Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Curly walnut small dining room table

Featured Replies

I'm a relative novice at woodworking. Most of my experience is in turning, but I'm trying to branch out and am building my first piece of furniture. I stumbled across some beautiful curly walnut. I've just completed my glue-up, and will be cutting it into a round, 40" table top.

 

I've spent the past few days reading about finishing walnut, and have succeeded in getting even more confused as to how to approach the job.  I want a very glossy finish that shows what I hope will be a lot of chatoyance in the wood. 

 

I've read that it's unnecessary to use dyes on walnut as you would on maple. Is this true?

 

I think, from what I've read, a coat of BLO, followed by a coat of shellac (multiple coats?), followed by a number of coats of high gloss lacquer would be a reasonable way to go - but again, at this point, I'm very flustered.

 

Any help would be appreciated. The curly walnut is really beautiful, and I don't want to mess it up.

Dye will help show off the figure and even out the color in the boards.  A CAB lacquer will be clear letting you build it up to a clear high gloss. Id skip the shellac and use the right sealer for the lacquer you choose.

  • Author

Dye will help show off the figure and even out the color in the boards.  A CAB lacquer will be clear letting you build it up to a clear high gloss. Id skip the shellac and use the right sealer for the lacquer you choose.

Would you dye the BLO? Also, what about sealing the grain? I've read all sorts of ways to pack the pores to get a mirror-like finish. Will this hurt the chatoyance? 

Would you dye the BLO? Also, what about sealing the grain? I've read all sorts of ways to pack the pores to get a mirror-like finish. Will this hurt the chatoyance? 

 

I wouldnt use BLO at all. You can get grain fillers but again get one you know is compatible with your Lacquer. Most of the better grain fillers like from SW can be tinted with wiping stain which will highlight the grain.

 

Something like Sherwood Natural Filler, Sherwood Vinyl sealer, Sherwood cab acrylic will make a nice high gloss finish. You can have the filler tinted to match the wetted wood. Or you can skip the filler and just seal then build the top coat until its smooth. The only real drawback is the amount of work involved AND with most CAB lacquers you should not exceed 4 mils dry. 4 mils may not be enough to fill the grain. You cant just pile CAB on like you can Nitro and expect to get any life out of the finish.

 

Thought I would add. If your weather is anything like ours you will want to make sure add a retarder to your lacquer. Sure would be a shame to go through all that work and end up with even the slightest blushing.

In terms of filling the grain, I just went through this so I'll share my experience.  I used a product called Timbermate (recommended to me by Marc).  Here's a link to it at woodcraft:

 

http://www.woodcraft.com/category/2020580/timbermate-water-based-wood-filler.aspx

 

I used the ebony color because I like how it popped the pores a little, but you could just as easily use the walnut color to kind of hide them, or you could mix a custom color with dyes.  This stuff was much easier to work with than the other pore fillers I tried (in particular Crystalac - a product that I tried and absolutely hated).  You spread it on, squeegee it off, then sand the excess in about 30-60 minutes.  It sands easily and doesn't clog paper.

 

I did two coats of this, and I probably should've done a third, as there were still some pores that weren't completely filled, but I still was happy with the result.  It definitely didn't ruin the chatoyance at all (at least in my opinion).  I top coated with Arm-R-Seal gloss, but lacquer would be fine too.  

 

I'd skip the dye because I really like the natural walnut color, but that's a personal choice.

 

EDIT:  There are some pics of my finished product in this post:  

Dont use colored Timbermate with solvent lacquer or vinyl sealer if its humid and you use retarder. It will lift the color into the finish.

Timbermate works well with waterbourne finishes. It smells funny and the smell lingers quite a while. After 37 years of woodworking, dust etc I do not have the most sensitive nose. Nice stuff but stinky. Dries quick, stains well, sands easyily,never had it let loose either.

I would take Particle Boards word on using it with lacquer , when experience speaks LISTEN!

Timbermate works well with waterbourne finishes. It smells funny and the smell lingers quite a while. After 37 years of woodworking, dust etc I do not have the most sensitive nose. Nice stuff but stinky. Dries quick, stains well, sands easyily,never had it let loose either.

I would take Particle Boards word on using it with lacquer , when experience speaks LISTEN!

 

+1 on the stinky.  It definitely smells pretty bad, and Like Steve said, it definitely lingers - not on the piece itself, but in your shop.  Also, when I said it was easy to work with, it's all relative - pore filling is a PIA.  The results are awesome, but be prepared for a somewhat frustrating experience.  Two other tips if you're working with timbermate:  

 

1.  Work on a small area at a time.  Stuff dries VERY fast.  Faster than you can work, probably.

2.  Take your time getting it to the proper consistency.  It should be like pancake batter.  Keep adding a little water at a time and mixing it.  Trying to mix it by hand is terrible - I chucked my wife's electric mixer attachment (don't tell her!) in my hand drill and used that.  MUCH faster and easier.  

  • Author

+1 on the stinky.  It definitely smells pretty bad, and Like Steve said, it definitely lingers - not on the piece itself, but in your shop.  Also, when I said it was easy to work with, it's all relative - pore filling is a PIA.  The results are awesome, but be prepared for a somewhat frustrating experience.  Two other tips if you're working with timbermate:  

 

1.  Work on a small area at a time.  Stuff dries VERY fast.  Faster than you can work, probably.

2.  Take your time getting it to the proper consistency.  It should be like pancake batter.  Keep adding a little water at a time and mixing it.  Trying to mix it by hand is terrible - I chucked my wife's electric mixer attachment (don't tell her!) in my hand drill and used that.  MUCH faster and easier.  

Thanks for the advice. BTW, beautiful table you made!

  • Author

Thanks!

One more question - how much did you sand prior to using the timbermate pore filler?

Hey Chris,

 

Right out front let me say I'm by no means an expert - but this is the procedure that worked for me (Marc guided me along the way), and I was happy with the end result.  

 

I sanded my usual 80-120-150-220 (I go to 220 only because it seems to be readily available for 6" ROS, whereas I can't seem to find 180).  I then applied a coat of timbermate.  When you first apply it, it will probably give you a heart attack because it will look like you just ruined your nice table top.  Not to worry - it sands fairly easily.  You can either load it on thick and have more sanding to do, or you can do it thinner and have less sanding but more applications.  I chose the former.  I loaded it on pretty thick, rubbed it into the surface, and then squeegeed it off.  The nice thing about timbermate is that it reconstitutes forever.  So you can squeegee the excess right back into your container.  Even if it dries up you can always add water and get it going again.

 

I let that dry for about an hour (though it was dry to the touch in 10-15min), then I sanded at 220 again (with my ROS - I wouldn't want to hand sand this on anything but the smallest project).  Make sure you wear a respirator because the dust is kind of nasty.  If you use colored timbermate then it will be pretty clear when you're done sanding because you'll only see the color in the pores.  Clean the dust off with a brush attachment on your vac, then rinse and repeat.  Do as many applications as necessary to fill the pores.  A nice way to test it is to drag your fingernail across the grain.  With every application you will feel it getting caught in the pores less (compare it with a bare piece of walnut).

 

I did two applications, then went right to my Arm-R-Seal gloss.  Probably should've done three applications, but I was still happy with the result.

 

And remember - this stuff sands fairly easily so even if you do an application and HATE the way it looks, just pop 80 grit on your sander and go back down to bare wood.  No harm no foul.

 

Good luck!

  • Author

Hey Chris,

 

Right out front let me say I'm by no means an expert - but this is the procedure that worked for me (Marc guided me along the way), and I was happy with the end result.  

 

I sanded my usual 80-120-150-220 (I go to 220 only because it seems to be readily available for 6" ROS, whereas I can't seem to find 180).  I then applied a coat of timbermate.  When you first apply it, it will probably give you a heart attack because it will look like you just ruined your nice table top.  Not to worry - it sands fairly easily.  You can either load it on thick and have more sanding to do, or you can do it thinner and have less sanding but more applications.  I chose the former.  I loaded it on pretty thick, rubbed it into the surface, and then squeegeed it off.  The nice thing about timbermate is that it reconstitutes forever.  So you can squeegee the excess right back into your container.  Even if it dries up you can always add water and get it going again.

 

I let that dry for about an hour (though it was dry to the touch in 10-15min), then I sanded at 220 again (with my ROS - I wouldn't want to hand sand this on anything but the smallest project).  Make sure you wear a respirator because the dust is kind of nasty.  If you use colored timbermate then it will be pretty clear when you're done sanding because you'll only see the color in the pores.  Clean the dust off with a brush attachment on your vac, then rinse and repeat.  Do as many applications as necessary to fill the pores.  A nice way to test it is to drag your fingernail across the grain.  With every application you will feel it getting caught in the pores less (compare it with a bare piece of walnut).

 

I did two applications, then went right to my Arm-R-Seal gloss.  Probably should've done three applications, but I was still happy with the result.

 

And remember - this stuff sands fairly easily so even if you do an application and HATE the way it looks, just pop 80 grit on your sander and go back down to bare wood.  No harm no foul.

 

Good luck!

thanks

Its alot easier to just sand to 150. Dump filler in a bucket and thin. Use a old 4" course paint brush and just slop it on like you did in first grade. Let it dry and screen off the top with a drywall screen. I have a drywall block that hooks to my shop vac for grain filler. Once you knock off the top sand up through your grits as usual. You will see any scratches or sander swirls as you move through the grits. This will get it first try no need to re coat. 

  • Author

Ok, sanded the bare wood to 220 and used the Timbermate pore filler. Did a final sanding all the way to 400 grit. I used the ebony Timbermate, and the wood really darkened after the Timbermate. I was a little nervous that it was too dark, but once I put the first coat of Waterlox sealer on, it looked great.

 

I allowed it to dry overnight, and checked it this morning. What had looked like a very even application of the sealer when it was wet is now sort of blotchy.  It's dry (though I won't be messing with it til tonight to give it 24 hours drying time), but the sealer soaked into the wood unevenly. I've never used Waterlox sealer - is this normal? There are portion that have a nice, sealed sheen, but other areas in which the sealer soaked in completely and the wood still looks bare. There are also what look like small bubble marks.  The directions on the Waterlox can don't mention sanding between coats. Any recomendations? Just put a second coat on without sanding? Light sand at 400 grit dry? Wet sand?

 

When I first put the sealer on last night, the table looked great. I don't want to mess it up when I'm so close. Any thoughts would be appreciated.

Yup, as PB said, just keep going with your coats and it will even out. Same thing happened to me with the arm r seal. I should've mentioned that. It evened out after the second coat. Be sure to post pics of the finished product!

  • Author

Yup, as PB said, just keep going with your coats and it will even out. Same thing happened to me with the arm r seal. I should've mentioned that. It evened out after the second coat. Be sure to post pics of the finished product!

Thanks. Will probably be a few more nights before I can finish the top, then I need to construct the base. So won't be completely finished for another 2 weeks or so. Let you know how it comes out. Thanks again for your help.

  • 4 weeks later...

Hit the "more reply options" button, which is right next to the "post" button. 

Host them someplace and then post here.  I use imageshack but, there are lots of places.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,009 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Joseph b Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.