fijat Posted December 29, 2012 Report Posted December 29, 2012 So I have a couple of tools at hand but need to complete my collection. Problem is I'm not sure what to get next .. I currently have a router, a table saw, a miter saw, circular saw and other smaller tools. What should I invest in next bewtween a Jointer, a Planer, a bandsaw or a drill press.. and why Was hoping for some insight as to which of these would carry out most woodworking functions till I get get the rest. be helpful if you can list reasoning behind your choices. Thanks all. Quote
TRBaker Posted December 29, 2012 Report Posted December 29, 2012 Fijat, I think I would buy a jointer next. It's amazing how many times a board bends when you run it through the table saw and it makes all the difference in the world to deal with straight lumber. I hate straightening a piece with a hand plane. I guess I wouldn't make much of a neandrathal. Quote
Dlhunter Posted December 29, 2012 Report Posted December 29, 2012 Um..it depends? Get a piece of cardboard and hang it in your shop. Write the tools you are considering on it. Ever time you would use one of them if you had it put a check by that tool. See which one has the most checks at the end of the month. That's the one you need most. That said I would put the band saw first and drill press last. Why? Because the bandsaw has the most checks on my piece of cardboard. Quote
Beechwood Chip Posted December 29, 2012 Report Posted December 29, 2012 I've had bad experiences buying a tool becasue I "should" get it, and good experiences buying a tool because I needed it for a project I was working on. I'd make a short list of about four tools that you would like to have in your shop based on the kind of work you do, how much space you have, your budget, etc. Then, when you are doing a project where you would really like a particular tool, if it's on your short list, go and buy it. Don't impulse buy something that isn't on your short list, and don't buy a tool that you don't won't use immediately just because you think you should. Quote
pghmyn Posted December 29, 2012 Report Posted December 29, 2012 Um..it depends? Get a piece of cardboard and hang it in your shop. Write the tools you are considering on it. Ever time you would use one of them if you had it put a check by that tool. See which one has the most checks at the end of the month. That's the one you need most. That said I would put the band saw first and drill press last. Why? Because the bandsaw has the most checks on my piece of cardboard. I actually really like this method. However, I would continue to add new tools. Bandsaw Jointer Planer Festool Domino CT 26 Kapex Rotex Combination Sander etc etc etc My list would never end Quote
tdale51@yahoo.com Posted December 29, 2012 Report Posted December 29, 2012 Well here's my two cents on your list: Jointer & Planer ....these two kinda go hand in hand. I bought my planer long before my jointer, coincidentally also long before I had even the slightest clue what I was doing. If I had to do it over again I would have saved my money and bought both at the same time instead of learning the hard way that a planer, alone, does not flatten lumber. Drill Press .... Nice versatile tool but not an absolute must have (at least for me) I have one and it's convenient but a good deal of what I do with it I could also do with a hand held drill Bandsaw ... GREAT TOOL! I got my first one about a year ago and I find myself going to it more and more with every project At the risk of adding to your confusion I would suggest adding a router table to your collection. In my shop at least, it really adds a lot of capability, repeatability, and safety. I really like the idea of keeping a written list hanging in the shop. I'm somewhat prone to impulse purchases and I can see where that would really help. Quote
fijat Posted December 29, 2012 Author Report Posted December 29, 2012 "Head spinning .. lol" Let me see if I can confuse you all a little more... So.. the reason I brought this up is because:I got a $75 harbor freight gift card.I had some old lumber I wanted to build some garage (workshop) shelving with and they are bowed, twisted and everything inbetween. hence the debate between planer vs. jointer.I intend on mostly building furniture, cabinets and other smaller items like jewelry boxes and so on. With that said.. I'll definately take on the cardboard technique. and I do have a router table (came with router tho - plan on building something more chunky and stable) From your responses so far this is what I have: Drill press - use a regular drill till later I can use a jig to flaten edges on the table saw plus the 2 hand planes I have will help Still have the issue of flattening wide boards/and planing them down to same width - so leaning more towards the planer Would love a bandsaw but I can use my jigsaw till later.. plus I havent gotten to milling my own lumber from logs - someday Any last words .. And big thanks to you all. Way to welcome a noob to the capentry world.. Another site added to my favorites Quote
STL Woodguy Posted December 29, 2012 Report Posted December 29, 2012 I like the cardboard idea a lot. As for me, I have all the major things I need and don't really want much, but when I bought them, I tended to look into buying whenever I came into a project that forced me to a halt because I couldn't find a way to accomplish the task either safely or with any alternative methods. On the jointer/planer, I think getting the jointer first is going to greatly depend on the situation. Best case situation as already said, they're best bought together in a pair. But if you are only getting one and the other IS NOT going to follow anytime soon, I'd have to say the planer. While a bit of a pain in the rear to do, there 'are' ways to joint on a planer most typically with a 'sled' of some sort, but you won't be doing surface planing on a regular jointer. The bandsaw and drill press I don't use as often as I'd like, but when I need them, I NEED them. I much prefer taking things to the bandsaw rather than use a jigsaw. But I think the jointer/planer would be the most immediate need. I think once you have a table saw, band saw, jointer, planer and drill press, there will be little you can't do. Beyond the major equipment...you have a Harbor Freight gift card? Here's a thought: if you don't already have one, what about a dust collector? Harbor Freight has a surprisingly decent one for around $150-200 (and can be had even cheaper, if you pay attention to coupons). And believe me, when the chips start flying on a jointer and planer, you'll be glad to have one. Quote
chipmaster Posted January 4, 2013 Report Posted January 4, 2013 While a planer is nice when you need it, I find that my jointer is used more often because the finished edges are SO much better to glue up than to try to correct wavy edges. You said you'll be making furniture...trust me, you'll want solid, straight edges. It can be done of course, but it's pretty difficult to do it consistently with a hand plane. If you can't get the planer at the same time, you can still get nice finishes with a good ROS and careful hand sanding. Either way...it's just fun to buy this stuff :-) Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.