Recommended Posts

Posted

I see a lot of router use in your videos, so you (or someone knowledgeable here) would be good to ask. I know the dictionary difference between a spiral up cut vs spiral down cut bit, but am having trouble fully grasping what to use when. I am in the process of beefing up my router bit collection and would like to understand the practical uses of each.

As a side note, I have a lot of routers and use them A LOT. I am a huge fan of the router, and it, with a few clever jigs/sleds, replaces a lot of tools in my shop.

Posted

So if I understand correctly, down cut bits are for cutting completely though the piece (cutting circles for example) and up cuts are for mortise/dado cuts and anything else that doesn't go through? That is helpful. Also I do cut a lot of mortises/dados with a horizontal jig I made, but I use a fluted straight bit. Would a spiral up cut give me a cleaner cut/flatter bottom?

Posted

I use the down-cut for dadoes and rabbets in plywood. While it leave the chips in the dado, it doesn't create any tearout on the plywood. I learned the hard way not to use an upcut bit...tore the crap out of the plywood.

Adam

Posted

So saying 'downspiral reduces tearout' is accurate if a backer is below the bit. Oddly enough, a lot of forum posts long ago would say the exact opposite. Spirals are excellent for clean cuts, but there aren't general rules; you have to consider your setup then decide the bit. If you only have one bit, use how it works to setup your work.

A downspiral slices away from the router; an upspiral slices towards the router. The up/down designation is relative to you holding the router handheld; everything is upside down if it's in a table or, worse, horizontal table. Maybe they should have used Latin and called them trans-spiral and cis-spiral respectively. I digress...

I'm assuming handheld use in the following rambling...

In the case of dados and blind mortises: a downspiral will slice down, but down where... there's no place for the chips to escape so they pack in there until you make a little clearance forming the dado. Since it slices down, the top surface of the stock is supported in the cut, it is a clean cut. All the crud in the dado can impair moving smoothly; loitering can smoke the chips. An upspiral slices toward the router lifting the chips from the dado so you have no issues with chips packing in the groove impairing motion allowing a faster cut, too. Downside is that the upward slicing action at the surface can lift fibers. The decision is whether speed with a possibly ratty edge is okay. If you are dadoing for a shelf and the shelf edge has shoulders, it will hide the ratty edge. If you are dadoing to insert the shelf into the dado, you need it pristine. In the case of mortises, typically your tenon stock will have shoulders that hide lifted fibers and typically you need a mortise depth that is difficult with a downspiral without a lot of passes.

In the case of routing against a pattern, you again have 2 choices. If you put the pattern on top of the stock, you'll use a bit with a shank bearing. You'll likely want an upspiral as it will slice towards the router; the pattern is between the stock and the router so the pattern backs up the cut making it clean. If you put the pattern on the bottom of the stock with the router on top, you'll want a downspiral bit with a bearing on the tip. The bit will slice the stock away from the router and be backed by the bottom pattern board. Personally, I put the pattern on the bottom to limit bit exposure but that's me.

All this ignores compression spiral bits, which gives you more options in many scenarios.

I wrote a longish blog article long ago about the bits I use the most. If you are looking for some ideas on bits, give it a read. There's a long section on spirals although it doesn't fully repeat what i put up here. So, if you learn the cutting direction, you can pick the right bit or setup for what you want to do.

  • Like 1
Posted

Thanks a lot, that is exactly what I needed. I am going to be buying both, but for the inversion proposition (table vs handheld). I plan on using these for mortises mostly and you are correct. The shoulder hides imperfections, and as a bonus, I find the little imperfections perfect as a "scratched up glue surface".

Now for the tricky part, I am building a horizontal milling jig for a router. Since I will be getting both style in various sizes, I'll try them out to see which works best.

  • 1 month later...
Posted

You are balancing edge crispness -v- chip removal ---- i.e. unsupported edge is balanced against chip removal. Direction of spiral produces cleanest surface in the direction of the cut. For clean on both sides , you can get an up-down bit (typically edge work). For plunging, up-cut clears chips most efficiently, so heat is reduced, but you risk the top edge as it is unsupported. On surfaces where you edge may pull away from the substrate (MDO, MSO, et al) or a very finicky exotic, down-cut can preserve the edge on a non-through plunge -- but you need to manage heat/chip removal. Of course, you can sandwich you material if the edge is really finicky.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   1 Member, 0 Anonymous, 51 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined