Recommended Posts

Posted

Does this tool really replace a sliding table for a TS? I want to get either a sliding table or the festool.

I do very little assembly work outside the shop, so having the saw stationary is a non-issue for me.

I was also considering the DeWalt track saw, but see it carries almost the same price tag as the Festool.

Opinions?

Posted

I use the Festool TS 75 because of that extra versatility. There are a lot of applications where a Table Saw is very useful. At the same time I use my plunge saw a lot. It is very convenient to have both.

Do you do mostly solid wood or panels?

Posted
Does this tool really replace a sliding table for a TS? I want to get either a sliding table or the festool.

If you're just using the slider to cut up sheet goods on the table saw, yes, a track saw will 100% replace the table saw for that use. If that's all you're after, get a TS 55 and you'll love it and never look back.

If you're trying to do ALL of woodworking, a track saw alone will not totally replace a table saw. A tracksaw coupled with a bandsaw (pretty necessary) and a SCMS (necessary only to get up to table saw speed for some operations) will replace a table saw for everything except coves.

Posted

as the others have said, I would not say that my ts55 replaces my ts, but is makes cutting sheet goods EXTREMELY easy. My boys call the festool "Daddy's back saver" as I don't have to try to heft sheet goods onto the ts.

It won't replace all of a ts's functions though (it especially cannot be used as an assembly table!)

Lawrence

Posted
Does this tool really replace a sliding table for a TS? I want to get either a sliding table or the festool.

I do very little assembly work outside the shop, so having the saw stationary is a non-issue for me.

I was also considering the DeWalt track saw, but see it carries almost the same price tag as the Festool.

Opinions?

I think it's easier to just learn to use the table saw to cut sheet goods. You won't save any space if you already own a tablesaw with and outfeed table. It's no more work rustling a piece of plywood onto the table saw then it is a pair of sawhorses.

Posted

I think it's easier to just learn to use the table saw to cut sheet goods. You won't save any space if you already own a tablesaw with and outfeed table. It's no more work rustling a piece of plywood onto the table saw then it is a pair of sawhorses.

It's easier still to just drop the sheet goods on the floor on some foam or other sacrificial surface and make the cut.

Actually, dwacker, I've got a question for you since you've been so adamant that the tablesaw can do everything quite easily. How do you make a diagonal cut corner-to-corner across a 4'x8' sheet of 1" ply on a tablesaw? I actually can't think of a high-precision, high-accuracy, fast, and safe way to do this on a tablesaw. It's trivial on a tracksaw.

Posted

+1 to the foam - I never lift a full sheet of ply anymore - heck I've put foam in my truck bed before and just cut it to width in place on the bed... (just put the wood on top of the foam at the lumberyard)

Also, with my tracksaw I never get that little "divot" that sometimes happens at the end of a cut on my TS-- I know improving my technique on the TS will alleviate this, but I've no need to learn this skill when I've got my tracksaw :)

One last thing to note-- my cuts with my festool are cleaner than those with my tablesaw (running a WWII blade) Switching to a ply blade would improve the cut but again... no need with my tracksaw.

I'm not saying the tablesaw isn't great. Heck, I love mine~ ... it's just that for me, the festool fits the way I work. Your mileage may vary...

Lawrence

Posted

Thanks for the replies guys. Maybe I should have been more specific.

I have a nice tablesaw, and I use it on almost every project. I do not plan on replacing it with a track saw.

I want to get a tool to help me cut larger panels. I thought of getting a sliding attachment for the table saw, but realized that a festool track saw is close to the same price (or cheaper). So I asked myself, "will a track saw better suit my needs than a sliding tabel attachement?"

I do about 60% of my projects in solid wood, and 40% with plywood and solid edging/face frames.

Posted

Actually, dwacker, I've got a question for you since you've been so adamant that the tablesaw can do everything quite easily. How do you make a diagonal cut corner-to-corner across a 4'x8' sheet of 1" ply on a tablesaw? I actually can't think of a high-precision, high-accuracy, fast, and safe way to do this on a tablesaw. It's trivial on a tracksaw.

Quite honestly in a quarter century of doing this for a living never had or seen the need for an eight foot triangle other than being argumentative is there really a point.

Would a slider do the OP some good ? You bet and a tracksaw will perform some tasks a table saw can't that's fairly obvious.

A sheet of plywood weighs 60 lbs no matter how you cut it or what tool you use. If your like the rest of the free world most sheet good projects are made from 90 degree angles.

Is is easier to flop on the ground and crawl around on your hands and knees? That really depends on who you ask. Is it easier to set one end on a saw and feed the sheet with a single hand. Again depends on who you ask.

Is a add on slider the answer to both. Simply put no. They are way to small to be of any real benefit.

I guess if I had to work in my living room the tracksaw would be the clear winner but that really doesn't apply to this thread.

People have been cutting sheet goods on table saws long before the festool cult ever proclaimed itself as the one

Don

Posted

Quite honestly in a quarter century of doing this for a living never had or seen the need for an eight foot triangle other than being argumentative is there really a point.

Much like me and coves. Far as I'm concerned, coves are only for being argumentative.

However, I've done a number of things that needed full-sized triangles out of 4x8 sheet goods. Most recent example is that there's a number of flat-pack temporary shelter designs that rely on full-length diagonal cuts out of sheet goods.

Posted

Much like me and coves. Far as I'm concerned, coves are only for being argumentative.

However, I've done a number of things that needed full-sized triangles out of 4x8 sheet goods. Most recent example is that there's a number of flat-pack temporary shelter designs that rely on full-length diagonal cuts out of sheet goods.

I've never needed to make an eight foot triangle, but I do have to crosscut full sheets of plywood, and I'm assuming I'm not the only one who's not blessed with the TS capacity to do that...I max out at 32". So the tracksaw is critical for those of us with that limitation, unless you wanna fumble and cuss with a standard circular saw and a straight edge...I don't.

On the other hand, there's no way I'd give up my table saw, and I have a bandsaw and a SCMS.

Posted

I've never needed to make an eight foot triangle, but I do have to crosscut full sheets of plywood, and I'm assuming I'm not the only one who's not blessed with the TS capacity to do that...I max out at 32".

32 is your rip limit thus why it's called a rip fence. Your crosscut limit is only limited by the size of your crosscut sled.

Posted

32 is your rip limit thus why it's called a rip fence. Your crosscut limit is only limited by the size of your crosscut sled.

A crosscut sled that can handle a full sheet of plywood? Sounds a mite unwieldy to me.

Anyway, the right side of my TS is up against a wall...unfortunately that's the only space I have for it. I'd love to put it in the center of my garage, but I have to keep a trailer in there. So I couldn't crosscut a full sheet even if I took the fence off. That's what tracksaws are for. :)

Posted

I have both.

The question will a TS55 replace a table saw?

Yes it can do everything a table saw can.

Can it do everything as fast as a table saw?

Most things yes.

Where I find I need/like a table saw is where I have one small quick cut to do or ripping thin strips. I think a table saw can do that faster.

Full sheets, a table saw falls short. A full sheet of ply or MDF can be done on a table saw, you bring the ply to the saw and have to muscle it, The same with MDF/ Melamine .

With a track saw you bring the track and saw to the ply/ mdf/ melamine, a back saver and it will rip and cross cut it more accurately.

But the thing about festool is its a system. Everything works with everything else and is designed that way.

Posted

How do dados work out on your tracksaw? :)

I actually just used my TS55 to make some dados and rabbets, of course with the help of an MFT and a couple hand tools. I set the guide on the inside of my pencil line made the cut (on both sides in the case of the dado) then cleaned out the waste using a chisel and router plane. Worked better than I expected, if I was at home I would take a couple pictures to show how well the joint came together.

James

Posted
...then cleaned out the waste using a chisel and router plane.

So James, I guess the answer to my question would be..."about halfway?" Neener-neener. :D

Posted

How do dados work out on your tracksaw? :)

Works great because I'm not dumb enough to try to cut them with a saw of any kind. Pick up the saw, put down the router on the rail. Run the router back and forth. Perfect dado. Even if I had a dado set for a table saw, I would still do dados with the router. It's a better tool for the job.

Posted

Geez, you guys sure are defensive about your tracksaws. The question was can the TS55 do everything a table saw does, and the answer still appears to be no. Playing devil's advocate here...I own both.

And williaty...not sure what you mean by "dumb." Dados on the table saw are fast, easy and plenty safe.

Posted

Geez, you guys sure are defensive about your tracksaws. The question was can the TS55 do everything a table saw does, and the answer still appears to be no. Playing devil's advocate here...I own both.

I answered no, just a tracksaw can't replace a table saw, in my first post.

And williaty...not sure what you mean by "dumb." Dados on the table saw are fast, easy and plenty safe.

Sorry, that's pre-caffine morning grumpy there. I don't use dado sets. They're too dangerous, the results they produce are not acceptable, etc. I meant that I wouldn't use the tracksaw to make dados just to prove that I'm man enough to do it or something. I pick up the best tool for the job that I happen to own, which isn't a saw of any kind.
Posted

Works great because I'm not dumb enough to try to cut them with a saw of any kind. Pick up the saw, put down the router on the rail. Run the router back and forth. Perfect dado. Even if I had a dado set for a table saw, I would still do dados with the router. It's a better tool for the job.

How is using a dado blade "dumb"? How is a router a better tool for the job? How do you adjust a router for width?

Posted

How is using a dado blade "dumb"?

See my previous post for my explanation of this. Effectively, less safe, unacceptable surface finish (meaning I need to come back through with a router plane to make it perfectly flat).

How is a router a better tool for the job?

Safer, better results, easier setup especially for something like a double-stopped dado, less work to finish out with a chisel when done.

How do you adjust a router for width?

There's this amazing technology called "different sized bits"! :lol: Yeah, smartassed answer. The real answer is that coupled with turning the micro-adjust knob on the guide that rides the rail. You can make really, really precise and repeatable dados this way. Couple that with using stop blocks on the rail and you can make precise, repeatable, and easy dados that'd be pretty hard to do in any other way.

Posted

I answered no, just a tracksaw can't replace a table saw, in my first post.

Sorry, that's pre-caffine morning grumpy there. I don't use dado sets. They're too dangerous, the results they produce are not acceptable, etc. I meant that I wouldn't use the tracksaw to make dados just to prove that I'm man enough to do it or something. I pick up the best tool for the job that I happen to own, which isn't a saw of any kind.

I make lots of dados with my 1400 on small projects or odd jobs or for stopped dados, but sometimes (usually) the dado stack is the more convenient option, especially if you're batching out a bunch of pieces or you're doing odd widths or long dados. I definitely wouldn't want to be relegated to a router to do a full kitchen's worth of cabinets.

It's perfectly safe...not sure where you get that it's not.

Posted
It's perfectly safe...not sure where you get that it's not.

If you're trying to make a stopped dado in the middle of a panel, dropping the panel down onto the top of a rotating dado set does not, in any way, qualify as "perfectly safe".

I've done stuff like cabinetry both ways (tablesaw and router). I honestly prefer the router. For me, it's as quick as using a tablesaw.

You guys seem to react like I'm trying to tell you that you're wrong for having a tablesaw and that you should go out and sell it. I'm not. If you already are invested in one and know how to use it to do everything you want to do, it obviously makes the most sense to stay with that. What I'm trying to drum into the collective conscious is that, if you don't already have one, buying a tablesaw isn't necessary. You can choose to buy one and that's fine. You can choose not to buy one and that's just fine. Regardless of which workflow you choose, the end result is going to be that you can do all of woodworking. It's no longer necessary for a new woodworker to feel like they have to buy a table saw.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   1 Member, 0 Anonymous, 43 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined