CessnaPilotBarry Posted July 13, 2013 Report Posted July 13, 2013 I'm thinking of a buying a vacuum bag system... I'd like a system that will start with a 4x4 or 5x5 bag and plate. I took a class with Steve Latta, and we used an expensive, but very effective, commercial quality bag and pump. As I do some research, I see a wide range of bag and pump prices... I don't have a problem spending money for quality. These things are deceptively simple, but we all know how easy tool manufacturers can mess up a simple device. I'd like to hear some feedback from those who own systems. Please tell me which system you have, why did you choose it, and would you buy the same system again. Quote
wdwerker Posted July 13, 2013 Report Posted July 13, 2013 I have had one for years, 5 x 12 . I got a second hand Gast vane pump , bought a bag and made my own platen. Joe Woodworker has a website with some great plans for vacuum press setups, veneer, glues, and vacuum clamping. He has some real good prices as well. I just bought a foot pedal valve for my vacuum clamp set up. I put a part on a gasketed platen, step on the foot valve and I have both hands free to route, sand and file laminate. Step again and change parts . Spend some time on Joes site and you can find a pretty complete tutorial to everything vacuum bag. He sells veneer as well Veneer supplies associated web site is his business. He answers emails pretty prompt but has no phone access because people were talking his ear off and he couldn't get any work done. He has bags in all sizes and prices. If you have a decent compressor a Venturi will give you a vacuum cheaply. Quote
Beechwood Chip Posted July 13, 2013 Report Posted July 13, 2013 Marc has a video on making a vacuum bag for veneer. Quote
dwacker Posted July 13, 2013 Report Posted July 13, 2013 I second Joes site as a source. His cheapest bags work fine and his hose connection is superior to most commercial bags. I had a big frame press, kept the pump and sold the press. I also have one of joes pumps for smaller bags and use it more than the big 10 cfm pump. My son in law has pretty much taken ownership of the big one and the little 5.5 gast has been more than enough. I would suggest Joes Rietschie Thomas refurb 3.15 for $100 and a your 4x6 bag for $140. Those and the parts kit is going to be plenty for most everyone. Stay away from the litte 1 cfm you see at places like rockler. They work but not nearly as well. Quote
Trip Posted July 13, 2013 Report Posted July 13, 2013 ==> I'm thinking of a buying a vacuum bag system... I just took the plunge -- did quite a bit of research... Turns-out that some of the top guys in veneering are right around the corner and did a site visit or two... http://www.pollaro.com/index.php Went a bit overboard and got a commercial unit that's very popular with local shops -- VacuPress 6 cfm... I also got some kit from Joe -- bags, manifold, vac-clamping pads, foot peddle, etc, etc... I went with a VacuPress pump due to reputation, local guys swear by it, high build quality, etc. Also, some of the other offerings in the field are a little DIY for my taste -- for me, down-time is more expensive than up-front cost... I only get a limited amount of shop time and don't want to fool around with flaky tools. The local guys all recommend VP for the pump... Joe is a fine source for the down-stream stuff (especially if you get several bags, manifolds, etc)... ==> If you have a decent compressor a Venturi will give you a vacuum cheaply. I did quite a bit of research on this route and almost went that way (I've got an after-cooler, separator and refrig dryer on my shop air), but decided to go stand-alone anyway. You need a refrig dryer (or better) on your shop air to get long-life out of a venturi-based unit (unless you live in Arizona).... ==> I have both hands free to route not to mention the best part -- access to the entire surface without having to move the stock, re-position clamps, etc... I've only had my system on-line for a week and it's a real time saver... Quote
CessnaPilotBarry Posted July 14, 2013 Author Report Posted July 14, 2013 Thanks, guys! The unit I used was a top of the line VacuPress belonging to a school, and it's certainly well built, but it's priced appropriately... I appreciate the info on Joe's bags. I've checked out his site, and was hoping some actual users of his stuff would chime in. My compressor is pretty ordinary, I only use it for nailing and blowguns, so I need a real pump. Also, since my shop is in my basement, the compressor cycling during the night is an issue. If I forget to turn it off, it's usually good for a foot in the side at 2 AM! Off for more reading and to check out Don's refurb tip... Quote
Trip Posted July 14, 2013 Report Posted July 14, 2013 ==> well built, but it's priced appropriately... certainly is -- on both accounts... the one thing that my site visits hit home -- avoid the entry-level 1cfm pumps if you are ever going to do projects larger than 4x4 bag, curved projects, etc. Further, if you're in it for the long run, the inexpensive DIY solutions should be avoided... They also emphasized that you can go more 'entry-level' for down-stream components -- VacuPress is very expensive for manifolds, bags, etc... They are sort of the FesTool of the vac world... Quote
CessnaPilotBarry Posted July 14, 2013 Author Report Posted July 14, 2013 I'm thinking along the lines of a 3-4, or more, CFM pump, with JW accessories. I'm not really in the mood to build a pump system myself, I think I'd rather write the check and get to using it. One thing about a single person personal shop vs. multi-person or school setting, is that I have full control over usage. In other settings, I think durability becomes more of a factor, since you've got both people who don't know what they're doing, as well as people who didn't pay for the stuff, using it. Quote
Trip Posted July 14, 2013 Report Posted July 14, 2013 ==> since you've got both people who don't know what they're doing, as well as people who didn't pay for the stuff, using it. good point... I only seem to have shop breakage when I have a helper in residence... but that could be my imagination... ==> I'm not really in the mood to build a pump system myself, I think I'd rather write the check and get to using it. that was my though exactly... Quote
Kevmc Posted July 17, 2013 Report Posted July 17, 2013 I built a joe woodworker Venturi system to use with my 4 gallon compressor. It only took about 1 hour to assemble. I have only used it a few time but ir worked great. I have a 4x8 bag and it handled the bag with ease. I would highly recommend it, especially if you have an appropriate compressor. I looked at the pump versions but decided on the simplicity of the Venturi system Quote
CessnaPilotBarry Posted July 17, 2013 Author Report Posted July 17, 2013 I built a joe woodworker Venturi system to use with my 4 gallon compressor. It only took about 1 hour to assemble. I have only used it a few time but ir worked great. I have a 4x8 bag and it handled the bag with ease. I would highly recommend it, especially if you have an appropriate compressor. I looked at the pump versions but decided on the simplicity of the Venturi system How often does the compressor cycle on? Quote
Kevmc Posted July 19, 2013 Report Posted July 19, 2013 I have only done a few small jobs but it doesn't cycle on all that much. It depends on the size of your compressor though. On my last job about every 8 to 10 min the Venturi opened up for less than 10 seconds. At that rate with a full lold in the compressor I would estimate the compressor would cycle on about once an hour. I can go do a more detailed test if you would like to confirm these numbers as they are based on my memory but I would say I was surprised by how little the compressor had to work. I have a 4 by 8 bag and when it initially evacuates the bag the compressor has to cycle on 3 or so times if I recall correctly. I have a 4 gallons compressor btw. Quote
CessnaPilotBarry Posted July 19, 2013 Author Report Posted July 19, 2013 Thanks! The more info the better! I appreciate everybody's input. Quote
Alan Bienlein Posted July 20, 2013 Report Posted July 20, 2013 Here is the system I got back in late 2008. I needed a system for a job I had that required twenty four 4 x 8 sheets of mappa burl veneer. The system has worked flawlessly and I've even used it to glue up 8" x 8" wood columns out of 3/4" pine for turning on the lathe. I also got a 54" x 109" bag with it at the time for some of the larger panels I needed to do. http://www.woodcraft.com/product/2005086/19303/vacuum-veneering-kit-with-pump-and-36-x-54-vinyl-bag.aspx Here is a link to the gallery showing the painted black columns I glued up and turned along with the size of the job I did with this system. And yes I would buy it again in a heart beat! http://www.woodtalkonline.com/gallery/member/202-alan-bienlein/ Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.