AstroDave Posted November 1, 2014 Report Posted November 1, 2014 I am planning on purchased a jointer and a planer and saw this just now show up on my local CL... What are your thoughts? It's a Hammer A3 31 Jointer Planer @ $2200.00 http://washingtondc.craigslist.org/doc/tls/4740893036.html Quote
chefmagnus@grics.net Posted November 1, 2014 Report Posted November 1, 2014 New it sells for $3500. The Jet version is $2250. A good jointer will set you back $2k and a a good planer will set you back $15-25k. You can get both for the cost of one. If had known about combo units I would have gotten one for my shop. On the downside you loose all you planer setting when you joint a board and vice versa. I am no expert but if you have limited space I would go for it. My German teacher at Purdue had one and he loved it. I only ever used one for a single afternoon when I helped him make a picnic table. A very quiet and clean machine to run. Quote
minorhero Posted November 1, 2014 Report Posted November 1, 2014 Well it has the advantage of giving you 12" jointer which is nice. On the downside it costs more then double what a brand new 6" jointer and 15" portable planer cost. Additionally its a combo machine. Combo machines are fantastic if you have essentially no space for a workshop. They are less good if you have the space for dedicated machines. The big difference being that 1) some combo machines (and I have no experience with this one) are not as good at their individual functions as dedicated machines. and 2) you have to manipulate the machine every time you want to make a cut using the other machine, which frankly I am sure would get tiresome very quickly. Bottom line is if you have the room buy yourself a nice jointer and planer. New units can be had for cheaper then this, and used units could be had for less than a quarter of the cost of this combo. Probably a deal you will want to pass. Quote
AstroDave Posted November 1, 2014 Author Report Posted November 1, 2014 Thanks Guys... My original intent was to get a Dewalt 735x and a 8" Jointer of some variety...(I am still trying to figure out which one). Based on several reviews that I have read regarding this J/P combo it appears to be a well respected machine but I think I will pass as I do have the room I think although it's getting crowded as you see. Quote
..Kev Posted November 1, 2014 Report Posted November 1, 2014 Looking like a well thought out shop Qiten! Quote
minorhero Posted November 1, 2014 Report Posted November 1, 2014 I like the shop layout! If you need space you can always move the dog so it is parallel with one of the longer walls. Quote
ChetlovesMer Posted November 1, 2014 Report Posted November 1, 2014 I love the layout you've done. It's a great idea to do that before setting up shop. One question - have you considered squeezing in a lumber rack? Or is you're plan to store lumber outside the shop someplace? Quote
AstroDave Posted November 1, 2014 Author Report Posted November 1, 2014 Thanks for the comments... Chet i will be using my former shop area for overflow and lumber storage. It's just adjacent to this area so the climate is the same. Oh and Apple Wood...the good news is the dog is much smaller than depicted I thought of one question... Not sure I really need the 52" Sawstop table... for those who have large tables what is the main benefit? Is it simply just easier to do larger sheet goods? Quote
minorhero Posted November 1, 2014 Report Posted November 1, 2014 You pretty much hit the nail on the head. Its a lot easier to do sheet goods. Also for doing crosscuts with a crosscut sled it can be nice to have that extra bit of table there when doing oversized pieces so when you let go the piece does not fall to the floor. Not exactly critical and if you are looking to save some money it might be a pretty good place to do it. Other than that I find myself using it for storage and to hold extra work pieces that I am running through the table saw. Building a small table right there that can also act as a glue-up table or finishing table might be a better use of your space. 1 Quote
dwacker Posted November 1, 2014 Report Posted November 1, 2014 New it sells for $3500. The Jet version is $2250. A good jointer will set you back $2k and a a good planer will set you back $15-25k. You can get both for the cost of one. If had known about combo units I would have gotten one for my shop. On the downside you loose all you planer setting when you joint a board and vice versa. I am no expert but if you have limited space I would go for it. My German teacher at Purdue had one and he loved it. I only ever used one for a single afternoon when I helped him make a picnic table. A very quiet and clean machine to run. I don't know where you get this from. Unless your buying a Martin or the like you would never spend 15-25k on a planer. The jet in no way compares to the Hammer although the Hammer is the bottom end of the Felder line up its far superior to the jets. The draw back to the all in ones is the short tables. You get the width but not the length to go with it. Quote
Eric. Posted November 1, 2014 Report Posted November 1, 2014 And you have to convert it back and forth every time you need to switch operations. The big jointing capacity is the only advantage to those combo units, IMO...everything else is a drawback, Quote
dwacker Posted November 1, 2014 Report Posted November 1, 2014 And you have to convert it back and forth every time you need to switch operations. The big jointing capacity is the only advantage to those combo units, IMO...everything else is a drawback, I think if was to ever set up another small shop I'd buy a felder or minimax all in in one slider with scoring,shaper, mortiser, planer and jointer. I regret not doing it last time. Quote
chefmagnus@grics.net Posted November 2, 2014 Report Posted November 2, 2014 I don't know where you get this from. Unless your buying a Martin or the like you would never spend 15-25k on a planer. The jet in no way compares to the Hammer although the Hammer is the bottom end of the Felder line up its far superior to the jets. The draw back to the all in ones is the short tables. You get the width but not the length to go with it. I dropped at two decimal point in there. was supposed to be up to $1.5K to $2.5K for a good planer . Sorry for the typo. Quote
Tom Cancelleri Posted November 4, 2014 Report Posted November 4, 2014 Qiten, I saw that jointer on CL yesterday. It's nice to see another woodworker in Nova. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.