Recommended Posts

Posted

I have a box of old auger bits that I've been starting to use with my grandfather's old brace. Most drill holes quite well but a couple will not advance unless I put most of my weight on the handle. I've attempted to sharpen the cutting edges (after having read Leonard Lee's Complete Guide to Sharpening) but they still won't cut.

Anybody have any idea what's wrong? The lead screw pulls the bit in until the cutting edges hit the wood then it just spins (and gets hot).

Posted

This is a very common problem with these old bits. It's a clearance angle issue. Someone likely sharpened the bottom of the cutting lip, which is a no-no. If this part of the lip is sharpened incorrectly (i.e. at the wrong angle) it will cause the bit to ride the bevel (like a turning tool) and the cutting edge won't actually engage. The only solution is to correct the geometry by filing the bottom side of the bevel to a more acute angle and providing enough clearance for the cutting edge to engage.

For reference, the picture shows the only side of the cutting lip that should ever be sharpened in a properly sharpened auger bit. If the opposite side of the cutting lip is sharpened, one is almost sure to change the geometry of the cutting lip and cause the problem you are experiencing. You'll need to correct the angle on the bottom of the cutting edge to get the bit to cut again.

post-2117-0-31158100-1321274562_thumb.jp

  • Like 2
Posted

Yep, I picked up nearly complete sett of Jennings pattern bits in there orginal box for a while back. They looked gorgeous, but tried them out to realize they have been missed filed as Bob described. This may sound nuts, but part me wondered if I could get in there with a rotary tool correct the angle and also give a slight hollow grind on the miss filed side to give it more clearance, instead of trying to correct it with a file (I know, neanders and collectors everywhere are screaming at the thought of it). Don't worry, I'm not about to run out and do this to one of my nice, hopefully salavagable, bits only to make it worse - but I'd be curious on folks thoughts on this idea. Is it completely stupid/insane or might it have some merit????

Posted

Sure, you can use a rotary tool if you can carefully get in there without disturbing the spurs, the lead screw or the smooth polish on the flutes. This might be hard to do, especially on the smaller bits. If you bugger up the spur or the screw with the rotary tool, you'll make the bit pretty useless. If the smooth polish on the flutes is made rough, the bit will have trouble ejecting the chips from the hole while boring, especially in deeper holes.

The nice part about the file is its safe edge, which will allow you to file right into the corner where the cutting lip meets the spur and screw without disturbing those parts. A rotary tool can't do that.

  • Like 1
Posted

Yeah, I'd probably experiment on a bit that wasn't part of the set. Actually, a couple in the set are pretty buggered up already and may not be salvageable anyway. Got so excited when I saw the set in an antique store for far less than they ever go online, that I guess I didn't take ample time to really investigate - also the bits were very clean which may have lead me to overlook some things. However, I don't feel too bad about it. I didn't get a steal, but I think I paid a fair price - no where near as inexpenisive as if I bought the bits individually, but fair I think for a nearly (missing 2) set of Jennings bit in the original box (assuming I can eventually get them to work). I also walked away with a Bell System brace for $20-$25 at the same time, and was pretty pleased with that. Yes, there are less expensive braces out there (I think I paid $10-$15 apiece for my MF and Stanley braces), but the Bell System sure is nice, and once again online they often go for a more.

Anyway, I've gotten off topic here. Since Bob, thinks it might work, I'll have to give the rotary tool a try some time, just on the ones that are really out of whack. The key will be to find a very very small grinding bit or sanding drum. Thanks for the input Bob.

Posted

Hey, thanks Bob. I thought I'd report back on my efforts.

I did as Bob suggested and brought two of them back to life which is pretty satisfying.

One of them has a lead screw with some messed up threads on the very end. I suppose I could try to get my hands on a thread-chasing file but other than that, I don't know what to do about that. Two others seem to be beyond me - they're both so small that I can barely get the file in between the lead screw and the spur.

Interestingly, the metal seems pretty easy to file. Maybe the steel is relatively soft to make sharpening easier? Don't know.

But I had some success. I'm going back out there and working on the small ones again. I can't make them any worse which encourages me to try harder.

Posted

OK, I hate to keep beating a dead horse but I think I've brought the horse back to life!

I searched google for the lead screw problem and although I only followed about the first 10 links, only one of them referenced the lead screw and hinted at using a triangular file.

So I got out my small triangular file that I bought for sharpening my handsaws. I started with a bit that is 3/4" - very common and thus very useful. I don't push a file one-handed with much control so I held the bit in my left hand up against a wooden dog and pulled the file (gripping at the tip) along the lead screw threads. I did this as much as I could and actually sharpened the threads after awhile. It worked - the bit now bores a nice hole. So out of a box of about a 15 old dull bits, I've now fixed up all but three.

A larger one had a similar lead screw but also the spurs had either been broken, bent, or just oversharpened because they are very short - maybe 1/8". The cutting edge had been ground upwards rather than level for some reason. So it had three strikes: bad spurs, non-straight cutting edge, and dull lead screw threads. Still I got it to the point where it would at least try to bore a hole. It actually split apart the 2x4 I was practicing on - perhaps because of the cutting edges that were not straight? Kinda weird. I figured that with spurs cutting the hole and the cutting edges removing the material, there wouldn't be any forces that would make the wood split but there it is. I think I'll just toss that one - too much work needed.

The other is a 1/4" bit and my files just won't squeeze into the little gap between the lead screw and the spurs or into the lead screw threads. I've seen teeny files and if I can get my hand on one of those, I just might be able to make that bit work too.

Very interesting. So I've got myself a set of auger bits that work now except for the smallest. Those larger ones (around 1") start to get pretty hard to muscle around. I guess in the old days, they'd have used a larger perpendicular handle rather a brace like I have. I suppose I could make one of those actually.

Posted

Greg, I couldn’t find any reference to what size brace your using. I’ve seen several sizes, but the most common size I’ve seen (and have) is a 10” brace (5” radius with a 10” sweep). As an aside, they do make smaller braces. I’ve seen an 8”, but no smaller, although they may exist. If you want to use a 1” auger bit or larger, and don’t have a brace with a 14” sweep (7” radius), I would recommend obtaining one if you really want to use your larger bits. I’m not the expert here, but somewhere I read that a 14” brace can adequately handle drilling with a 2” auger bit. I’ll leave the proof of this to the reader. You might also look into a joist brace for higher torque.

Posted

I hear you Greg. However, with a larger radius, less “strength” is required. I mentioned a 14” sweep brace with a 7” radius which would reduce the strength requirements over a 10” brace with a 5” radius. Also the Joist Brace has a 10” or so handle which gives you a 10” radius. Of course the only problem here is actually getting ones hands on one of these brace types to try them out with a 1” or larger auger bit. However, you may rarely if ever need to drill a 1” or larger hole.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.