Recommended Posts

Posted

I am making adjustments to my shop to improve my dust collection. I am increasing all machine ports to 5", and I am trying to collect dust from more than one location on some tools (TS and RT).

On my router table, I have 2 ports (one in the fence and one under the table). They are both 2.5". Here is the question:

Am I better to connect the 2 ports to a shop vaccuum (Y-adaptor), or to a dust collector dropped from one 5" line to a 4" line, and then split into two 2.5" ports?

I know that shop vacs and DCs operate on different princples. Which set up should I go with?

Posted

I would answer this question with this word "Logistics" I have several tools that work as good with a shop vac vs my 2 hp ducted setup. My shop vac hooked up to a short hose pulls really hard and

is hooked up to my panel saw and a foot switch so much easier than closing all my 4 inch gates for a 30 second cut. Using my shop vac with secondary tools keeps the airflow stronger in my 4 inch system.

BUT I would not use a y adapter with a shop vac I think you would lose to much suction.

Posted

I'm not an expert, but here's the rule of thumb I use:

Assume that device can't handle a larger duct than it was designed for. For smaller dust collectors, that's one 6" duct or two 4" ducts. For a shop vac, that's one 2.5" duct. So, if you want to hook up two 2.5" ducts, you could use two shop vacs or one dust collector, with some left over.

Area of a circle is pi r squared, so a 2.5" hose is pi times 1.25" squared or 1.56 pi sq in. A dust collector with a 4" duct is pi times 2" squared or 4 pi sq in. So, you can split a 4" duct into two 2.5" ports and a 1.25" port with a little left over.

Of course, you lose a little with bends, long hoses, flex pipe, etc.

I have no idea whether this math would make sense to a fluid dynamics engineer, but it's how I think about these problems.

[ EDIT - fixed radius / diameter problem pointed out by robjeffking ]

  • Like 1
Posted

I'd hook it up to the DC and then the shop vac and compare results. Nothing answers questions better than empirical evidence.

But one thing I'd keep in mind is to make sure you're not going so big on your port sizes that you lose too much velocity in your DC. I've found that while increasing pipe size on my 2HP DC increases fine dust collection, the chip collection inversely suffers. The router table is one of those tools that produces a lot of both chips and dust, so you'll have to find the right balance of CFM and velocity in order to collect both. I do think that the shop vac's performance will be drastically diminished by breaking the one 2.5" inlet into two 2.5" inlets, since a shop vac operates more in a "suction" type of capacity as opposed to a "flow" type of capacity with the DC...so I'd be willing to bet the best scenario would be breaking your 4" or 5" DC pipe into two 2.5" ports, one on the fence and one on the box. But again, no way to know for sure without testing it.

Let us know what your results are...I'm planning to tinker with my RT DC soon, too.

  • Like 1
Posted

in your first equation you used diameter, π x radius squared= 4.91 They make a router table tee 4inch /2.5 split for the fence.

Thanks. Note to self: never post after miidnight!

I've done the math correctly before, and remembered the results. I just re-did it using radii: two 2.5" and one 1.5" is equivalent to a little less than a 4" - all diameters.

Posted

Just a note, a I burnt out a shop vac using it as a DC for a planer. I ended up getting a real DC plus a new shop vac. I have been keeping a close eye on the shop vac, and see what happened. The filter clogs up real quick with dust, which causes the motor to work harder. As a result, my preference is when taking dust directly from a machine is to use the DC, then use the shopvac to clean up afterwards.

Posted

I use a shop vac solely for my dust collection. Just having the shop vac really wasn't that great, but then I bought a dust deputy based on Marc's review and I have been thoroughly impressed. I never, ever, thought a shop vac could work so well. No need for filters or bags (I do keep a filter on mine).

I would rather have a DC but for a hobbyist like me, what I have works fine. It keeps up with my planer, table saw, sanders, etc without any problems.

Posted

I use a shop vac solely for my dust collection. Just having the shop vac really wasn't that great, but then I bought a dust deputy based on Marc's review and I have been thoroughly impressed. I never, ever, thought a shop vac could work so well. No need for filters or bags (I do keep a filter on mine).

I would rather have a DC but for a hobbyist like me, what I have works fine. It keeps up with my planer, table saw, sanders, etc without any problems.

This surprises me. One time when my DC was full, I used a shop vac for my TS and dado blade. It filled the canister in about 90 seconds.

Posted

This surprises me. One time when my DC was full, I used a shop vac for my TS and dado blade. It filled the canister in about 90 seconds.

Don't get me wrong, when I'm doing stuff like planing I can fill it up quick, but it only takes a few seconds for me to dump it out. Easy peasy.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   1 Member, 0 Anonymous, 50 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined