Recommended Posts

Posted

So I searched the wood talk online forums tonight for any posts on CNC’s with no hits. I know that there are countless other forums out there dedicated to CNC’s but this is where I tend to find some of the best information, As of late unfortunately, I have been tasked with multiple request for custom cremation urns. Some may feel that this is a morbid task, but I find it to be an honor to construct someone’s final resting place.

So to get to the point I have been thinking about purchasing a Shark Pro Plus CNC setup from Rockler. I feel that this would give me the ability to add even more customization to the above projects as well as endless customization to other projects.

So I am looking for input from anyone who has had experience with the shark or any other consumer grade CNC setup as far as recommendations and suggestions.

I am currently looking for a turnkey solution that would get me up and running in a short period of time, not a custom construction project.

As always thank you for your time in advance.

Mark Maslonkowski

Posted

Mark,

I used to sell huge CNC machines. 100 K plus.

My approach to this technology is for you first to dominate software. The machine takes orders from the computer and not from your hand. Well ... not really ... your fingertips.

Research on software. Another thing. Research on support. I remember loosing orders to cheaper competitors and when the machine broke the support people had no idea how to fix things.

Remember when the machine breaks, you are shut down. Closed business.

So ... check on software and support.

Find other current users of the machine you are buying and ask for their experience on the machine and also on the support.

Last. Tooling. Now you will have to buy tooling balanced at 25,000 rpm's. If your tooling is not balanced at that speed, the vibration will go to the spindle and you will end up buying a new one.

I hope this helps.

So I searched the wood talk online forums tonight for any posts on CNC’s with no hits. I know that there are countless other forums out there dedicated to CNC’s but this is where I tend to find some of the best information, As of late unfortunately, I have been tasked with multiple request for custom cremation urns. Some may feel that this is a morbid task, but I find it to be an honor to construct someone’s final resting place.

So to get to the point I have been thinking about purchasing a Shark Pro Plus CNC setup from Rockler. I feel that this would give me the ability to add even more customization to the above projects as well as endless customization to other projects.

So I am looking for input from anyone who has had experience with the shark or any other consumer grade CNC setup as far as recommendations and suggestions.

I am currently looking for a turnkey solution that would get me up and running in a short period of time, not a custom construction project.

As always thank you for your time in advance.

Mark Maslonkowski

Posted

Mark,

I think Bobby is right on with is comments! I couldn't agree more with his view on software. It's what makes my CNC a POS. That being mentioned I think your choices are slim to none in the bench top cnc market. If you are just looking to goof off then the smaller models should serve you well. If you are looking to make money I think you are SOL.

Honestly your best bet is to probably outsource this process. Not only are there machine and tooling costs to look at but a learning curve as well.

RJ

Posted

To elaborate more.

Software. Find out who makes the most user friendly software. We are woodworkers ... find somebody who has experience in different offerings.

Once you narrow the software, find a machine that works with that version ... plus flexible for others because I saw in my many years of experience selling CNC that customers change their minds.

Good luck.

Software ... software ... software.

Mark,

I think Bobby is right on with is comments! I couldn't agree more with his view on software. It's what makes my CNC a POS. That being mentioned I think your choices are slim to none in the bench top cnc market. If you are just looking to goof off then the smaller models should serve you well. If you are looking to make money I think you are SOL.

Honestly your best bet is to probably outsource this process. Not only are there machine and tooling costs to look at but a learning curve as well.

RJ

Posted

mark, another system to look into is carvewright. the software is very easy to use. it is a proprietary system which sucks a lot but all in all it is a good system. i have 200 hours on mine right now with just a few hickups. machine maitenance is key, keeping the dust mostly out of it.

  • 3 weeks later...
Posted

Have been away from this board for a bit, so missed this when it first came out. The software advice is good. Fortunately, the Shark pro comes with VCarve, which is an excellent program. Unfortunately, it doesn't come with Mach, which is the best of the control programs available to a hobby CNC user.

There are two limitations of the Shark Pro. One is the size of the working area, which is 24 x 24 x 4.5. If that works for you, great. Mine is 48 x 48 x 6. The other limitation is that it uses the Bosh Colt router, which is underpowered for lots of interesting jobs. Mine uses a Hitachi M12VC.

Some more nits: it doesn't have a dust collector. You can make one, but it's silly not to at least offer one. It only has two T slots. A machine of this size should have 4. It doesn't have an auto Z set, which makes set up harder; even better if it had auto X/Y set. It doesn't say what its accuracy is, only its resolution; there is a BIG difference.

Mostly, it costs too much, but the other side of that is that you get more support (not necessarily better support) by buying a complete system instead of a DIY or kit that would cost you a whole lot less. Mine cost less than yours, but it was a kit and I had to spend a lot more hours putting mine together.

Posted

I'm pretty late to this thread but here goes.

I've used the ShopBot and although expensive, it's pretty easy to use and they have a huge forum community that is really helpful.

There are a number of "fablabs" opening around the country in larger cities that all have shopbots available for the public to use.

Posted

mark, another system to look into is carvewright. the software is very easy to use. it is a proprietary system which sucks a lot but all in all it is a good system. i have 200 hours on mine right now with just a few hickups. machine maitenance is key, keeping the dust mostly out of it.

I love my carvewright too-- With an aftermarket Rock chuck the bits are not proprietary and once you make a dust collector (you carve it of course) the clean up is next to nothing.

I've recently posted some of my projects in the blog section and am more than happy to answer any questions. Jason, let me know if you want the dust collector MPC and I'll send it to you.

Posted

I love my carvewright too-- With an aftermarket Rock chuck the bits are not proprietary and once you make a dust collector (you carve it of course) the clean up is next to nothing.

I've recently posted some of my projects in the blog section and am more than happy to answer any questions. Jason, let me know if you want the dust collector MPC and I'll send it to you.

thanx lawrence. the mpc is on the forum somewhere i think. i have something else in mind anyway. i have the rock chuck too and love it. it is a nice machine but it does get frustrating.

  • 5 months later...
Posted

I would like to thank everyone for their feedback is anyone familiar with this unit the shark pro plus cnc.

After a six month search, I decide to buy the Shark Pro Plus HD. This is a new model that was introduced last Nov.

The HD has been beefed up to use a larger router. The gantry rail and side rails are now fully supported.. The control box comes with fourth axis capability (coming later). The standard cutting area is 25"x25"x7". It can also be ordered with a 25"x48"x7" cutting area.

I chose this machine because I could not find anything close in this price range ($3999). There are certainly better quality small CNC machines, but the next step up in price is huge. I did look at the Carvewright, but did not care for the flexible shaft drive.

The Shark is manufactured by Next Wave Automation in Holland, Ohio and distributed excluvisely in the U.S. by Rockler (http://www.rockler.c....cfm?page=30833). The support from Next Wave is not stellar, but it is there. I get the feeling that they are growing fast and a little overwhelmed. However, I doubt that there will ever be a problem getting parts.There is an online forum for support (http://www.cncsharktalk.com) run by Rockler and Next Wave, but neither company participates much. The support there is mostly user to user, but there is a lot of good input from experienced Shark owners.

The Shark HD comes with VCarve Pro software by Vetric (http://www.vectric.c...comparision.htm) but can be upgraded to their high-end Aspire package. I'm just getting started with the software, but both packages seem to be well regarded. And Vectric's reputation for support is stellar.

I'm installing the Bosch 1617 router, which is 2.25 hp, a big step up from the 1 hp Bosch Colt.

I am installing high precision collets in the Bosch from Precise Bits (http://www.precisebits.com/). They also offer a wide variety of cutters. Browse their site for a lot of good info.

I am also installing the Kent Dust Shoe (http://www.kentcnc.net/nc/). They make a shoe specifically for the Bosch 1617.

I can't report much about the machine itself yet because I'm still setting it up. So far I find the quality to be good for the price, and as I said the next step up in price is BIG one.

  • 4 weeks later...
Posted

I have the Pro Plus HP with the Kent dust shoe and for the price is a great machine. It takes a little trial and error to get really smooth carvings but the VCarve software does everything I can think of plus a whole lot of stuff I didn't. The documentation (other than assembly) is lacking but if you're somewhat mechanically inclined you can figure it out. The Vcarve online tutorials are pretty good as well.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   2 Members, 0 Anonymous, 50 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined