Recommended Posts

Posted

Yeah, those are knock-offs. Big difference. Quality of the steel and the forging process. Google it, tons of info already out there. Even a $500 set of ten is on the cheap side when you're talking Japanese chisels. I'd suggest buying three or four quality chisels instead of ten crappy ones.

Posted

Talk about a provocative issue....!

I suppose so. But my LNs are way better than the Irwins and FatMax chisels I've used. Likewise, they're better than the few 750s that I've picked up cheaply at pawn shops and restored. I've used a number of other vintage chisels, however, that held a sharp edge well and matched cutting performance but didn't match the weight, balance, or "feel" of the LN. But I don't necessarily think the LN chisels are the best made: they're just very well designed and produced. Great tools.

Posted

so are the japanese chisels considered to be the best of the best? for example, would a good japanese chisel be of better quality than a LN chisel?

I think that question is a little too general to answer, and I certainly don't know enough to answer it. Someone like Wilbur would be good to hear from on this one. My personal opinion...between good Japanese chisels and quality western chisels like LN or the new Veritas bench chisels...probably boils down to personal preference. They're all good options as far as I'm concerned. I like Japanese bench chisels, but the LN mortise chisels are on my Christmas list. You listening Santa?

Posted

Not really better, just different. With Japanses chisels (real ones, made by a smith), you are paying for the custom work of the blacksmith. Each chisel is made by a smith and stamped with their "brand". You are paying for their experience and expertise as a blacksmith. With the modern premium chisels, they are typically drop forged and/or machined. So the skill of the blacksmith is removed from the equation (skilled machinists are sometimes still required to finsih the job after forging, but the majority of the work is done by machinery). At least as far as the expensive, smith made Japanese chisels are concerned, It comes down to manufactured chisels (LN, AI, Lee Valley, etc.) vs. individually crafted tools (blacksmith made chisels).

There are of course manufactured Japanese style chisels (i.e. Grizzly ones linked above) as well as hand forged western style chisels (e.g. Barr Tools). Their prices will also reflect the process. If you want to compare apples to apples, look at the prices of the Barr Tools chisels. They are right in line with the blacksmith made Japanese style chisels.

Posted

so are the japanese chisels considered to be the best of the best? for example, would a good japanese chisel be of better quality than a LN chisel?

Yes.

***ducks*** :)

Seriously, I think the major difference between Japanese and western chisels in terms of using them is that Japanese chisels used for a given task tend to be shorter than the western counterpart. So a Japanese bench chisel is shorter than a typical western bench chisel, a Japanese paring chisel is shorter than a western paring chisel, and the same holds for mortise chisels. Personally, I like the shorter length. To me, Japanese chisels feel more nimble and easier to place where I want them compared to western chisels. And then there's the ease of sharpening and the ridiculous edge retention that Japanese chisels are known for.

In terms of the Grizzly set, there have been people who bought this set and were happy with them. There are others who reported issues with chipping. I would consider the fact that you are buying $15 chisels, and given the amount of steps it takes to make a Japanese chisel, decide if you think that it's reasonable to make one that you can sell at $15 a piece.

Alternatively, you can take the $150, and get a few really nice Japanese chisels in sizes that you use a lot. You don't need the set of 10. That's how I started, and over time I eventually built up to my set of 11, but I don't regret going that way at all.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   1 Member, 0 Anonymous, 68 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined