Recommended Posts

Posted

I'm going to buy my first hand plane; well, at least my first quality hand plane. I bought a 15 dollar block plane at big box store to tinker around with so I didn't feel bad if I screwed it up during the initial tune up, and it works ok. I'm going to buy a Veritas plane because it seems to fit in my budget better than a LN one, but it's still great quality from what I understand. This is the application for which I'm buying: I'm building some friends a dining table.

The table top is a quite large, roughly 5 x 7, glue up of straight grain doug fir. To make the top flat, the only way I know to do it is either plane with a router sled, or hand plane it. I like to buy tools as I need them and this seems like a good opportunity to buy a plane and learn to use it through this project. My question is, what would be a good plane to use in this application. I'd like to get one that can be useful on other aspects of this build, so versatility would be nice. I was thinking low angle jack plane. What do you all think?

Posted

Veritas planes are phenominal and the low angle jack will certainly be versitile, but for such a large table top something longer would more ideal if you really want to get it flat. You certainly could do it with the LA jack, you just need to pay a bit more attention to where you are removing material. A No 6. would be a little longer and still fairly versatile, but really the task is best suited for a large jointer plane. My advice is to buy the plane best suited for the task at hand, so in this case that would be a jointer. Trust me when I tell you it won't be the last plane you ever buy, and even though a jointer will be less versatile than the LA jack you will still find plenty of times when it will come in handy.

Whatever you decide, make sure you practice getting some boards flat before going to town on the table top. I remember when I first started falttening by hand I assumed that the plane would automatically get the board flat, but regardless of how large the plane is, you still need to pay attention to where material needs to be removed and this takes practice.

Also, if you don't already have a method of sharpening do yourself a favor and buy one when you get the plane. The best plane is worthless with a dull blade.

Posted

+1

A #6 would be good, but a #7 would be ideal for your situation. The longer sole of the #6 or #7 will not ride along all the smaller, uneven sections a smaller plane would (like a #4).

Posted

BUT, if you want to do the router rail thing, the smoother would be the obvious choice from that, unless we're talking about a joinery bench, then you kind of want a somewhat rough texture left on the top.

Posted

It's a dining table top. I'm leaning towards the router flattening method. I just don't know it I'm ready to purchase a jointer plane first. I'd rather purchase something that I can use on other projects, and right now I kinda stick to smaller things. This is my first large build. So if I go the router method, Vic suggests a smoother to finish the process, any suggestions on where to go from there? I don't know why I keep gravitating to the jack plane, but I do. What would be a good plane to use for this project, but then give me some versatility in other ones? #4 smoother, or would a low angle version be better? Also, what's your feeling on A2 or O1 steel? Sorry for all the questions, just a little new at this.

Posted

In that case I'd start with the Low angle jack (or really any 14-18" plane). It will be more versatile than the smoother and it will work well as a panel plane (e.g. large smoother). O1 vs A2 really doesn't matter all that much for me. 01 is a little easier to sharpen (on some abrasives) and holds an edge better at a lower angle, and A2 is a little more durable/harder wearing when honed at 30 degrees or above. Really I feel like the differences in actual use tend to be exagerated though. If you use oil stones or feel lke you want to keep the bevel angle as low as possible I guess I'd go with 01, if you use sanadpaper or waterstones to sharpen, flip a coin.

Posted

It's a dining table top. I'm leaning towards the router flattening method. I just don't know it I'm ready to purchase a jointer plane first. I'd rather purchase something that I can use on other projects, and right now I kinda stick to smaller things.

If you are worried that you can't use a jointer plane on other projects, don't. You can use it on lots of projects that are smaller than a dining room table. I'm in the process of building a small stool, about 20" high, with a top that's going to be about 20" x 10", and I'm using a jointer plane for all the pieces that are going into this stool.

I really don't think "versatility" is a great reason to get a low angle jack plane. If low angle jack planes are so versatile, where are all the woodworkers that have a low angle jack as their only plane? ^_^

Seriously, the advantage of being able to change the blade to get you a bevel angle that is higher only is versatile in the sense that you can go from planing more well behaved pieces of wood to planing wildly figured wood. It's not very versatile in the sense of serving as a jointer plane and then a smoothing plane. I'm going to guess that by the comments that you're making, you're not going to be using highly figured crotch in your pieces just yet. That's actually a good thing. Learn to use a plane with more normal wood first, and then you'll be ready to make your next dining table out of tiger maple. ^_^

Posted

Man, the title of this post was "quick question..." somehow it doesn't suprise me that it turned out to be a little more in depth than I thought. Wilbur Pan, you make some good points. I'm just trying to navigate the world of hand planes and make the best choice I can. I probably won't be buying another hand plane for awhile, so I'm just trying to pick something that will serve me well on multiple types of projects until I can save up for another one. I mostly do things for friends or myself like step stools, urns (only done one of these thank Jesus), cutting boards, and picture frames. I always assumed a jointer was good for big things, but I'm probably wrong. I'll have to think on this a bit more I guess.

Posted

I've been thinking about it, and I guess I should get the best tool I can afford for the project I'm working on. Maybe I shouldn't try to think too far ahead on things I'm not even working on. I guess that means Veritas Jointer plane it is. I know that's wont be my last plane, so it should be fine. I'm thinking of getting the 38 degree blade as well, both in O1. Any concerns with that?

Posted

I think thats a very good choice - it will give you the opportuny to learn to flatten by hand, which I think will ultimatley be preferable to the router setup. It an invaluable skill to have. While I think a mid sized plane like a LA jack could be a good choice IF you are married to using the router for flattening, overall I really do think the jointer is a better choice given the task at hand. It really won't be the last plane you ever buy, and when it comes to jointing and flattening you will never find it lacking.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   1 Member, 0 Anonymous, 66 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined