Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Finish for commercial surfaces (and oil vs. water based)

Featured Replies

So I've seen a couple of threads on here about commercial finishes, but nothing that completely answers what I need to know.

 

So what would be a good finish for cafe tables, and a coffee bar top (no alcohol in the restaurant)?  The bar won't be the actual work surface.  It will just be the part where drinks and food are placed for customers to pick up (and customers will likely lean on it a lot).  Everything will be made out of mixed hardwoods (recycled pallet wood; mostly oak, ash, maple, poplar, nothing exotic).  I am leaning toward an oil-based stain, but the color-scheme person chose a water-based color.

 

Is polyurethane a bad choice?  I don't want to use epoxies because I have zero experience with them and I don't want to deal with crazy fumes.

 

Also, what would be best if I use a water-based stain?  Or an oil-based stain?  Do you have to use the same-base finish over them?

 

And, while I'm at it, I saw this mentioned on another site: http://www.ubeaut.com.au/hardshell.htm  Anybody ever use it (or an equivalent product)?  Can it be used over oil-based stains?

FWIW for a commercial food service the wood has to be completely encapsulated. This does not mean a thick epoxy finish. Something like 5mil poly or conversion varnish would be legal. Personally Id use a two part poly. Not so hard that is going to shatter when banged up but not going to turn to mush after a few years of bleach rags.

I can't say for sure if it's FDA approved for commercial use; guessing so but not 100%..  I'd look to use a clear epoxy for the build coats and a 2-part poly for the last couple of finish coats (little to no odor at least with the epoxy).  My epoxy of choice is West System and their 207 clear hardener..  It has to be the 207 hardener; not the 205 as it's an amber finish :rolleyes:.

 

Easy to apply, provides a thick coating and will take a beating!  Let me know if you have any further Q's..  I use West System products daily :P ...

I agree with both posters above. A bar top we did nine years ago is still basically exacty the way it started after bleach, alcohol, and juices, and mostly coffee 7 days a week. The work surface failed after five years and we switched to zinc. The product we used is the famowood glaze coat. It definitely has yellowed but thats the way they like it. I have never liked the glossy nature of epoxy and find myself always wanting to dull it down. That is very hard to do with reclaimed wood. Too many bumps cracks and edges to dull down. If you need a quick and sturdy method, although not preferable, the glaze coat can hold up and be worth the investment.

I can't say for sure if it's FDA approved for commercial use; guessing so but not 100%..  I'd look to use a clear epoxy for the build coats and a 2-part poly for the last couple of finish coats (little to no odor at least with the epoxy).  My epoxy of choice is West System and their 207 clear hardener..  It has to be the 207 hardener; not the 205 as it's an amber finish :rolleyes:.

 

Easy to apply, provides a thick coating and will take a beating!  Let me know if you have any further Q's..  I use West System products daily :P ...

I really enjoyed your videos about varnishing using the epoxy build coats. Thank you for making them and other great videos.

I can't say for sure if it's FDA approved for commercial use; guessing so but not 100%..  I'd look to use a clear epoxy for the build coats and a 2-part poly for the last couple of finish coats (little to no odor at least with the epoxy).  My epoxy of choice is West System and their 207 clear hardener..  It has to be the 207 hardener; not the 205 as it's an amber finish :rolleyes:.

 

Easy to apply, provides a thick coating and will take a beating!  Let me know if you have any further Q's..  I use West System products daily :P ...

It's NSF standards. Even a good 5 mil WB poly would pass, won't last but will pass.

  • Author

wow.  thanks guys.  Some follow up questions:

 

1. Do stain and sealer have to have the same base?

 

2. Found our food code website, and says surfaces can't have pits, etc.  Our wood will be planed, but there will still be potential nail holes.  What would I use to fill it?  Would the dewaxed shellac fill it?

 

3. Can you guys recommend a 2-part poly?  I have zero knowledge of them.

 

4. We are making ten tables and an 11 foot bar.  Tables are approximately 3'x3'.  About how much sealant will that take?  i.e., do I need many gallons and therefore a company that sells larger quantities and potentially pay less per gallon, or just a couple gallons, and pay the full price per gallon?

You can top coat water based stain over solvent based and vice versa. You should fill the holes and shellac will not fill it without applying 22 coats.

Are you going to spray or brush on your products?

You can use west systems epoxy with their thickener, even add some black into the mix To fill the holes. It will make your nail holes function and look great. Just make sure your stain is dried thoroughly before you apply top coats and such. I always rub stains or dyes in. It takes the guesswork out of getting the right look on reclaimed wood. I never know what has been exposed to the wood i'm using so i always make sure to wear a respirator when planing the stuff especially pallet wood. If i were doing your project i would buy two gallons of zinnser seal coat wax free shellac. I did several cafe tables with varathane water borne poly for floors and that worked great. I like using that product for benches and booths too, dries quite hard and creates a very slippery surface. Every time i do a floor with it, i take my shoes off and see how far i can slide in my socks. Its proper jobsite etiquette. :)

  • Author

I will be brushing on.  I have no spray equipment, and no access to any or funds to rent any (if that's even possible).  And also no experience using any.

 

besides the epoxy, what else could I use to fill the holes?

I will be brushing on.  I have no spray equipment, and no access to any or funds to rent any (if that's even possible).  And also no experience using any.

 

besides the epoxy, what else could I use to fill the holes?

Besides epoxy wood filler you can use regular wood filler found at your home center.

And yes you can rent spray equipment. I've only seen Airless systems. But nothing you need to worry about right now.

  • Author

Some other questions.

1. I'm guessing the theory behind using the shellac would be "build up" coats, to get a thick finish before adding urethane. Is this correct?

2. Does anyone have a recommended non-epoxy wood filler? Will it take the stain at all? I'm not going for a pristine high end finish. The furniture is all mixed woods, so even though everything is planed, it will still look "rustic".

3. For that matter, does anyone have a recommended epoxy wood filler? What would be the benefit?

4. I watched a boatworks today video of someone applying west systems epoxy. It looked easy enough. Is it actually?

5. for the chairs, would a regular poly work?

Just some other stuff for context. None of us are remarkably skilled or professional wood workers. We are learning as we go, and this site is where I get at least half my info. The furniture is our first mass produced furniture experience and I'm running into all kinds of issues. But the furniture will still work, but will not be perfect, so the finish just needs to last, not necessarily look phenomenal. Hopefully this also explains my many questions and uneasiness with everything.

The shellac is just a barrier between the stain and top coat. If you were spraying it would be a unnecessary step. Shellac is not for build that is what the top coat is for. Take a look at famowood, stay away from home center fillers. You can also just color some plain old 5 minute epoxy with some of your stain.

1. No, shellac was only suggested as a sealer coat. If you apply it too thick it'll crack. It's a finish to be used to increase film thickness. (Don't worry about applying it too thick.)

2. Wood fillers take stain. However they are like endgrain and soak in everything thus appearing darker. Seal it first. However filler doesn't look very natural unless grained.

3. The benefit would be durability. It's harder than regular wood fillers and they don't shrink. If anything less than 1% which means fewer applications of filler. You'll find great ones that come in tubes. Bondo works great too. Both are great for repairing edges.

4. Ask him yourself. :

5. Constant kicking, constant moving, it's best to finish with same finish as the tabletops.

  • Author

Cic and pinnacle are both great. I'd use pinnacle if given the choice.

I can't find the pinnacle stuff.  it appears they were bought by another company, and I keep finding paints, not clear coats.  Where would I get the pinnacle product?

 

Also, it looked like the CIC product was water-based.  Just to be clear (and repetitive) is that going to go on fine to oil-based stain?

I can't find the pinnacle stuff.  it appears they were bought by another company, and I keep finding paints, not clear coats.  Where would I get the pinnacle product?

 

Also, it looked like the CIC product was water-based.  Just to be clear (and repetitive) is that going to go on fine to oil-based stain?

 

annex paint.

  • Author

Certain waters and oils play well and others do not. The use of shellac as a barrier product takes care of any mismatch.

Ooooohh...  Understanding now.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,011 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • bobtjanitor Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.