Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

First indoor furniture finish

Featured Replies

hey folks, started this hobby back in february. I've done a few outdoor cedar things for practice and now I'm almost at the finishing phase of my first indoor piece in white oak.

Could you take a peek at my finishing plan and see if I'm missing anything and/or fill in the question marks?  I got most of this info from youtube videos and my own practicing in preparation for this.  This will be the first time I've used a tack cloth or mineral spirits and my only poly experience has been on the test pieces where I was trying to figure out what stain to use.

Finish plans:

1.       Shop vac / blow staining area clear of dust

2.       Wipe piece with damp cloth

3.       Allow to dry X time?

4.       Wipe with mineral spirits with cloth

a.       Look for glue spots

b.       Sand glue off with (what grit?) and repeat steps 2, 3 and 4 as necessary

5.       Allow to dry X time?

6.       Wipe with tack cloth?

 

TOP PIECE:

                Apply painting tape to area where top will be glued to table

                Perform steps below covering area up to tape

                Remove tape when finish completed

BOTTOM PIECE:

                Apply painting tape to area where top will be glued

                Perform steps below covering areas that will be visible with finished piece

                Remove tape when finish completed

 

 

Pre-stain:

                Rub on with cloth

                Wait 10-15 minutes

Stain:

                Rub on with cloth

                Wait 8-10 minutes

                Wipe off with cloth- harder on dark spots

Let dry 24 hours, with fan running

 

Poly:

                Create batch of 33% min spirits 66% poly

                Create batch of full strength poly

                Wipe with tack cloth?

                WORKING TOP DOWN?

                Apply full strength poly to easy to apply areas using natural brush

                Apply weakened strength to hard to reach areas using cloth

                Let dry 24 hours

                Examine for missed spots (hopefully won’t happen 2nd time , if so must do 3rd coat?)

                Examine for bubbles that need to be cut off with razor (hopefully won’t happen second time around)

                Sand with 330 grit sand paper (only first time right?)

 

                Repeat whole poly process, ensuring missed spots are covered.

 

I'd skip anything that has to do with water (damp cloth) because that will raise the grain and you'll just have to sand again.  Unless you're using water-based finish, raising grain is just a time waster.

I'd also skip the full-strength poly from the can and just use Minwax Wipe-On Poly (satin) or Arm-R-Seal (satin).  It's pre-diluted, easier to use, and looks better because it's easier to control drips and runs, etc.  Thinner coats means you build a film more slowly and it helps to prevent that plasticky look you get with full-strength poly.

This is my program for indoor stuff:

10 SAND UNTIL GRIT >= 240

20 APPLY "SHELLAC"

30 SLEEP FOR 30 MINUTES

35 RUB WITH STEEL WOOL

40 IF NOT SATISFIED GOTO 20

50 END

  • Author
8 minutes ago, Eric. said:

I'd skip anything that has to do with water (damp cloth) because that will raise the grain and you'll just have to sand again.  Unless you're using water-based finish, raising grain is just a time waster.

I'd also skip the full-strength poly from the can and just use Minwax Wipe-On Poly (satin) or Arm-R-Seal (satin).  It's pre-diluted, easier to use, and looks better because it's easier to control drips and runs, etc.  Thinner coats means you build a film more slowly and it helps to prevent that plasticky look you get with full-strength poly.

While I have a good sized can of full poly , one guy said that wipe-on poly is basically the same thing as poly + 1/3 min spirits, is this true?

1 minute ago, Dhankx said:

While I have a good sized can of full poly , one guy said that wipe-on poly is basically the same thing as poly + 1/3 min spirits, is this true?

Kind of but not really.  There's a lot of proprietary secrecy so the exact formulas are not really known...but they do something else to them to make them behave and look better.  I've tried the diluted poly before and it's inferior both in application and appearance.

Buy a can of one of the wipe-on formulas and do a comparison on some test boards.

  • Author
30 minutes ago, Eric. said:

Kind of but not really.  There's a lot of proprietary secrecy so the exact formulas are not really known...but they do something else to them to make them behave and look better.  I've tried the diluted poly before and it's inferior both in application and appearance.

Buy a can of one of the wipe-on formulas and do a comparison on some test boards.

OK you talked me into it.  Water based OK?  https://smile.amazon.com/Minwax-60900000-Wipe-Finish-Clear/dp/B009YNUT6Y/ref=sr_1_3?ie=UTF8&qid=1499364011&sr=8-3&keywords=minwax+wipe+on+poly

https://www.woodcraft.com/products/arm-r-seal-top-coat-satin-quart?gclid=Cj0KEQjwv_fKBRCG8a3ao-OQuZ8BEiQAvpHp6Bi6gOBnvt1-b9iZougM8Z3YZRVJ_DjSI_kUszd5yXoaAgfS8P8HAQ

 

detail.jpg?c=1480706987

 

 

White oak + ARS, no stain...

 

rPeCrXN.jpg

 

Wacky white oak + ARS, no stain...

 

BX06Vl8.jpg

 

White oak + ARS, no stain...

 

UwxGcL7.jpg

 

 

Notice a pattern? :)  White oak is one of the few species that does look good under stain, though...so I won't hold it against ya.

 

I strongly suggest that you take a piece of the same wood in your project, sanded the same way and make a sample board so you will know exactly what your finished product will look like.  Example:  If your have 4 steps to your finish regimen, draw 4 lines across you sample board to create 5 spaces.  Mask off the first one so that it remains bare wood.  Put the frist step on the rest of the sample board.  When dry, mask off the section next to the bare wood so it receives no further treatment and then apply step 2 to the rest of the board.  Keep moving over one space unitl you have you final coat on just that last of the (5) sections. Now you have a picture of what each step looks like (don't forget to label the back of each section) and you have a sample board that you can use as a reference in the future.  If you are unsure what products or application methods then make a sample board for each.  Very easy to to and you learn a lot.

  • Author
2 hours ago, Ronn W said:

I strongly suggest that you take a piece of the same wood in your project, sanded the same way and make a sample board so you will know exactly what your finished product will look like.  Example:  If your have 4 steps to your finish regimen, draw 4 lines across you sample board to create 5 spaces.  Mask off the first one so that it remains bare wood.  Put the frist step on the rest of the sample board.  When dry, mask off the section next to the bare wood so it receives no further treatment and then apply step 2 to the rest of the board.  Keep moving over one space unitl you have you final coat on just that last of the (5) sections. Now you have a picture of what each step looks like (don't forget to label the back of each section) and you have a sample board that you can use as a reference in the future.  If you are unsure what products or application methods then make a sample board for each.  Very easy to to and you learn a lot.

Thank you sir! I've done a lot of test samples primarily to find our preferred color and stuff.  This first piece is the first of many to furnish our living room, kitchen and office. I wanted to make sure I got the finish right so I did a lot of testing as I created scrap boards while I was building the project.  After Eric's post I'll do a couple more tests: no stain + ARS and the pre-stain, stain we think we like + ARS.  It was interesting that after Eric's post I went to check my tests of pure Poly and noticed quite a bit of bubbles under light that I didn't see before.  True I put it on without a proper brush, just a crappy sponge since I was testing - but I'm excited about wiping poly on rather than trusting in brush technique which I have no skill.

  • Author
7 hours ago, Eric. said:

https://www.woodcraft.com/products/arm-r-seal-top-coat-satin-quart?gclid=Cj0KEQjwv_fKBRCG8a3ao-OQuZ8BEiQAvpHp6Bi6gOBnvt1-b9iZougM8Z3YZRVJ_DjSI_kUszd5yXoaAgfS8P8HAQ

 

detail.jpg?c=1480706987

 

 

White oak + ARS, no stain...

 

rPeCrXN.jpg

 

Wacky white oak + ARS, no stain...

 

BX06Vl8.jpg

 

White oak + ARS, no stain...

 

UwxGcL7.jpg

 

 

Notice a pattern? :)  White oak is one of the few species that does look good under stain, though...so I won't hold it against ya.

 

Very beautiful stuff , will definitely testing with ARS only , it's on the way.  We light the lighter colors and were leaning towards minwax weathered oak quickly wiped off.  Was interesting that the difference of pre-stain + weathered oak was much better than just weathered oak without prestain.  More stuff to test :) . 

  • Author
On 7/6/2017 at 1:19 PM, Eric. said:

I'd skip anything that has to do with water (damp cloth) because that will raise the grain and you'll just have to sand again.  Unless you're using water-based finish, raising grain is just a time waster.

I'd also skip the full-strength poly from the can and just use Minwax Wipe-On Poly (satin) or Arm-R-Seal (satin).  It's pre-diluted, easier to use, and looks better because it's easier to control drips and runs, etc.  Thinner coats means you build a film more slowly and it helps to prevent that plasticky look you get with full-strength poly.

Any advice on using mineral spirits? How long before its dry enough to either sand more, stain or poly?

 

  • Author

Eric

 

got the ars, put it on a test board with nothing but sanding. Wife and I both like it better, thank you so much for your help! Easy peasy!

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,011 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • bobtjanitor Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.