Recommended Posts

Posted

I think one point people argue with Snodgrass is the subject of coplanar wheels and how they're set a certain way - where someone always claims that there was an defect with their wheels from the factory - and I think they're interpreting him a little too literally. Of course there will be an issue if the wheels weren't set right to begin with (to which he even says to call the manufacturer first), but sometimes I think people dive in, go messing around with a good unit and applying a solution in search of a problem.

 

Ultimately my thoughts on drift is even if drift can be eliminated with proper tuning, sometimes it's just quicker to just adjust for the drift and get back to work.

Posted

==>The only trickery in the show if you want to call it that

I'm not sure 'trickery' is quite what I'm going for... My concern is more along the lines of transparency...

 

The blanket assertion that folks who don't do things his way, "Don't know what they are talking about" is not a good way to start a demo... He should state somewhere during the talk that his process is geared toward the saws he's demoing and may not work on others... Again, let him come to my shop and remove a 160lb table every time he wants to change a blade... :)

 

His process would impress me far more if he were to walk the show floor and stop at a random booth and tune a random saw with a random blade and make a bandsaw box on the first go... Now that would be impressive... but also unlikely...

 

If he was a bit more transparent on the limitations of his process, I'd give it a pass...

Posted

I think one point people argue with Snodgrass is the subject of coplanar wheels and how they're set a certain way - where someone always claims that there was an defect with their wheels from the factory - and I think they're interpreting him a little too literally. Of course there will be an issue if the wheels weren't set right to begin with (to which he even says to call the manufacturer first), but sometimes I think people dive in, go messing around with a good unit and applying a solution in search of a problem.

 

Ultimately my thoughts on drift is even if drift can be eliminated with proper tuning, sometimes it's just quicker to just adjust for the drift and get back to work.

 

I think so many cause issues by adding riser blocks. Second cast iron from some of the cheaper manufacturers is not seasoned prior to milling. On the other hand most of the time coplanar is not an issue unless your having series problems.

 

It ONLY takes two things to make a saw work properly as long as its not a twisted piece of junk. Thats a good blade properly tracked.

 

The issue is that even the instruction manual on most saws tell you to track the blade improperly. IMO this is so that they can overstate the max blade width as marketing hype. So if you do the real measuring you measure from the center of the crowned tire to the back edge of the wheel that measurement plus the gullet depth is the true max blade width of your saw.

So for example:

Your tires are 3/4" wide.

Your blade is 3/4" wide

Your gullet is 1/8" deep

 

You can't use that blade and track it properly. The reasoning is you have 3/8" max plus the gullet. On that 3/4 blade with an 1/8" gullet you need 5/8 plus the 1/8" gullet. If I overstate the max blade width and tell you to run it in the center it will fit but the blade will not track properly. Most saws are overstated by 1/4" and have been for many years.

 

There is no such thing as tuning a band saw. All the adjustments are at the users discretion as to the individual needs. As far as blades and tracking again all you need is a good blade tracked properly. Good blades are hard to come by in todays mass produced order from the internet world.  Even with a properly tracked blade a poor weld job may cause drift thus why you see so many just dealing with it and moving the fence to the drift.

Posted

One thing he never mentions in that video, is adjusting the fence to be perpendicular to the blade. It's a pretty crucial step if you want good resaw results. 

 

Because it has nothing to do with it and its not crucial at all. 

Posted

==>adjusting the fence to be perpendicular to the blade

On a bandsaw, the table is the reference surface. It's more important to get the blade cutting perpendicular to the table... Some veneer gurus use the 'single-point-fence' with great success...

Posted

==>I think so many cause issues by adding riser blocks. 

I agree with where your point is going, but to clarify: it's not riser-blocks themselves, but the notion that adding a riser-block to a 3/4HP saw somehow allows the user to veneer a 12" Hard Maple slab... That, and insufficient frame strength, will leave you with a right mess...

 

On the other hand, I've seen some vintage saws (read as rigid frames) with added riser blocks and upgraded motors work just fine... But at that point, you might as well get yourself a proper re-saw... :)

Posted

==>I think so many cause issues by adding riser blocks. 

I agree with where your point is going, but to clarify: it's not riser-blocks themselves, but the notion that adding a riser-block to a 3/4HP saw somehow allows the user to veneer a 12" Hard Maple slab... That, and insufficient frame strength, will leave you with a right mess...

 

On the other hand, I've seen some vintage saws (read as rigid frames) with added riser blocks and upgraded motors work just fine... But at that point, you might as well get yourself a proper re-saw... :)

 

My point with the riser blocks is the installer not getting the saw put back together straight. If the pins are not put in the block perfectly the saw ill be out of wack. Cheap riser block kits dont always have the pins drilled properly. If this is is the case then coplanar needs to be adjusted at the wheel.

Posted

==>getting the saw put back together straight

Haven't seen that one yet... Maybe the folks I deal with are a bit more handy :)  But you're right, that would be bad...

Posted

==>getting the saw put back together straight

Haven't seen that one yet... Maybe the folks I deal with are a bit more handy :)  But you're right, that would be bad...

 

It really has nothing to do with the guy installing the block but more so the block itself. if its not machined to perfectly match the saw it will always be off. The guy installing the block is just causing the problem buy using an improperly machined block. Jet blocks are horrible Id assume it pretty much across the board. You have to check the saw before and after installing the block.

Posted

Because it has nothing to do with it and its not crucial at all. 

I'm not sure what you mean by this. Please educate me how you can resaw, using a fence to guide your stock through the blade with the fence not being square to the blade, with good results. On my saw, you can set your table square to the blade and still not have a square fence to table or blade without making an individual adjustment. It's not rocket science that a fence out of whack and not square to the table and or blade will not give you a strait cut so, I'm not following your logic. If a square fence doesn't matter, they would make them out of rubber bands, it would be cheaper.

Posted

Here's a thought, bear with me folks, timber wolf blades suck! Seriously I've tried them several times and its just the truth. I run a bimetal sanvik (sp?) and it cuts great for 10x as long. Even cheap store brand bands cut better than those bs timber wolf blades. Re sawing on small saws can be trying I know. I also like Lennox wood master blades on my big saw.

Steve

Posted

Here's a thought, bear with me folks, timber wolf blades suck! Seriously I've tried them several times and its just the truth. I run a bimetal sanvik (sp?) and it cuts great for 10x as long. Even cheap store brand bands cut better than those bs timber wolf blades. Re sawing on small saws can be trying I know. I also like Lennox wood master blades on my big saw.

Steve

 

Sorry to hear about your trouble with timber wolf blades.  I have been running them on my band saw for several years, and have found them to be good blades. 

Posted

PB... I stated this wrong. Fence being parallel to the blade would have been the correct term, not perpendicular. my bad.

Parallel does not mater either that is the entire point. You notice he uses their magnetic fence as long as you can eyeball the fence within the neutral area of the cut it doesn't matter it could be out of parallel 1/2" either direction. I broke my fence so it no longer clamps so I just shove any old scrap of wood in it to get it to tighten down. As long as it's somewhat close by eye it cuts straight no matter where I get it clamped.

Notice the scraps hanging down from the fence. I have scraps on both sides just randomly stuffed in so it clamps somewhat close until I get off my butt and order a new fence.

Posted

Here's a thought, bear with me folks, timber wolf blades suck! Seriously I've tried them several times and its just the truth. I run a bimetal sanvik (sp?) and it cuts great for 10x as long. Even cheap store brand bands cut better than those bs timber wolf blades. Re sawing on small saws can be trying I know. I also like Lennox wood master blades on my big saw. Steve

This is true to a degree. I think a lot has to do with manufacturing. The blade you buy packaged for retail are mass produced sloppy. For those that have bigger saws we can't buy a blade off the shelf so our blades don't come off an assembly line. IMO you end up with a better blade. My blades come from a local service that just comes to my shop every other week and swaps them out. I haven't had a bad blade since starting the service.

Posted

PB...we are talking apples and oranges, and I just realized this. The parallel I am referring to and have been referring to, is the VERTICAL part of the fence that stands off the table, not where it sits on the table. If that vertical part of the fence does not run parallel to the blade, it should be adjusted.

 

Most saws, there are fence rails that get bolted to the side, those bolt holes have play, and can subsequently lock the rail down out of level with the table causing the vertical portion of the fence to be out of line with the blade, causing I'll effects to re-sawing results. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   2 Members, 0 Anonymous, 39 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined