Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Finishing Ideas for Cutting-Board Style Table Top

Featured Replies

Hi. I'm looking for finishing ideas for a "cutting-board style" corner-desk top. For the handful of wood items I've made so far - I'm somewhat new to woodworking - my usual finishing regimen has consisted of Watco Danish oil, usually in "natural" color, followed by three or more coats of Minwax satin wipe-on poly, which goes on smoothly and streak-free relative to other polyurethanes I've tried. I'll probably stick with a similar plan for this desktop, but would like to bounce some ideas off y'all.

Does anyone know if different Watco Danish oils can be mixed prior to application? I may want to darken the piece more, but just slightly more, than it would darken with "natural." I have some "medium walnut" as well, and might consider, say, three parts natural to one part walnut. Or maybe begin with natural, give it a few days to dry, then (if I want darker) thinly apply a darker shade and wipe off the excess relatively quickly. I've been reading here and there, on various Internet forums... Some people speak of applying multiple coats of Danish oil, several days apart. Others say that's a bad idea, as later applications will absorb little of the oil part and instead build up a larger and potentially weak or sticky film of the varnish part. (Danish "oil" contains both.) Any thoughts?

Some people speak of getting stunning finishes by largely chucking the label instructions, and wet-sanding Danish oil using some of that black, 400- or 600-grit wet/dry sandpaper, or a series of finer sandpapers. (If several grits, this makes my earlier question even more relevant.) The idea, I understand, is to fill the grains of open-grain wood with sawdust. Now, here's the thing. This desktop uses a mixture of species. From most to least, approximately: cherry (at least three shades; some might actually be apple or another fruit wood), oak, black walnut, and a bit of maple. Wet sanding would thus create a mixture of sawdust, which would then go into the grains of each species to the extent possible. With a mixture of woods, maybe the result would be spectacular - or maybe it would be awful! I could try the underside first, I suppose, but much of the underside is criss-crossed with a sturdy, arguably over-engineered frame, so there aren't any really large areas of the cutting-board style. Any thoughts on whether or not wet-sanding would work well here?

I'm particularly concerned about the edge. The desktop is fairly thick, about 1.5 inches, so there's a lot of end-grain along the edge. I've observed with other projects that Danish oil is absorbed readily into end-grain, and, no matter how much oil I apply, end-grain sections of my pieces have often ended up a bit uneven, in both look and feel. If wet-sanding would work well at all, for this piece, perhaps it would help most along the edge.

Finally, a protective finish. I like wipe-on poly, as it's easy to apply and goes on smoothly. But I don't know how strong it is. I want a tough top. Some people speak highly of this Behlen Rockhard, saying it's a bit finicky in application, but very tough. "Tough" as in "hard," at least, though not necessarily scratch-resistant. Or something like that. Any thoughts? Another idea might be wipe-on poly followed by a coat or two of paste wax. I'm open to ideas.

This desktop is arguably the most complicated piece I've done so far. It was painstakingly constructed from strips of wood that I cut from various warped, uneven boards that my dad collected from old trees he cut down on Grandpa's property. We all want to do our projects right, but this one, I especially want to do right! With a good finish, it should be very nice. So, I welcome thoughts on how to achieve this!
 

post-6909-0-54833200-1364676959_thumb.jp

If you want to keep the color pretty natural I really like the Watco butcher block oil and finish. It will build a little film if you put on enough coats, and it is wipe on. There is another product that is on my dinning room table called Breakthrough, it is a waterborne that can be brushed on and is tough as they come. It has survived 6 years of 2 kids beating on it and looks like the day it was put on. I don't remember who makes it but it came from my Pittsburgh. Paint dealer.

I don't see why you couldn't mix the danish oils. Or you can dye the project first and than apply the oil. You can apply apply a coat of oil once per day and wet sand in-between. You only have one species which is open-grained (Walnut). Sand at 400 before applying another coat of oil. If you wet sand you'll be cutting some of the danish oil down so the fact that it will be 'potentially weak' is invalid. You can of course wet sand the end-grain but gently so as not to cut the edges. End-grain soaks everything in so be sure to sand up to a higher grit before the oil. You'll survive with the wipe-on poly but I'll recommend 4 coats followed by wax. Just one coat of wax. Be sure the wait a week before applying the poly over the oil.  

 

 

However I'll like to know why you'll want to wet sand the oil. Is it for the sheen or smooth surface? Once you apply the poly that'll be lost. You can skip that part and wet-sand the poly. This'll save so much time on your finishing schedule. 

 

Be sure to do a sample piece first. One on the walnut and one on the cherry. I hope you saved your off-cuts. 

Yes you can mix various colors of Watco Danish oil, I use a separate jar for custom color. I usually start 1 part dark into 3 parts light and work-up from that.

 

Not sure you would want to wet sand the top. You'll probably get bleeding of the dark wood into the lighter wood and look smeared. (try it on some cut offs see if this happens)

 

As to the edge...again, test on a scrap. Try sanding the end-grain to higher grit of 600. Or try very carefully wiping a 1/2 pound cut of alcohol cut shellac. Or do both. TEST ON SCRAP!

 

You could try General Finishes Arm-R-Seal as a top coat. Has high solids and have use on several oak dining room tables, works really nice.

 

Keep us posted! :)

 

-Ace-

Yes you can mix various colors of Watco Danish oil, I use a separate jar for custom color. I usually start 1 part dark into 3 parts light and work-up from that.

Not sure you would want to wet sand the top. You'll probably get bleeding of the dark wood into the lighter wood and look smeared. (try it on some cut offs see if this happens)

As to the edge...again, test on a scrap. Try sanding the end-grain to higher grit of 600. Or try very carefully wiping a 1/2 pound cut of alcohol cut shellac. Or do both. TEST ON SCRAP!

You could try General Finishes Arm-R-Seal as a top coat. Has high solids and have use on several oak dining room tables, works really nice.

Keep us posted! :)

-Ace-

Do you apply the arm r seal like other wiping varnishes? Wipe on, let sit for a few mins, and then wipe off? I usually wet sand the second coat of a wiping varnish, and then apply 2 more light coats.

I may try this product. I usually use min wax wipe on poly.

Do you apply the arm r seal like other wiping varnishes? Wipe on, let sit for a few mins, and then wipe off? I usually wet sand the second coat of a wiping varnish, and then apply 2 more light coats.

I may try this product. I usually use min wax wipe on poly.

 

Nope,  I use a clean cotton rag folded nicely, dip in the finish and lay it down. Don't over work it. Get it on and let it flow out. After the finish has had time to dry, I will do a light scuff with 400 or 600 wet dry paper. Will do about 3 coats.

 

If you wipe the finish back, all your doing is removing those wonderful solids  :)

 

-Ace-

  • Author

I don't see why you couldn't mix the danish oils. Or you can dye the project first and than apply the oil. You can apply apply a coat of oil once per day and wet sand in-between. You only have one species which is open-grained (Walnut). Sand at 400 before applying another coat of oil. If you wet sand you'll be cutting some of the danish oil down so the fact that it will be 'potentially weak' is invalid. You can of course wet sand the end-grain but gently so as not to cut the edges. End-grain soaks everything in so be sure to sand up to a higher grit before the oil. You'll survive with the wipe-on poly but I'll recommend 4 coats followed by wax. Just one coat of wax. Be sure the wait a week before applying the poly over the oil.  

 

 

However I'll like to know why you'll want to wet sand the oil. Is it for the sheen or smooth surface? Once you apply the poly that'll be lost. You can skip that part and wet-sand the poly. This'll save so much time on your finishing schedule. 

 

Be sure to do a sample piece first. One on the walnut and one on the cherry. I hope you saved your off-cuts. 

 

Thanks for your remarks. I thought about wet-sanding largely because I kept seeing claims online that it gave really good results, but I wasn't actually sure precisely what those good results were. Maybe sheen, maybe smooth surface, maybe both. If those are achieved anyway by putting on a poly finish, then I'll probably just skip that part!

  • Author

Yes you can mix various colors of Watco Danish oil, I use a separate jar for custom color. I usually start 1 part dark into 3 parts light and work-up from that.

 

Not sure you would want to wet sand the top. You'll probably get bleeding of the dark wood into the lighter wood and look smeared. (try it on some cut offs see if this happens)

 

As to the edge...again, test on a scrap. Try sanding the end-grain to higher grit of 600. Or try very carefully wiping a 1/2 pound cut of alcohol cut shellac. Or do both. TEST ON SCRAP!

 

You could try General Finishes Arm-R-Seal as a top coat. Has high solids and have use on several oak dining room tables, works really nice.

 

Keep us posted! :)

 

-Ace-

Thanks for your suggestions, especially regarding the edge. I'll definitely at least sand to a higher grit, which presumably will cut down on some of the excessive absorption.

I've used a lot of Danish Oil in the past and have often mixed Watco to either darken or add a touch of red. As far as multiple applications, if you follow the direction  on the label, it works great. Also, DO NOT shortcut the drying time specified on the label. Any time I tried to finish over the Watco early, I got the sticky finish you were talking about. The Danish oil needs time for the solvents to bleed off before you seal over it. Wipe-on Poly works great over Watco, but save yourself a ton of money and just buy regular poly. If you mix poly and mineral spirits in a 50/50 ratio, you have the same thing as wipe-on poly at less than half the price. The wipe-on is just deluded product sold for more money. Some bartenders are accused of doing the same thing.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,009 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Joseph b Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.