jdbrown1998 Posted February 12, 2012 Report Posted February 12, 2012 Ok so I am building my own bench top router table. I am not sure which way to go with a router top insert. The three options are: 1) 3/8" Acrylic insert 2) Rockler blue insert 3) Bench Dog Router table It seems like both the rockler and bench dog are essentially the same thing (and the same price). So the real question is: Is there an advantage to 1/4" aluminum plate or a 3/8" acrylic plate? Not sure what the advantages of the aluminum is other than maybe less deflection and changeable inserts. The acrylic is $35 cheaper if that weighs into the decision any...I would rather have the better solution given that it is just $35. Quote
semmons23 Posted February 12, 2012 Report Posted February 12, 2012 I have the rockler and don't love it. It only has 2 corner hold downs which sucks. Its too hard to level perfectly Get one with 4. I'd get a jessem or woodpecker - not that I've checked the holding/leveling system Quote
tim0625 Posted February 12, 2012 Report Posted February 12, 2012 Various inserts are good but what I hear is Acrylic will flex and the aluminum will not. I bought the Incra Masterlift 2 and love it. The price is like a strong cup of coffee...makes you wince and close one eye but everytime I use it, I'm glad I spent the money. The plate has 12 or 14 leveling screws and has many metal inserts that snap into place held by 4 RE Magnets. Under the metal inserts there are 4 leveling screws so the insert is never "almost level" - it's dead on and it holds the adjustment pretty good. If the Masterlift is not an option just now, I'd go with the aluminum plate to prevent bad words later. Quote
nikbrown Posted February 12, 2012 Report Posted February 12, 2012 I'm a big fan of the woodpecker one. It levels great and the various size of twist lock rings. Quote
Sac Posted February 12, 2012 Report Posted February 12, 2012 Well, I had this nice long thing typed out and it was nice, but I lost it. What it boilded down to was Other manufacturers make the same thing with a different name on it. Bench dog -> Rockler, Woodpecker -> Kreg. I had a plastic plate, it sagged and gave me lots of problems. Go Woodpecker in my opinion. I think they make one of the best plates/lifts around. Quote
SignWave Posted February 12, 2012 Report Posted February 12, 2012 The size of your router is a big factor in how much you need to worry about sag. It's a much bigger concern with a 3+ HP router than a 2HP router. I have the non-lift Incra insert (my router has above-the-table height adj. and bit changes), and can recommend it. It's very sturdy, and the magnetic inserts are fast and easy to change while still holding in place very well.. Like many of the Incra products, it seems a bit pricey at first, but it is both designed and implemented very well. So as they say, you only feel the pain once. Quote
jdbrown1998 Posted February 13, 2012 Author Report Posted February 13, 2012 Rockler ran a special today on their router table and then tossed in free shipping to boot....that made up my mind:) thanks for all the feedback guys and eventually I hope I can upgrade to one with a lift! Quote
Sac Posted February 13, 2012 Report Posted February 13, 2012 Well Congrats on the new Router table.. Make sure to post back with pics and a review. Good luck! Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.