Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Pellet/Corn stove or wood stove?

Featured Replies

Good afternoon,

 

We just signed the papers for our new house... close december 6th. New home has a 2 stall detached shop that will be dedicated for my woodworking. I am planning on putting in a heating source (live in ND)...  I am a big fan of using the scap wood for heat as well as eventually get my own pellet mill and create my own pellets from sawdust... grass clippings and leaves...Here are my thought options...

 

1. Gas heater.

 

- can set it up with a thermostat and can keep it warm all the time

 

2. Wood Stove and gas heater

 

- base load with the wood stove and still have the thermostat of the gas stove

 

3. Pellet stove and gas heater

 

- thermostat on both

 

4. Wood stove.

 

- no way of keeping it going.... must keep stoking the fire

 

5. pellet stove.

 

- thermostat

 

 

I should mention I do have the ability to get wood pellets very cheap.

 

 

I am leaning towards installing a wood pellet stove first with a thermostat and then MAYBE a gas unit for peaking heat if needed.

I burn wood (solid fuel) in my home, and I love it. All scraps become kindling, and the heat from a wood stove is beautiful.

In my shop I have an electric radiant heater, but it is not really adequate in the coldest nights of winter. I would put a wood stove in my shop as well, if I were to be in there full time. You are correct, you need someone to be there to load and stoke it. Mine is good for 8 hours or so unattended, but after that it needs a reload.

A pellet stove is nice in that you can have it auto feed. You are then reliant on another purchased fuel source however, unless you produce your own pellets like you have indicated.

I have a wall mount propane heater and it keeps the shop at a minimum temp when I am not in the shop and it comes up to comfort level quickly. The pellet stove can do the same and with a continuous feeder it would be about the same as propane. I would pick one method to keep the costs low. just like tools, it is better to buy once than several times.

BRuce

I heat my 36x 36  insulated shop with a woodstove I live in Washington State and, I'm able to get free wood I have to cut, haul and split it, but I like doing it I maybe go through between 1-2 cords a year I only have the stove going when I'm in the shop. The shop heats up and is t-shirt comfortable in less than an hour even in the coldest times in western Washington we only get down to the teens hardly ever get below zero.

http://www.woodtalkonline.com/uploads/gallery/album_838/gallery_2926_838_61073.jpg

  • Author

I heat my 36x 36  insulated shop with a woodstove I live in Washington State and, I'm able to get free wood I have to cut, haul and split it, but I like doing it I maybe go through between 1-2 cords a year I only have the stove going when I'm in the shop. The shop heats up and is t-shirt comfortable in less than an hour even in the coldest times in western Washington we only get down to the teens hardly ever get below zero.

 

 

Higtron,

 

do you see issues with condensation when the temperature fluctuates or does your stove keep it 50+ 24/7?

 

how often do you have to re-stoke? 

 

Also, how about the distance away from the combustibles? is that a code or per each unit's manufactures directions?

I wouldn't give up my gas fired furnace for anything. Convenient, and easy and the shop never freezes. I have no idea what it costs me per month but if i were to guess 20 bucks per month in the winter. Just my 2 cents.

I've had many different shops, all the condensation issues were because of lack of insulation and in some of the shops part of the problem was water wicking up through the concrete slab. When I built my shop I installed a vapor barrier under my shop slab insulated the shop walls and, ceiling to R-19 I can leave the shop with no heat for over a month at a time when work or life gets in the road and, I've never had condensation in my new shop at all. Now about the stove I only use it when I'm actually out there and only when it gets cold enough for me to feel I need a coat on so I've never ran the stove 24/7 when in use I stoke maybe every 2-3 hours. I think all the condensation issues I've had in the past was rapid temperature changes like when it has been in the teens for days and, suddenly it gets to above freezing overnight or something like that with the new shop being insulated whatever the temps are doing outside the shift in the shop happens a lot slower so nothing condensates on my cast iron surfaces.  

Oh I forgot got your combustible distances from the stove question In our state 18" from stove is the code so that's 18" walls now my stove is closer than 18" from the wall so as a per code precaution I installed two sheets of hardi backer board I used two 3/4 nuts as spacers with the screws going through the backer through the nuts into the dry wall into the framing. The theory is the backer can heat up and the dead air space behind the backer dissipates the heat whenever I've checked the heat shield backer board it never  seemed extremely hot to the touch I could hold my hand on it without yelling hot! hot! hot! and I try to keep a wood 18" away.

I've got one friend who heats with a wood and one who heats his shop with both wood and pellets....  Both love their setups and maintain that theirs is the 'best' method....

 

My friend who burns wood has two Vermont Castings Defiant stoves... he loves them...  His shop sits on a lot with 20 acres of hardwood...

 

My friend who heats with pellets uses one wood burning Vermont Castings Defiant and one Vogelzang pellet stove...  His 'hybrid' approach allows him to burn pellets when they are cheap, and wood when they are not...  I don't know much about the cost of pellets, but I've been told that it fluctuates quite a bit-- something to consider... 

 

BTW -- both have gas as a 'backup' for when they travel, are sick, just don't fell like stoking for a day or two, etc...  

I could see pluses and minuses to each, with a wood stove if you start burning kiln dried scraps your going to go through a LOT. That would will burn fast because it's so dry so you really need a supply of good seasoned firewood. That means cutting wood or buying it. Pellets, unless your making your own that's another expense, I think if I had the options I would just go with a gas furnace. You can get a programmable thermostat to help keep costs down by turning the temp down while your away, maybe a wood stove to help because I love the smell of a fireplace, but when I was growing up that's all we had, a fireplace in winter and fans in the summer, and I'm only 35!

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

  • There are no registered users currently online

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.