 Report Posted March 20, 2012 From Popular Woodworking, March 12, 2012: California assembly member Das Williams has introduced a proposed law that would make the sale of new table saws without active injury mitigation technology, illegal. As written, the law would take effect January 15, 2015 and defines the requirement as: "technology to detect contact with, or dangerous proximity between, a hand or finger and the teeth of the blade above the table top of a table saw, and to prevent the blade from cutting the hand or finger deeper than one-eighth of an inch when the hand or finger approaches any portion of the blade above the table top at a speed of one foot per second from any direction and along any path. Notwithstanding the prior sentence, active injury mitigation technology may be temporarily deactivated by a person so that a saw can cut material which would otherwise be detected as a person." The federal government, through the Consumer Products Safety Commission, is in the process of considering proposed product safety requirements with similar specifications, and will be holding hearings sometime this year. While this law would not directly effect sales of table saws in other states, consumer legislation in California often has an impact beyond the borders of that state. Quote
dwacker Posted March 20, 2012 Report Posted March 20, 2012 I would not buy the contractors saw safety features aside. Its way over price and to light weight for 52" rails. On a safety note the only table saw accident ive ever seen personally was a tipping over railed contractors saw that tipped to the right during a cut. The guy lost only one finger and it was a jet contractors saw. You can add legs to the right to stop this from happening but the saw is still a light weight for the money. Just go someplace like woodcraft and fire up a cabinet saw then fire up any contractors saw. You dont even have to make a cut to feel the difference. Don Quote
JimB1 Posted March 21, 2012 Report Posted March 21, 2012 From Popular Woodworking, March 12, 2012: California assembly member Das Williams has introduced a proposed law that would make the sale of new table saws without active injury mitigation technology, illegal. As written, the law would take effect January 15, 2015 and defines the requirement as: "technology to detect contact with, or dangerous proximity between, a hand or finger and the teeth of the blade above the table top of a table saw, and to prevent the blade from cutting the hand or finger deeper than one-eighth of an inch when the hand or finger approaches any portion of the blade above the table top at a speed of one foot per second from any direction and along any path. Notwithstanding the prior sentence, active injury mitigation technology may be temporarily deactivated by a person so that a saw can cut material which would otherwise be detected as a person." The federal government, through the Consumer Products Safety Commission, is in the process of considering proposed product safety requirements with similar specifications, and will be holding hearings sometime this year. While this law would not directly effect sales of table saws in other states, consumer legislation in California often has an impact beyond the borders of that state. hmmm, oddly specific wording there and in reality as written I'm not sure even the saw stop mechanism would pass depending on the testing used. I have read of several instances where the saw stop triggered saving a hand but still causing enough damage to require stitches. The effectiveness of the saw stop mechanism is variable depending on speed, angle of impact and surface across which the blade hits. It's always far better with it then without it but it will not always just cause a scratch requiring a bandaid from everything I've read... -Jim Quote
Jafet10 Posted March 22, 2012 Report Posted March 22, 2012 I have had a Sawstop contractor saw for about a year now. The only problem I see is poor dust collection. Very accurate out of the box, I did get the 36" Bessmeyer type fence, the mobile base, and cast iron wings. I built a router table into the right side. I would go for the 1.75 HP PCS if I were to do it again, But still happy with the saw. It was a big upgrade from a very old Grizzly tablesaw Grizzly stopped making 10+ years ago. 1 Quote
Fah-Fah-Fooey Posted March 22, 2012 Report Posted March 22, 2012 It's always far better with it then without it but it will not always just cause a scratch requiring a bandaid from everything I've read... -Jim You can figure this out just by watching the sawstop video where Gass touches the blade, ever notice how slow he is moving his hand, he is trying to get as small of a nick as possible to make the saw look as good as possible. There is a really good reason he didn't "ninja chop" the saw blade : ) Quote
Beechwood Chip Posted March 22, 2012 Report Posted March 22, 2012 I've seen videos where he uses a hot dog on a board and pushes it into the blade as fast as anyone would push a board through a saw. But you've got a point, you could "ninja chop" a stationary blade and get a pretty good gauge out of your hand. Quote
lighthearted Posted March 22, 2012 Report Posted March 22, 2012 Great Review here from Tom Hintz: http://www.newwoodworker.com/reviews/sawstoprv.html Quote
CessnaPilotBarry Posted March 22, 2012 Report Posted March 22, 2012 You can figure this out just by watching the sawstop video where Gass touches the blade, ever notice how slow he is moving his hand, he is trying to get as small of a nick as possible to make the saw look as good as possible. There is a really good reason he didn't "ninja chop" the saw blade : ) My local adult super-duper fine woodworking school had two firings, a student's hand, and an improperly placed miter gage. Both were normal speed accidents, and neither the hand or the miter bar received more than a nick. A local college's maintenance shop, as in the pros, not the students, fired their SS when a carpenter put his hand into the blade during a rip. All he needed was a Band-aid and new underwear. While this is only three examples, there are thousands more available. II have yet to hear of an example of where the saw failed to work as advertised during a flesh contact incident. I have to believe this would be big news and would travel fast over today's Interwebs... Even if the Ninja chop caused more damage, it's obvious the damage would be far less than if the system were not present. Another point is that the system can actually detect flesh before it actually touches the blade. With my saw's processor on and motor off, I can trigger the red light without physically touching the blade. In other words, activation may actually begin BEFORE you touch the teeth. That said, I don't blame Stephen Gass for being careful during that demo. Have you seen the inventor of the seat belt, airbag, or HANS device purposely drive head-on into crash? Me either! Quote
JimB1 Posted March 22, 2012 Report Posted March 22, 2012 Just to clarify, I have no problems with the SawStop saw, it is very nice, and seems very well put together. I probably would get the hybrid over the contractor saw though, once you add on the cast iron table extentions you are near the base price for the hybrid cabinet saw and it runs quieter and has better dust collection not to mention you get a mobile base or the dust collection blade guard free with the current promotion... I just don't like the reliance on the mechanism that some folks seem to emphasize. Stupid still hurts even with a SawStop I also find it odd that people have actually triggered the mechanism after owning the saw for very short amounts of time, months or a year. Some people even sound proud of the fact that they did something bad and triggered the mechanism. (I'm glad my truck has airbags but I hope to never see them at work and probably won't be too happy if I ever do...) I mean, knock on wood but I've been using my TS for years and while I've had a few encounters with kickback I've been pretty good about keeping my hands away from the blade. It just seems like people get complacient and sloppy when they feel they are "safe" Just an observation... -Jim Quote
CessnaPilotBarry Posted March 22, 2012 Report Posted March 22, 2012 It just seems like people get complacient and sloppy when they feel they are "safe" I totally agree. This is why I bought a SS after 20 accident-free years, which included advanced professional table saw training. Quote
Jodavis Posted March 23, 2012 Report Posted March 23, 2012 I saw the saw stop slow motion video and the only thing that concerns me is all the flex you see in the trunion when it fires That's got to mess up alignment. I understand those cartridges are essentially crush zones to absorb the energy of the blade Just like cars have for wrecks, but that can't be good for a precision instrument. It seems to me stopping the blade is more of a way for them to make money on cartridges When they could just have the blade drop below the table and accomplish the same result. The reason I did not by a saw stop is it's the only game in town. And as a result your stuck buying replacement cartridges and new blades for as long you own it. I think once competition has caught up we will see a better design that isn't based on the inkjet printer cartridge trap. Don't get me wrong Im speaking as someone has filet his thumb with a table saw once already So I can appreciate the safety. But I think it's too early to get one I'd wait for the tech to improve. Just my 20 cents Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.