aengland Posted August 6, 2011 Report Posted August 6, 2011 Boy what a discovery!! I bought some Sigma Power Ceramic stones from Stu (TFJ) and got the first installment just in time for some shop time this morning. INCREDIBLE is by the far the best descriptive to relate how much better they cut than my oil stones and my Norton water stones. These Sigmas are fantastic. First, with two O1 chisels (Irwin, 1/2 and 3/4) I went from flattening the backs to sharpening bevels on the Norton 1000 and the Sigma 1000. The Sigma 1000 was multiple times faster!!!!! At least 3x faster. And, it left a sharper, more polished edge than the Norton. IT LEFT A LOT LESS MESS, TOO. This stone is incredibly responsive (its the Sigma hard) and very, very dish resistant. I kept drawing lines to see where it was dishing--and it wasn't. By the end of the morning, I concluded that oil stones produce an edge that is as sharp as the Norton 8000 but not as polished. The Norton 8000 leaves the edge less sharp than the Sigma 6000, though its polish is nearly comparable. The 13000 stone I ordered hasn't arrived yet. I can't wait to see what crazy sharp may look like! When I took the Irwins, Stanley's, Ashley Iles, and Lie Nielsons off the Sigma Power stones, I couldn't believe how mirror polished the backs and bevels were!! Yes, I consistently get wicked sharp with Ark oil stones (ain't no betta!!); but, the Sigma ceramics just cut and polish so much faster than the either the oil stones and the nortons. BTW, my Ark. stones cut A2, as well as the Nortons--though the Nortons are a little faster on the A2; about the same for 01. The Sigmas are screaming fast compared to that. There is some mess. But compared to the Nortons, the Sigmas are significantly less messy in fresh dressing, water spritzing, and clean up. The Sigmas cut faster, resist dishing significantly longer, and leave the beginnings of mirror polishing much quicker--oh, and draw burr extremely faster, too. So, I'm declaring my new Sigma ceramic stones a GLOAT!!!!!!!! Hope this helps others on the fence, as was recently was. Archie, near NOLA Quote
flairwoodworks Posted August 6, 2011 Report Posted August 6, 2011 That was an interesting read, Archie. Thanks for sharing your experiences. Quote
cjcgw Posted August 13, 2011 Report Posted August 13, 2011 Looking for new stones and this may be the answer Quote
aengland Posted August 14, 2011 Author Report Posted August 14, 2011 I've been using my new Sigma Power stones (these are not the Select II stones) and they are fast, fast, fast and great! I'm amazed at how sharp and polished these stones work the tools. I wish you the best in discovering what's best for you. Quote
jpdorn Posted November 20, 2011 Report Posted November 20, 2011 stu got me hooked on the sigma power 1k as well. if you haven't already, play with different soaking times. say.. splash water on before use soak for a few mins before use store it submerged (bad mojo for most artificial stones but won't hurt the sigma) it changes the feel of the stone fairly significantly i've found. still haven't found a strong preference myself yet. Quote
aengland Posted December 18, 2011 Author Report Posted December 18, 2011 Well, four months later and I still feel that these Sigma Stones are a gloat!! I love the fast, sharp edges. Stu Tierney, at Tools from Japan, has blog in which he has tested virtually all the newer ceramic stones (plus some vintage ones). He's posted six reports, filled with massive info on sharpening. This covers sharpens achieved, finish, and time--plus much much more. Being curious, I've tried other stones, too. The single best stone that no one can touch is the Sigma 6000! It's incredible. Though I bought and use the Sigma 13000, too; the 6000 produces an edge that is ready to go for 90% of my chisel work. For end grain or difficult grain, I pull out the 13000. Bottom line: the Sigma powers (not the SSIIs) are incredibly fast, efficient for sharpening, honing, and polishing, and affordable--compared to other quality stones (Chosera, Gesshin, etc). I've tried the Bester 1200, as well, and the Sigma 1k is faster, better feel and feedback, better finishing, and sharper (in the time compared). The Bester is a good stone--just the Sigma is so much better. Price wise, they're about the same. hope this update helps.... Arch Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.