Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

A Few Questions

Featured Replies

I thought I'd start a new thread because I have several questions. I apologize in advance if any of them are stupid, but this is the only way I learn anything.

1. Does anyone know how many of us are doing this build? Also, if there is anyone else out there who is going to struggle through this project despite it being beyond their skill set (and who doesn't want to say so out loud) please feel free to send me a private message. I know of myself and one other person who are talking off-line to help each other.

2. Is there anyone out there who could label the drawing with the names of the pieces on the cut list? I'm happy to do it myself if anyone would want to talk me through it on Skype. I have to make several modifications starting with height, and it would be helpful if I had some idea which parts referred to what on the drawing.

3. The first modification I have to make is for height. I'm making it 5" shorter. Does anyone have any suggestions on this? Take it from the top of the leg, the bottom of the leg, shrink the leg vise vertically?

4. I'd like to know if it would be helpful for anyone else if I post my modifications for the benefit of others?

Thanks very much, that's it for now. :rolleyes:

Cynthia,

Great questions and it's nice to see the energy starting so soon. I can't speak to all of your questions but I can help with the plans. The final version of the plans that we publish will have all the parts identified and many many more details about building the bench. If you can hold tight a couple more weeks they should be ready. Take a look at the plans for previous Guild Builds like the chest of drawers or the adirondack chair to see what you'll be getting.

To shorten your bench the typical guidance is to take it out of the legs below the bottom stretchers. But 5" is a lot of height and there may not be enough down there. You may have to take some off the bottom and the rest from the middle of the legs, shortening the leg vise a little.

Again, great questions!

  • Author

Thanks Aaron. I spoke to Benchcrafted today trying to order a combination of hardware + one vise, but they won't do that. You have to order either the whole thing or an individual vise, but no other combinations. So I'm going to get my hardware and different vises from Lee Valley and modify for those as well. I can get the Gramercy Holdfasts from toolsforworkingwood.com

Re: shortening the bench

I think I'll have to shorten the leg more than that because I want to add casters, and the heavy-duty ones are about 4" high.

Thanks

If you are considering casters, you might want to look at http://www.greatlake...00F.php?cat=262

They are very sturdy and there is a knob you turn to lower a rubber leveling post and stop it from rolling. I use them on my bandsaw and it makes it incredible easy to move a very heavy bandsaw, yet lock it to the ground when I am using it. They also make ones with a ratchet to raise and lower the leveler which would make it even easier. I am considering doing the same but will have to investigate a little more to confirm the bench will still be sturdy enough.

Alternatively I am considering building a retractable caster system to use which would keep the entire bench on the ground unless I want to move it. if you search the web there are several designs out their that entail putting casters on a hinged plate that locks in a down position when you want to roll it around by using your foot or a lever.

I will be interested in what others are thinking.

By the way I am also concerned about the time commitment and my ability to complete this project. I was all ready to go but in reading some other build blogs began to realize that the scale of this work will make it rather demanding of my skills.

If you are considering casters, you might want to look at http://www.greatlake...00F.php?cat=262

They are very sturdy and there is a knob you turn to lower a rubber leveling post and stop it from rolling. I use them on my bandsaw and it makes it incredible easy to move a very heavy bandsaw, yet lock it to the ground when I am using it. They also make ones with a ratchet to raise and lower the leveler which would make it even easier. I am considering doing the same but will have to investigate a little more to confirm the bench will still be sturdy enough.

Alternatively I am considering building a retractable caster system to use which would keep the entire bench on the ground unless I want to move it. if you search the web there are several designs out their that entail putting casters on a hinged plate that locks in a down position when you want to roll it around by using your foot or a lever.

I will be interested in what others are thinking.

By the way I am also concerned about the time commitment and my ability to complete this project. I was all ready to go but in reading some other build blogs began to realize that the scale of this work will make it rather demanding of my skills.

I cannot recall who makes another caster that I saw but it attaches to the side of the leg and you have to lower each of them individually using a built in foot lever. This way you can leave the legs at full length as the casters are out to the side and lower about a 1/2 inch when engaged. They only hold about 300 lbs each but when you get the bench in the location you want you disengage the casters and then the bench is on it's own feet.

Just another option.

Stephen.

I just received my three vise's (11/14/11). After opening the boxes, I received NO plans. Were we to get plans?

How is the split bench to be held together??

In my order I have NO bolts or similar.

I ordered the leg vise, then when I found out my present tail vise was not going to work I ordered the Tail and Moxon vises also telling them of my present order for the leg vise.

Apparently its my fault, I ordered ala cart (two orders for $896.00) and was not entitled tor the complete package!

Apparently the ala cart orders for $896.00 does not qualify me for the combined price of $712.00 + shipping price to get the "hold together screws"

I have been informed that the screws have been sent.

additional error message 11/15/2011 1923 EST

I am in error on the price I paid. Fr. John says, if had paid for the complete package, I would have paid $908.00, where as I paid $856.00 ($ 896.00 was my math error).

This first class business man has made it correct, I owe him $58.00. mea clupa!!

Edited by Steve Anderson

  • Author

I just received my three vise's (11/14/11). After opening the boxes, I received NO plans. Were we to get plans?

How is the split bench to be held together??

In my order I have NO bolts or similar.

I ordered the leg vise, then when I found out my present tail vise was not going to work I ordered the Tail and Moxon vises.

I went through this with Benchcrafted yesterday. They will only sell the *whole* package or the individual vises. They won't sell the hardware unless you get the whole package. That's why I decided to buy my stuff from Lee Valley and use different (less expensive) vises and hardware. You can buy the Gramercy Holdfasts from toolsforworkingwood.com The plans come from the Guild here.

I just received my three vise's (11/14/11). After opening the boxes, I received NO plans. Were we to get plans?

How is the split bench to be held together??

In my order I have NO bolts or similar.

Steve, you only get the hardware if you order the complete kit. As for the plans, they don't come with the kit on the Guild deal, those will be available here.

I went through this with Benchcrafted yesterday. They will only sell the *whole* package or the individual vises. They won't sell the hardware unless you get the whole package. That's why I decided to buy my stuff from Lee Valley and use different (less expensive) vises and hardware. You can buy the Gramercy Holdfasts from toolsforworkingwood.com The plans come from the Guild here.

Sorry for the duplicate response. I'll have to write faster, the responses come quick around here. :)

Cynthia, I understand and respect your decision to go with less expensive hardware, but have you ever had a chance to see the Benchcrafted hardware in action? Just a light spin on those small wheels opens the vises up, another light spin quickly locks your material in place, no further tightening needed. Smooth as glass!

After playing with a Benchcrafted bench at the WIA, I fell in love and could settle for no less. Of course I'm seeing this as a lifetime investment, since I can't see myself ever building a better bench in the future.

... By the way I am also concerned about the time commitment and my ability to complete this project. I was all ready to go but in reading some other build blogs began to realize that the scale of this work will make it rather demanding of my skills.

Here's a link to one of the best progression threads I've seen on a Benchcrafted Roubo bench build. It was done about two years ago by a very skilled woodworker named Jim Kirkpatrick:

Roubo Bench Build

  • Author

That is a great link Joraft! Thanks! Joraft, I think that hardware is "caviar for the general" so to speak. I totally respect everyone's choice to use it, but I doubt this will be my last bench. I think I'll be very happy with slightly less sophisticated hardware for years to come. Perhaps someday I'll want the best of the best.

I struggle almost daily with the vise decision. The bench craft set looks so good and the videos are impressive as are all the comments I have read about them; however, the cost is significant and I know I can get less expensive hardware. It is not easy making a drop of that amount of coin on the hardware.

I can relate to your thinking Cynthia and as of right now I am still searching and evaluating how to best balance the price/quality matrix. one day I am ready to spot the coin, the next I think save some cash and go with a different set of hardware.

Stephen.

Alternatively I am considering building a retractable caster system to use which would keep the entire bench on the ground unless I want to move it. if you search the web there are several designs out their that entail putting casters on a hinged plate that locks in a down position when you want to roll it around by using your foot or a lever.

I will be interested in what others are thinking.

By the way I am also concerned about the time commitment and my ability to complete this project. I was all ready to go but in reading some other build blogs began to realize that the scale of this work will make it rather demanding of my skills.

I saw that type of caster on a few threads. Sort of like the look of it. But concerned about it being attached with screws/bolts to bottom (end grain) of bench legs. Seems sort of weak against racking (planing) forces. I see you'd have to lower each foot separately by hand. That looks like torture for my bad knees (replacements are on order). I need to roll the bench out every day. Thinking of going with a flip down bar type that the LVL bench at WIA classroom had. Then it is sitting on its own strong legs. Down side is I need to lift each end of the beast enough for the wheel bar to flip down.

re: skill set and time commitment

This is not a quickie build. Easier than some smaller case work as you are not making and fitting a bunch of drawers 'n doors as in a dresser type cabinet. Skill set not that demanding other than dealing with large and heavy pieces. So it has its own challenge. Due to the size and material handling I wouldn't undertake this if my woodworking was an occasional thing, with time being tough to carve out of a busy life.

As with many projects, the trick is to break down the steps and components into something you can handle. I'd guess the toughest thing other than size/weight will be the installing and setting up the vises.

The cool thing is that Marc (and Aaron) really present things in a useful manner. Also as Cynthia said the forums are great resource and many of the experienced guild members are willing to help one on one outside of the forum if that works better for you. You'd also have Marc's 911 guild hot e-line for specific questions or feedback.

If your time and/or confidence is not quite ready, remember that you will have access to the videos and forums long after the build is "finished." There is some benefit to waiting until it is over to getting the full vision of it all. I am having knee replacement surgery end of December, then the other one 3-4 months later, so even though the BC hardware is in da house I won't be starting the build for some time. I am comfortable with all the steps, but know I can benefit watching Marc handling the big lumber.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,011 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • bobtjanitor Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.