Recommended Posts

Posted

so i have a older craftsman table saw with upgraded extentions and fence system that a i am very pleased with, it as the origanal 2hp motor on it 3400 rpm, i recently aquired a 3 hp  motor with 1700 rpm  my question is would it be adventages to change to the 3 hp ? i am thinking maybe i will loose on the rpm bot gain on the torque   the 2 hp bogs down if i am ripping large stock like a 4x

Posted

First order of business.....FIRST POST!!!! WELCOME TO SPAGNUOLO'S WIDE WORLD OF WOOD WORKING!! Good place to hang out, ask questions, and get inspired! Wow...I've just hit my 500th post....moment of silence............................. ^_^

 

Someone with some more knowledge of motors probably needs to chime in also; but I'm thinking off of the cuff that if you fit the 3HP motor with the pulleys to get the desired the 3400 rpm, that maybe you will need a larger torque motor than the 3HP or either a 3HP motor that is designed to run at 3400 rpm. In this case, you gain one more HP but you're increasing the load on it, by getting more rpms out of it. it seems like its performance (actual power to cut through thicker stock) may be about the same as the 2HP motor that you have now at its (designed) 3400rpm? :blink:

Posted

Again, wait for a motor guy to answer for real but in response to Tim, you size the pulley to allow each motor to run in its optimal range while getting the correct rpm for the arbor. The HP will show as an increase in torque. HP is the movement of mass over time. If you lengthen the time by double and still rate at 3 HP then the motor should have tremendous torque capability.

Posted

First order of business.....FIRST POST!!!! WELCOME TO SPAGNUOLO'S WIDE WORLD OF WOOD WORKING!! Good place to hang out, ask questions, and get inspired! Wow...I've just hit my 500th post....moment of silence............................. ^_^

 

Someone with some more knowledge of motors probably needs to chime in also; but I'm thinking off of the cuff that if you fit the 3HP motor with the pulleys to get the desired the 3400 rpm, that maybe you will need a larger torque motor than the 3HP or either a 3HP motor that is designed to run at 3400 rpm. In this case, you gain one more HP but you're increasing the load on it, by getting more rpms out of it. it seems like its performance (actual power to cut through thicker stock) may be about the same as the 2HP motor that you have now at its (designed) 3400rpm? :blink:

We don't care about the speed of the motor. We want to maintain the rim speed of the blade to get the proper chip load. If you cut the blade speed in half the the blade performance falls on its face. In the end we are looking for an arbor speed of 4000 to about 4500 with a 10" blade. Your going to need some oddball pulleys to get the needed arbor speed. Sounds more like a compressor motor rather than a high rpm machine motor.

Posted

thanks for the responces,  i am a carpenter and i am remodaling  a restaraunt and the motor came off of a large ac unit , couldnt i just use the same pully off the origal motor? its 2 in. in diameter

Posted

Like some of the other guys, I'm not a motor guy but I think it would be less hassle to get a thinner blade to cut your thicker material. They require less HP and make nice clean cuts. I never have been one to modify things. Somebody with a lot more knowledge than me designed the saw and when you modify it there as usually backlashes that you never dreamed of show up. Just my experience!

Posted

The pulleys drive- driven ratio would have to be changed to compensate for the motor that's only turning half the speed. To change this and get the speed you need you are going to to have to increase drive size and possibly reduce the driven side(arbor). This will in effect make the motor gearing higher but it comes with the trade off of power loss through mechanical advantage. Optimal performance is 1:1 ratio for power and torque. Just imagine it as a 10 speed bike same effect just different power transfer mechanism.

Posted

thanks for the responses. i think i am going to try it anyway it is just 4  5/16 bolts to remove and reinstall , simple easy to get to i will see how it preforms if it dosent i will switch it back to the original   

 when i have time and the energy  i am usually to tired from work to play in the garage .maybe this weekend

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   2 Members, 0 Anonymous, 54 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined