Recommended Posts

Posted
I've finally watched enough videos and read enough books and articles to give it a go sharpening my dull Disston D8 thumbhole rip saw.  I've got the clamp/saw holding figured out but I don't have any files.  I know I need a mill file to joint and a saw file to sharpen - the question is where's the best place to get them.
 
Also, it seems that when it comes down to reading about the quality of files made today, there just doesn't seem to be any quality available.  Before I worked up the courage I was going to see about sending it up to techno primitives to have him sharpen it.  After reading the latest file test over on SMC, I'm back to wondering if that isn't the best option.
 
BTW, Sally sells sea shells by the sea shore.
Posted

Files from Lee Valley are okay, as well as a couple of other places I'm too tired to remember right now.  Lee Valley sells a little case for saw files that's well worth it's cost.  Keeping files wrapped and not banging against other stuff in a toolbox is a must. 

 

Learn to use the whole length of the file. Some videos you see show the person using a couple of inches of the file length.  That greatly shortens the life of what you are using.

 

I'd strongly suggest learning to sharpen a chainsaw chain first.  The file pressure angle is completely different than a hand saw, but developing a feel for a file is a must. A chainsaw chain is many times easier to whet than a handsaw.  I think what made it so simple for me to learn to file a handsaw was years of filing chainsaw chains.  I sent some saws out to be sharpened and they came back ruined, so I decided to learn for myself.  It really goes pretty quickly, once you figure it out.

 

Get a couple of saws that you don't care if you screw up to start with. DON'T start with the D8.  You're going to screw some up until you learn the right angle to put pressure on the file.  I've seen the direction indicated by arrows in some treatises on the internet that are wrong.  Put a piece of white printer paper right behind the blade that you will develop the feel for the file on.  When you are throwing metal shavings on the paper the whole length of the file, without letting the file chatter from start to finish, you are starting to get it. NEVER BACK UP WITH A FILE.  It greatly reduces its life.  When you get to the end of a stroke, lift the file and go back for another stroke.

 

I like a 6" mill file for jointing, where some people use an 8".  The 6" takes a finer cut, so I feel like it gives me better control.  You need to joint first.

 

Buy a 42X off of ebay. Don't bother with the others.  If you get one with weak springs, there is a guy on there that sells replacement springs.  The anvil needs to be in good shape.  If you end up doing handsaws and fine toothed backsaws, you will need 2.  One for the little teeth will need the pusher narrowed.

 

You need a good vise.  I like ones that tilt so I can always keep the file level regardless of what angle I want to file the teeth.

 

Do a Google search on "sharpening hand saws", and print out the long treatises.  There are several really good ones.

 

You need good lighting, and good eyes.  If your eyes aren't good, get some magnifiers that work for you.  I like 2.5x dental surgery lopes, and I don't wear glasses.  You can buy them for about 60 bucks on ebay.  http://www.ebay.com/itm/140891625090  Cheap ones make my eyes tired.  The dental surgery lopes come in different focal lengths.  Figure out how far away you will work with your eyes from the teeth, and order accordingly.

 

You have to have a good vise.  There are always pages of them available on ebay at any one time.  I'll be glad to post my comments on one if you post a link.  I probably have that one too, whatever it is.

 

I like to sit down, most like to stand up.  I'll leave it here for a start but will check back.

 

http://www.toolsforworkingwood.com/store/item/EE-555-SF.XX

 

http://www.wenzloffandsons.com/component/virtuemart/tool-care/files-files.html

 

http://www.vintagesaws.com/library/primer/sharp.html

 

http://www.norsewoodsmith.com/content/sharpening-hand-saws

Posted

Here's my favorite type of vise.  A Stearns, with levers for tilt adjustment, and saw clamping.  Make sure it's complete, with no breaks, and the C-clamp screw is complete without a lost pad.  This one looks pretty good. A lot of people think one that supports the whole length of blade if best, but it only takes a few seconds to move the blade along in one of these.  This actually works best for me since I sit down.  One of these days I'll own an Acme, but it's not a priority.  The old Stearns works just fine.  I wouldn't bother to make one for what you can buy an old one for.

 

http://www.ebay.com/itm/Antique-Stearns-Saw-Sharpening-Vise-Syracuse-NY-Tool-/110966275146?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item19d61afc4a

 

Here's a good video.  I use blocks on the end of the file much like this guy.  My only difference is that I drill the hole for the file at the fleam angle.  Since he's filing a rip saw, the fleam angle is 90 anyway.  Also, instead of a guide to slide along the saw to indicate fleam angle for a crosscut saw, I have boards in my Saw Sharp toolbox with different fleam angles drawn on it.  I lay that behind the saw, and it makes a good visual reference that you don't have to keep moving.  A vise that is sturdy, like the old iron ones, makes for a better vise than a tall wooden one that shakes.

 

http://blip.tv/hand-tools-techniques/episode-7-sharpening-part-3-2608210

 

Once you can take full light to heavy cuts with the file on the old beater saw, throw it away or pass it on, and buy this one to learn to do the whole process on:  http://www.ebay.com/itm/Vintage-26-Sandvik-270-Swedish-Hand-Saw-7-Teeth-8-Point-Etched-Wood-Handle-/321181034616?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item4ac7e1a878

 

I had Hall's Arkansas Stones make a set of triangular stones for me to see if I could get a saw much sharper than with a file.  I can get a saw sharper than anyone with them, but that sharp doesn't last long enough to be worth the extra effort, unless maybe it's for some few cuts in something really valuable-haven't really needed it yet.   http://www.hallsproedge.com/index.php

Posted

Don't get obsessed over the saw file quality issue. Leave that to the people on SMC.  This will be an issue if you are sharpening a lot of saws for others. Although the quality of the files is not as good as in the old days, they will be good enough for personal use.

 

And keep in mind what Joel Moskowitz said about saw sharpening: "A poorly sharpened saw will still work better than a dull saw."

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   2 Members, 0 Anonymous, 59 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined