Fxguy Posted June 20, 2014 Report Posted June 20, 2014 Hello everyone, I would like to ask your opinion on two jointers I came across on craigslist. The market near me is pretty slim pickings. So I came across a grizzly 6" G0452: http://chicago.craigslist.org/sox/tls/4523633296.html and a Jet 6" JJ-60S: http://racine.craigslist.org/tls/4503577996.html Both are pretty much what I have to spend at the moment and just wondering if anyone has had any experience with either of these jointers? Thanks, Tim Quote
wdwerker Posted June 21, 2014 Report Posted June 21, 2014 I have the closed stand version of the Jet. It's a fine little jointer and should serve you well . Careful time spent setting sharp blades is key to getting the most out of any jointer. Quote
knotscott Posted June 21, 2014 Report Posted June 21, 2014 Both look like decent deals to me. The Jet looks to be in better shape, but the Grizzly has a larger motor and a bit more weight. Quote
Freddie Posted June 21, 2014 Report Posted June 21, 2014 Before committing to one or the other, or either, go see them in person. Bring a straight edge and feelers. Check the tables. For reference, my grizzly jointers in feed table is .003" and the out feed table is .001". If the tables are to your satisfaction, and it runs smooth, then you can be sure that it will perform well in your shop. Warped cast iron would sour the deal even for free. 1 Quote
wdwerker Posted June 21, 2014 Report Posted June 21, 2014 Potato has a far nicer and newer jointer than mine. If you have sharp knives and flat tables you can compensate for a small motor by taking light cuts. But when the knives get dull that bigger motor does come in handy...... Quote
Fxguy Posted June 21, 2014 Author Report Posted June 21, 2014 Another thing to consider is that the Jet is an extra 2 hours (96 miles) north where as the Grizzly happens to be in the town I will be traveling to next week. The Grizzly does state that the blades need sharpened (or purchase a new set of blades) and the condition does not look as nice as the Jet. Any comparison of the two models in general? How do they compare brand new? Also the Grizzly G0725 Brand new bench top model is 1.5 HP and brand new is only $225. Would you consider it over the Craigslist Grizzly? Quote
Freddie Posted June 21, 2014 Report Posted June 21, 2014 Another thing to consider is that the Jet is an extra 2 hours (96 miles) north where as the Grizzly happens to be in the town I will be traveling to next week. The Grizzly does state that the blades need sharpened (or purchase a new set of blades) and the condition does not look as nice as the Jet. Any comparison of the two models in general? How do they compare brand new? With the jet being two hours further away, I think that offsets the $50 difference to lean towards the grizzly. That being said, it all boils down to the specs and condition of the individual machine itself, not model number. On a 6" 115v jointer, you should not be overly concerned about a 1/4hp difference. With proper depth of cut, you should never test the power limit of the machine. If you happen to do so, then you know you have to adjust the way you use the machine from there on. Another example, my grizzly jointer is a 3hp 220 machine, while Marcs pm 8" jointer is 2hp. To the best of my knowledge, he has never stressed the motor on that machine. Biggest thing I saw between the jet and grizzly ads you posted, the jet guy took time to clean the machine before he snapped some photos. Go look at the grizzly, and if the tables look good and it runs smooth, then you have found yourself a good deal on a jointer for your shop. Everything else is just cleanup, clean and wax the cast iron, and start making sawdust. Quote
knotscott Posted June 21, 2014 Report Posted June 21, 2014 Another thing to consider is that the Jet is an extra 2 hours (96 miles) north where as the Grizzly happens to be in the town I will be traveling to next week. The Grizzly does state that the blades need sharpened (or purchase a new set of blades) and the condition does not look as nice as the Jet. Any comparison of the two models in general? How do they compare brand new? Also the Grizzly G0725 Brand new bench top model is 1.5 HP and brand new is only $225. Would you consider it over the Craigslist Grizzly? This particular Jet with the open stand is smaller motor is a slight step down from Jet's 1hp enclosed model and the Grizzly...both having more power and weight than the open stand Jet. Both have potential to do the same job very well....setup and blade condition will determine the final performance if both pass muster for flatness and overall function. With that said, weight and power are rarely a disadvantage if all else is equal. An extra 2 hours of driving is pretty significant, and pretty much offsets the price difference. I'd start by taking a look at the Grizzly. If it runs well, has flat tables and fence, I'd give it some strong consideration. If you're not comfortable with it or have a concern, then take the next step and take a look at the Jet...then decide. If either have issues that are a deal breaker, remove it from contention. The "patina" on the Grizzly should clean up pretty easily.....15-20 minutes could have it looking like new, so don't let that be much of a deciding factor unless you find other concerns. Basically, I'm in agreement with DBP. I would not choose a new portable jointer over a stationary jointer if you have an option.....weight, capacity, power, reliability, noise, and precision are all advantages for the stationary units. There's always this Sunhill long bed 6" 1hp jointer with enclosed stand at closeout price of $250 +s/h ($350 shipped). Made in the same plant as the Jet, Griz 1182, GI, some PM, Bridgewood and others....all well proven workhorses. http://stores.lomatools.com/geetech-6-x-56-heavy-duty-jointer-ct-150/ You're area is loaded.....below is a decent list of jointers with comparable capability in your general area. You can always make an offer for any that are a bit over budget. This one could be worth a look and a lower offer if the other two don't pan out...it's a bit overpriced IMO. http://racine.craigslist.org/tls/4461906650.html This Delta (it's either a 37-190 or JT360) is pretty comparable to the Jet JJ6-OS....condition merits a slightly lower offer IMO, but it should also clean up well: http://racine.craigslist.org/tls/4528040504.html How close is this PM to you? http://milwaukee.craigslist.org/tls/4528505361.html Or this Ridgid? http://chicago.craigslist.org/nwc/tls/4528702537.html Jet JJ6-CS $300 (motivated seller): http://chicago.craigslist.org/wcl/tls/4526973798.html PM53 ($400...I'd offer $300-$350) http://chicago.craigslist.org/nwc/tls/4515013345.html This is a Craftsman made by Steel City/Orion - $350: http://madison.craigslist.org/tls/4468202348.html Another Craftsman (not sure who made it) - $200: http://chicago.craigslist.org/wcl/app/4507200733.html Quote
woodbutcher74 Posted June 21, 2014 Report Posted June 21, 2014 I just got the Grizzly G0452P. Haven't had a chance to use it much yet but the boards that I have ran through it come out perfect. I am very satisfied. As far as going with the new benchtop, I would steer away. I was at the Grizzly showroom in Springfield a month ago and the bench top tools are something less than desired. If you checkout the topic Opinion of Grizzly I think you will understand. Never used a Jet but I am satisfied with my Grizzly. Quote
Fxguy Posted June 21, 2014 Author Report Posted June 21, 2014 You're area is loaded.....below is a decent list of jointers with comparable capability in your general area. You can always make an offer for any that are a bit over budget. Actually not so much, I'm from Champaign, IL and so even the Joliet, IL listing is 2 hours away. So most of the listings you have posted are a lot farther. Appreciate the help though! Quote
knotscott Posted June 21, 2014 Report Posted June 21, 2014 What do you think of the Geetech/Sunhill CT-150 from Loma Tools brand new at $350 shipped? Quote
wdwerker Posted June 21, 2014 Report Posted June 21, 2014 It looks like another Taiwan made small jointer . Unless you can return if the tables are not flat and the fence is adjustable to keep square it could be a risk. I haven't heard anything positive or negative about Loma. In general the Taiwanese machines seem better than the Chinese ones . It all comes down to quality control. You could get a good or bad machine from anywhere but I would rather check out a machine in person before buying. Quote
Fxguy Posted June 23, 2014 Author Report Posted June 23, 2014 Well so much for that , both of these have sold. Guess I will just have to keep a watchful eye out and be patient! Thanks for the advice guys! Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.