blitt214 Posted February 17, 2014 Report Posted February 17, 2014 hi all, my bandsaw is giving me troubles, i have a powermatic 14 inch with a 1/2 3tpi timber wolf blade, everything is ok with thin stock (set fence for drift) but when i try to resaw material everything goes wrong the blade pulls the wood right off the fence, any idea what happening between these two different cuts thanks all Quote
Trip Posted February 17, 2014 Report Posted February 17, 2014 ==>blade pulls the wood right off the fence The only time I've seen that is with tension/deflection issues... How did you verify tension? Quote
blitt214 Posted February 17, 2014 Author Report Posted February 17, 2014 timber wolf says to use low tesion but it pulled so i tried a bunch of different tensions and same thing happens Quote
Trip Posted February 17, 2014 Report Posted February 17, 2014 ==>different tensions and same thing happens More info will help things along... What stock worked and what failed? Quote
blitt214 Posted February 17, 2014 Author Report Posted February 17, 2014 when i first set the drift i was using 1/4 then to try a resaw cut it was maybe 4 inch, Quote
Boatworks Today Posted February 17, 2014 Report Posted February 17, 2014 My guess feed rate is a bit too fast and the blade isn't clearing the material causing deflection = stock begins to walk ? Quote
dwacker Posted February 17, 2014 Report Posted February 17, 2014 Set your speed to the slower setting. Raise the upper guides and move them away from the blade. Tension the blade until the flutter is gone then loosen slightly. Lower the upper guides and re adjust. Set the speed back to the highest setting. If you still have the same problem get a new blade. Quote
Trip Posted February 17, 2014 Report Posted February 17, 2014 ==>^^^ If you're going flutter method... also remove throat plate and verify tracking. ==>timber wolf says to use low tesion I've got several TW blades -- never seen any included documentation about lower tension... I just treat them like any other blades and tension accordingly... ==>then loosen slightly I always thought you tightened slightly once flutter disappears --- about a 1/2 turn or so? ==>If you still have the same problem get a new blade. +1 That's a good point and I should have asked it up-front --- blade new/sharp? If brand new, could be a mfg issue. ==>it was maybe 4 inch Wasn't 4 inches of Lignum Vitae by any chance? Quote
blitt214 Posted February 17, 2014 Author Report Posted February 17, 2014 brand new blade,,,,,,maybe ill just try a new one never had this problem before,,,,,,thanks all Quote
dwacker Posted February 17, 2014 Report Posted February 17, 2014 brand new blade,,,,,,maybe ill just try a new one never had this problem before,,,,,,thanks all New doesn't mean anything anymore. Defective blades are a way of life for mass produced blades. Quote
dwacker Posted February 17, 2014 Report Posted February 17, 2014 ==>^^^ If you're going flutter method... also remove throat plate and verify tracking. ==>timber wolf says to use low tesion I've got several TW blades -- never seen any included documentation about lower tension... I just treat them like any other blades and tension accordingly... ==>then loosen slightly I always thought you tightened slightly once flutter disappears --- about a 1/2 turn or so? ==>If you still have the same problem get a new blade. +1 That's a good point and I should have asked it up-front --- blade new/sharp? If brand new, could be a mfg issue. ==>it was maybe 4 inch Wasn't 4 inches of Lignum Vitae by any chance? No you dont need to remove the throat plate unless you happen to have some oddball zero clearance plate. No you dont add tension with the flutter method on a small wheel saw. The flutter method will actually over tension the blade on a 14" saw. The majority of the flutter is centrifugal force caused by the small diameter wheel thus why small saws rely heavily on the guides. Quote
Trip Posted February 17, 2014 Report Posted February 17, 2014 ==> add tension with the flutter method on a small wheel saw. The flutter method will actually over tension the blade on a 14" saw. Ahhh, thanks. Learn something new every day... What's the wheel size where you either leave it alone or add tension? Quote
dwacker Posted February 17, 2014 Report Posted February 17, 2014 ==> add tension with the flutter method on a small wheel saw. The flutter method will actually over tension the blade on a 14" saw. Ahhh, thanks. Learn something new every day... What's the wheel size where you either leave it alone or add tension? Its not a set in stone thing but 20" is a good starting point. Quote
Janello Posted February 17, 2014 Report Posted February 17, 2014 I am of the opinion you'll never get consistent results...."setting the fence for drift" If you ask 10 different people, you'll get 11 different answers, but it's my opinion if everything is square..meaning table to blade, fence to blade, and wood to fence you shouldn't need to set your fence for drift. Before I had my saw set up properly, I had all kinda trouble re-sawing. Now that everything is square, it's a mindless process and I get excellent results. Quote
dwacker Posted February 17, 2014 Report Posted February 17, 2014 I am of the opinion you'll never get consistent results...."setting the fence for drift" If you ask 10 different people, you'll get 11 different answers, but it's my opinion if everything is square..meaning table to blade, fence to blade, and wood to fence you shouldn't need to set your fence for drift. Before I had my saw set up properly, I had all kinda trouble re-sawing. Now that everything is square, it's a mindless process and I get excellent results. http://www.educreations.com/lesson/view/drift/17261438/?s=bKx3XU&ref=link Quote
mikem Posted February 17, 2014 Report Posted February 17, 2014 I am of the opinion you'll never get consistent results...."setting the fence for drift" If you ask 10 different people, you'll get 11 different answers, but it's my opinion if everything is square..meaning table to blade, fence to blade, and wood to fence you shouldn't need to set your fence for drift. Before I had my saw set up properly, I had all kinda trouble re-sawing. Now that everything is square, it's a mindless process and I get excellent results. This has been my experience as well. Quote
Trip Posted February 17, 2014 Report Posted February 17, 2014 ==>http://www.educreati...XU&ref=link It's an interesting way of explaining the phenomena... I like the 'steering' terminology... Thanks. As a note: his discussion reflects my real-world experience... Once a saw is setup, I never really have to screw with it again -- well maybe after a new tire, but that's about it... And blades of a similar type all run about the same -- sort of his 'window' idea... The only time things change is when I change the blade 'type' -- let's go Linnean -- blade 'family'... For example, If I'm working curves then the 1/8" - 1/2" - 8/10/12/etc tpi RC blades all run about the same -- or so similar that I don't need to touch anything -- maybe adjust tracking a bit, but that's about it... But If I mount an 1-1/4" carbide resaw blade, then I've got to adjust the fence --- not much, just a bit... So I've got two blade 'families': A 'resaw' family and a 'curve cutting' family... I only have to touch the fence If I move between 'families', not between members of a single family -- 'species' -- keeping the metaphor. So from my experience, his explanation of 'drift' is pretty good... Quote
dwacker Posted February 17, 2014 Report Posted February 17, 2014 ==>http://www.educreati...XU&ref=link It's an interesting way of explaining the phenomena... I like the 'steering' terminology... Thanks. As a note: his discussion reflects my real-world experience... Once a saw is setup, I never really have to screw with it again -- well maybe after a new tire, but that's about it... And blades of a similar type all run about the same -- sort of his 'window' idea... The only time things change is when I change the blade 'type' -- let's go Linnean -- blade 'family'... For example, If I'm working curves then the 1/8" - 1/2" - 8/10/12/wtc tpi RC blades all run about the same -- or so similar that I don't need to touch anything -- maybe adjust tracking a bit, but that's about it... But If I mount an 1-1/4" carbide resaw blade, then I've got to adjust the fence --- not much, just a bit... So I've got two blade 'families': A 'resaw' family and a 'curve cutting' family... I only have to touch the fence If I move between 'families'... So from my experience, his explanation of 'drift' is pretty good... thats my video made special just for this conversation. I learned it decades ago on an old 36" Robinson verticle resaw that didn't really use a fence as most know a fence but the same theory applies to most bandsaws. Quote
Trip Posted February 17, 2014 Report Posted February 17, 2014 Wonder if/where blade rigidity comes into play... Swapping like-for-like but heavier gauge and/or swapping something like a BiMetal for a TriMaster... I bet rigidity comes into play somewhere along the line... Clearly tension changes a bit and I've got to tweak the tracking, but I'm not sure about the fence... does it fall within the same window? Quote
blitt214 Posted February 18, 2014 Author Report Posted February 18, 2014 the weird thing is i get perfect rips but thickmaterial just goes nuts, im going tomorrow to get a new blade think ill get 3/4 instead of 1/2 Quote
AceHoleInOne Posted February 18, 2014 Report Posted February 18, 2014 Is your cut angled and thus pulling the wood away from the fence? Sounds like your guides need adjustment. -Ace- Quote
tim0625 Posted February 18, 2014 Report Posted February 18, 2014 Guys...do you have an opinion on this guy's video on setting the band saw up? His premise is if it's set up right, there is no drift. Quote
Trip Posted February 18, 2014 Report Posted February 18, 2014 ==>^^^ There was a thread on this video some time ago… I’ll summarize my comments: Some of the stuff presented is spot-on (setting a blade, tensioning, checking for square, etc) and some is oversimplified.. His workflow is geared to the saws/blades he's demoing (remember, those are his tuned saws and his blades that he takes from show to show)... If you wheeled-in a saw that he's never seen before and not 'pre-tuned', the outcome would be quite different. Some of the specific negatives: 'Remove the table': is geared to the hobby-shop 14" band saw... I'd like him deal with a 24” saw and blithely remove a 160lb table for every blade change... Yea, that'd be fun... 'Fold the blade this way': Let’s see him try his ‘casual twist method’ with a 200" 1&1/4" blade without losing a digit (or an eye)... But the one thing that relegates the video to the bog: The blanket assertion that folks who don't do things his way, "Don't know what they are talking about"... Yea, everyone else is wrong --- with his saws and his blades... There are plenty of smart people getting great results using a different workflow... For example, David Marks has a bandsaw video geared for shop-sawn veneers -- it's also quite good, but it costs $$... David doesn't rely on 'pre-tuned' band saws to get his results... Quote
dwacker Posted February 18, 2014 Report Posted February 18, 2014 Guys...do you have an opinion on this guy's video on setting the band saw up? His premise is if it's set up right, there is no drift. His video is exactly right. If you track the blade properly the guides are only to keep the blade from twisting thus in a straight cut they really dont even get used. Really it boils down to a good blade and proper tracking. You notice he uses a magnetic fence and just eyeballs the location. This is can be done because the blade is properly tracked and creates a wide neutral area as I describe earlier in the thread. Quote
dwacker Posted February 18, 2014 Report Posted February 18, 2014 ==>^^^ There was a thread on this video some time ago… I’ll summarize my comments: Some of the stuff presented is spot-on (setting a blade, tensioning, checking for square, etc) and some is oversimplified.. His workflow is geared to the saws/blades he's demoing (remember, those are his tuned saws and his blades that he takes from show to show)... If you wheeled-in a saw that he's never seen before and not 'pre-tuned', the outcome would be quite different. Some of the specific negatives: 'Remove the table': is geared to the hobby-shop 14" band saw... I'd like him deal with a 24” saw and blithely remove a 160lb table for every blade change... Yea, that'd be fun... 'Fold the blade this way': Let’s see him try his ‘casual twist method’ with a 200" 1&1/4" blade without losing a digit (or an eye)... But the one thing that relegates the video to the bog: The blanket assertion that folks who don't do things his way, "Don't know what they are talking about"... Yea, everyone else is wrong --- with his saws and his blades... There are plenty of smart people getting great results using a different workflow... For example, David Marks has a bandsaw video geared for shop-sawn veneers -- it's also quite good, but it costs $$... David doesn't rely on 'pre-tuned' band saws to get his results... The only trickery in the show if you want to call it that is that he has probably pre tested the blades to insure they are not junk off the shelf. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.