Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

How much it costs to have a new cutter-head installed

Featured Replies

I contacted an authorized, Powermatic service center in my area (Midwest).

I wanted to see what it would cost to have them replace the cutter-head on a jointer and planer.

Not including the cost of the cutter-head:

$85.00 an hour

Jointer: 6 hours

Planer: 11 hrs

Seems like a long time. There are many here who like to buy used machines, including myself.

So if you weren't comfortable tackling the work yourself, the answer might be sticking to a straight-knifed jointer and purchasing a new planer with the helical head already installed.

It would be a nightmare going through the trouble of buying a used machine, buying a new cutter-head, trying to install it yourself, only to find out you cannot complete the task.

Couple of points....

 

a. it's rather straight-forward to do yourself.

b. there are several YouTube videos demonstrating the process, so you can judge project complexity for yourself

c. it does take longer for a planer than a jointer

d. you could probably do both in 4-7 hrs depending on how handy you are.

 

The only 'specialty tool' you need is a bearing puller...  Or if you order from Byrd, they'll deliver a complete head with bearings in a kit for a little more $$ -- worth it.

The worst such job I've had is changing the fuel injectors in my truck.  It's a Duramax diesel, 13 years old.  Injectors cost $1326 for the complete set and install kit.  The dealer wanted 5 grand plus extras, so the math worked out that I did it myself. I found detailed instructions, with pictures, on an internet Forums. Being slow and meticulous, it took a day to break it down, and almost another day to install the new ones, and get it back together.

 

I would expect getting a manufacturer to change a cutter head, would be comparable to getting a dealer to change my fuel injectors.

 

I like straight knife jointers and planers because it's so quick and easy to change the knives.

I contacted an authorized, Powermatic service center in my area (Midwest).

I wanted to see what it would cost to have them replace the cutter-head on a jointer and planer.

Not including the cost of the cutter-head:

$85.00 an hour

Jointer: 6 hours

Planer: 11 hrs

Seems like a long time. There are many here who like to buy used machines, including myself.

So if you weren't comfortable tackling the work yourself, the answer might be sticking to a straight-knifed jointer and purchasing a new planer with the helical head already installed.

It would be a nightmare going through the trouble of buying a used machine, buying a new cutter-head, trying to install it yourself, only to find out you cannot complete the task.

 

Those labor times are WAAY out of line even for on site service. They would have to be charging you for at least two lunch hours, a few coffee breaks and maybe even a trip to the strip club. If you know what your doing and have the proper equipment you can do a PM 12" jointer in under an hour and a 20" planer in under 2 hours. I paid right at $380 labor which included travel charge and the guy was done and gone well before lunch for both machines.

  • Author

I got the feeling they were trying to discourage upgrading in favor of just buying a new machine with the desired cutter-head installed.

His first words were, 'it's pretty expensive.' You'd think that would be the easiest thing they do.

Particle,

That is an unbelievable price.

Geeze, was he a friend of yours?

Even if one were to upgrade a used machine, you won't always save that much. Comparatively speaking, you might save yourself between $500-$1000 per machine when you factor in replacement parts and the costs associated with the time and trouble of picking up a second or third hand machine. And you haven't installed the cutter-head yet. Is the savings worth it compared to buying a new machine with a warranty? You have to get past the fact that newer machines aren't made like they used to.

As far as video tutorials are concerned, there are several videos demonstrating planer upgrades. In real time too. But jointers, I found none without time lapse. Missing video in the form of 'time lapse' skips over the most important parts.

Particle,

That is an unbelievable price.

Geeze, was he a friend of yours?

 

 

No not a friend or even that great of a price your just being so over quoted it sounds like such a good deal.

I contacted an authorized, Powermatic service center in my area (Midwest).

I wanted to see what it would cost to have them replace the cutter-head on a jointer and planer.

Not including the cost of the cutter-head:

$85.00 an hour

Jointer: 6 hours

Planer: 11 hrs

Seems like a long time. There are many here who like to buy used machines, including myself.

So if you weren't comfortable tackling the work yourself, the answer might be sticking to a straight-knifed jointer and purchasing a new planer with the helical head already installed.

It would be a nightmare going through the trouble of buying a used machine, buying a new cutter-head, trying to install it yourself, only to find out you cannot complete the task.

 

Was that for replacing the heads on a modern machine? .  I ask because you mentioned used machines.  I don't really know how much they have changed over the years, but I could see replacing the heads on a modern machine being a lot faster than on someting built who knows when.   

Would modern machines be "that" different, though, at least when it comes to the cutter? My jointer is a few decades old and the installation is just two bearing blocks holding the cutter, not very different from newer ones I've looked at.

I don't know, I haven't worked on any old machines.  But like anything else, if a guy is bidding a job and he is done the identical job 100 times, it will be a lower bid.  If a guy is bidding a job on a machine he has never worked on the price will go up to cover any unknowns.  Parts don't fit, rusty nuts, something cracks, you know the drill.    I am trying understand why your estimate is so much higher than what others have experienced.  That might be one reason. 

==> I contacted an authorized, Powermatic service center in my area (Midwest).

==> I wanted to see what it would cost to have them replace the cutter-head on a jointer and planer.

 

 

==> I am trying understand why your estimate is so much higher than what others have experienced

 

 

 

What are the actual model numbers of your jointer/planer...

I don't really think its going to make that much difference. My machines were brand new. That being said even older machines would not take near that amount of time. 6 hours for a jointer head is crazy unless your trying to sign up for Obama Care while changing the head. Im sure the same guy has some great ocean front property in Arizona that he will give you a great deal on while he is working on your machines.   

 

The biggest job Ive done to date on a machine was to change the bed assembly (complete) and cutter head on a Jet 20" planer which required the complete machine be tore down. That took a 1/2 day, 2 pots of coffee, no experience and a mess of improper tools.

==> even older machines would not take near that amount of time

 

Don't get me wrong, I agree completely that the numbers quoted to the OP are not even realistic.  I'm only wondering if he has something really old and the tech might not have seen before so he hedged his bet...  PM's been around long enough to have babbitt bearings (used them in planers through the '50s)... or maybe something else not seen recently...  Just hoping it's something unusual and not simply the PM tech gouging a customer...

I was curious because I plan on having my powermatic jointer upgraded.  I called the closest authorized service center (which is about 60 miles from my house).   It is a new machine, about 1 year old.   Long story short he said it takes about "an hour and 25 minutes, I charge $65 an hour so lets just call it $75 if you bring it to me."  If he came out to my shop he'd charge for commuting time.  

 

I'd get another estimate, if you can. 

Sounds like they figured it for the OP about like the dealer did for my fuel injector job-about four times as much time as someone good at doing the job could do it in.  Maybe that's the way I should start charging instead of double the time that I think I can do a job in.

  • Author

I told the guy it was for a Delta DJ20 just to get a ballpark figure of what I was dealing with.

On hindsight, I should have asked for a Powermatic.

I called 2 authorized centers so I could compare quotes.

The first guy never called me back, the second guy apparently tried to take my savings.

Going to call a few more, this time I'll ask for a 5-year old Powermatic.

I guess if worse comes to worse, I could always travel to Woodsap's guy (only 4-5 hours away).

I wouldn't know anyone else to call besides an authorized service center.

If Powermatic is this bad, there's no telling what I'd be dealing with if I went elsewhere.

I told the guy it was for a Delta DJ20 just to get a ballpark figure of what I was dealing with.

On hindsight, I should have asked for a Powermatic.

I called 2 authorized centers so I could compare quotes.

The first guy never called me back, the second guy apparently tried to take my savings.

Going to call a few more, this time I'll ask for a 5-year old Powermatic.

I guess if worse comes to worse, I could always travel to Woodsap's guy (only 4-5 hours away).

I wouldn't know anyone else to call besides an authorized service center.

If Powermatic is this bad, there's no telling what I'd be dealing with if I went elsewhere.

 

I think if you can run the machines you can change out a head yourself. You may have to take it to a machine shop for the bearing swap but that should make it an easy job. The only reason I paid to have mine done was my machines were brand new and I wanted to preserve the warranty.

==> The only reason I paid to have mine done was my machines were brand new and I wanted to preserve the warranty.

 

That's a good point...  Didn't think of that..

 

@OP.  You maybe over-thinking this... If you're reasonably handy and have some basic tools, you should not have any problems...  Seriously, many folks have done it themselves...  If you've set-up the machine you should be able to swap the head...  The only unusual thing is dealing with the bearings.  Before I got myself a bearing puller, I just took the head my local auto-repair guy and gave him $5 to pull... He would have done it for free (it only takes about a minute), but wanted to pay him something...  If the machine has a few years of use, I'd just order the head with the bearing kit -- it's only a hew more $$ and will remove all complexity...  The jointer is really easy and straight-forward.  I'd give it a go.  With that one under your belt, the planer is only slightly more involved due to planer's alignment procedure...

  • Author

I'm thinking worse case...what if I get stuck, what will I do then.

I get stuck all the time on projects and have nowhere to go. The know-how just isn't out there.

I'm talking about doing things right. Take home improvement for example.

If you find 10 different ways to do the same project, chances are none of them are correct.

Look at all the utube videos on how to change the cutter-head on a jointer.

The only hopeful 'how to video' is proprietary where the intent is selling their product.

I do appreciate the help. :)

I contacted 2 other outfits within 50 miles radius. One told me he had never heard of anyone wanting to change out a cutter-head in a jointer in the 35 years he's been doing it. The other recommended I contact a local woodworking store or lumber yard and inquire since his store doesn't specialize on woodworking equipment. Both of these guys were on Powermatic's authorized center list. I also contacted one of Delta's authorized service centers and he told me they didn't do that sort of work. They were more parts oriented.

There's not a lot of effort to keep these lists updated. If I OWNED Powermatic or Delta I wouldn't trust warranty work on a business that had never heard of replacing a cutter-head on a jointer. I just don't get it. It's no wonder these businesses change hands so often or go bankrupt.

That's the problem with today's business.

There's just no pride to back up one's business.

You can't have just greed, it doesn't work.

But stupidity is the backbone of this wonderful country (government). :)

I'm thinking worse case...what if I get stuck, what will I do then.

I get stuck all the time on projects and have nowhere to go. The know-how just isn't out there.

 

 

You can buy me a plane ticket and a thick T-bone medium rare worse case, but really I think you can handle it.

  • Author

You can buy me a plane ticket and a thick T-bone medium rare worse case, but really I think you can handle it.

LOL!

Thanks Particle I appreciate that.

On a side note...  If you can't buy the new cutter head with new bearings installed, and you don't know any auto mechanics, many auto parts stores rent, or sometimes even loan, tools like bearing pullers.   Since you can carry the old cutter head around, you may even be able to get a counter person to pull the bearings on the spot,  with the offer of a "tip".

 

Look here, for an exploded view of a typical cutter head installation...   I'm with the others who think you can do this yourself.   If you have any friends or family members who do basic auto, motorcycle, or even riding mower maintenance, maybe an offer of pizza and beverages to assist you will relieve some of the anxiety.  

 

Also, take digital photos as you remove each part, you'll have a step-by-step record for reassembly.

 

You can probably see exploded views of your exact machines at ereplacementparts.com, if you no longer have the manuals.

  • Author

Thanks Cessna,

Everything happens with the cutter-head removed.
I can take it anywhere...good point.

I just have to put the assembly back into the machine and hope that it fits.  
Worse case I can always put the original cutter-head back in, as long as it goes back in okay.   :lol:

Nothing ventured nothing gained, it's just the older I get the less I seem to gain.

 

Thanks for the help gentlemen.   :)

  • 1 month later...
  • Author

Thanks woodsap.  Have not gone there yet, but I'm definitely going to do it when the time comes.  How can you not with all this support?  

Appreciate you digging this up to add further comment.  Good job on the install..3 hrs, I'd be happy with that! 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,011 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • bobtjanitor Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.