CJC5151 Posted October 15, 2012 Report Posted October 15, 2012 Im in the market for a domino...i just dont know which one to buy...is there anything the old one does that the new one doesnt...if i get the big one is there and limitations I may run into...i do alot of large joinery so im leaning towards the xl, but i dont want to be limited to large joinery if i do...I guess what i want to know is which one bridges the gap better and will be more versitile...thanks guys Quote
Beechwood Chip Posted October 15, 2012 Report Posted October 15, 2012 This has been discussed and I don't think that there was a clear consensus. Quote
STL Woodguy Posted October 15, 2012 Report Posted October 15, 2012 Because there is not much overlap between the two, there really isn't any all-in-one choice and it's going to boil down to what you are planning to work most with. I'm going to marginally say that the original Domino is a little more versatile because it can cut small enough to work with 3/4 sheet goods and small projects, can use smaller Dominos for alignment (biscuit replacement) and it can handle some bigger stuff too, especially if you use multiple Dominos for some joints. These days some may say you need the XL for things like tables and chairs, yet before the XL they were saying the original Domino could do the same stuff just fine. But depends on what it is, of course. But if you're doing large joinery (as you said) and the above isn't a concern, I'd go with the XL. Quote
wdwerker Posted October 15, 2012 Report Posted October 15, 2012 i have the original and we do some large joinery. What is the thickest wood you use on a regular basis? 8/4 works fine with the original Domino. And if you use 1/2" , 5/8" and 3/4" stock frequently I wouldn't get the XL. If you work mainly in heavier stock and want longer tenons the XL will plunge a much deeper mortise The Domino stock comes in sticks that you cut to length to suit your needs. Large doors and big furniture would be an example. A longer tenon can reach past a cope and stick joint . I was using the deepest plunge on a door we built and could have used more depth. I think the fence on the XL allows for a cut farther in from the edge. This would speed things up without the need for clamping on a stop to reference the cut from. We sometimes make our own Domino's to use with the wider settings.Festool only sells one width for each thickness of tenon. We have also made Domino's in mahogany to match a project where we plunged through mortises.We routed and sanded the ends before we cut them to length. The exposed ends added an interesting detail to the project and made the assembly sequence easier. Either Domino needs a vac attached to operate. We use a Fein Turbo II. The XL might need something a bit stronger to remove the heavier volume of shavings.Look into this and make your own decision. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.