Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Deeper walnut color under General Finishes High Performance water poly with epoxy

Featured Replies

Hi everyone, I am finishing a walnut dining table and legs. The finishing procedure I've been using involves putting down a layer of epoxy (West System), sand smooth, then multiple layers of General Finishes High Performance (GFHP) water-based poly, then polishing (something I'm trying to figure out). The epoxy serves as a nice filler of large gaps (done before first step), small gaps, and deep grains in the wood (lots in walnut). However, it's a pain to deal with and going forward I'd like to just use it for large gap filling and go straight to GFHP onto bare wood.

So I tried this with one leg and noticed that the epoxy (which is clear to the eye) imparts a very nice reddening and deepening to the walnut color that doesn't occur with just the GFHP. In the picture you can see the table top (bottom) which is redder and has a deeper look (not obvious in the picture) than the leg (top) which is kind of a raw brown color of the walnut, and doesn't have that "deep" or "effervescent" look. I don't care so much about the filling aspect of the epoxy, but do you guys have a suggestion of another product that I can put on the bare wood underneath the GFHP that would have the same color deepening effect? Remember, the epoxy is crystal clear to the eye, it is not a stain. It's just somehow bringing this color out of the walnut. I try to stay to water-based products, so that would be preferable.

Thanks ahead of time for any suggestions and/or help!

59948d5ed11ce_EpoxyvsNoEpoxycolortone.thumb.JPG.09e13145f383f572bd77f78136eeccb0.JPG

IMO walnut doesn't need any help in the color department.  I'm perfectly happy with nothing but a few coats of Arm-R-Seal satin.

Yea, with General Finishes High Performance it doesn't add to much to walnut or most woods for that matter on its own.  I have sprayed Garnet de-waxed shellac before spraying High performance.

  • Author
33 minutes ago, Mike. said:

Hi - Welcome to the foum.

Epoxy will amber wood, even though it looks clear.

Personally I would skip the epoxy all together.  I can't see the benefit of it on an indoor project.  Also you might end up with some cracking in your top coat eventually.  Epoxy is soft and flexible, water based acryclic finishes less so.  You are introducing a whole lot of work for very little benefit, in my opinion, and you run the risk of a very plastic looking finish.

If you are dead set on water based finishes (I guess you would rather be poisoned by something you can't smell :) ), then I would at least put a light coat of boiled linseed oil on the wood (to give it some warmth) and then proceed your your GF HP.  Or switch to Enduro Var and skip the BLO.  Eduro Var is water based but ambers like a solvent finish.

 

Thanks for the suggestion Mike. As for the epoxy, this is the second walnut table I've done with it and it turned out awesome. What I didn't realize the epoxy was doing is ambering (new word for me) the color and giving it that "deep" effect. The GF HP doesn't do either of those things on its own.

As for oil based products, I'm not dead set against them, just prefer water based. I work in a closed basement shop so I'm not fond of really strong smells that linger. Equally as important, I like the easy clean up with water. I will look into the Enduro Var, that sounds like a good idea. Maybe I'll get a small can of that and BLO and see how both end up looking. By the way, does water based poly (GF HP) go well over oil? As you may tell, I'm pretty new to finishing and it's annoying the hell out of me. I like the building part of wood working.

  • Popular Post

Skip the BLO and use garnet shellac which only needs to dry for an hour! Left oil-based wipe-on poly, right garnet shellac plus waterborne poly which is what Chet is talking about. 

1707_wood_003.thumb.jpg.dd47048f1fb2a240743f169bf516bb53.jpg

I take it your question is really...   "I did this to the top, should I do the same to the legs to help them come out the same color?"

I guess I understand why you would want to fill the grain on a table top, especially something like a dining room table where you're likely to be wiping off spills and such.   A nice smooth top would be easier to maintain.   Granted you could also just use a table pad underneath a table cloth.   But then at that point why not just make the top out of cheap plywood like the restaurants do since nobody is going to see it?

 

waterlox on walnut will give you the same appearance as your lower example of epoxy+topcoat. It ambers anything considerably. Certainly more so than endurovar. 

 

What gaps are you filling? Pin knots in the wood, glue joint gaps, tearout?

I'm with others. I'm not sure why you need epoxy. Just a good poly, either water or oil based, should suffice. From my experience, all water based finishes seal and finish OK, but they don't bring out the grain as well as oil based poly and do not bring the more rich coloring to wood that an oil based poly does. To some degree, I have had success using a stain underneath that will color the wood to match the way it would look with oil based poly, but that sometimes takes a fair amount of experimentation to get the color just right. My understanding is that you can also tint the poly but I have never done the research or tried it.

If you want to match the "ambering" of the parts of the table which have been coated with epoxy without using the epoxy again, General's oil based gel poly could work. It is a wipe-on finish and works very well but takes more coats because the result is a slightly thinner coat of finish. However, it appears to me that it only comes in a Satin finish and it's unclear whether that is what you want. The nice thing about this gel is that it is very easy and controllable to wipe on with a soft cloth. No runs or drips. Also, because it is a gel, less fumes are given off during use and drying because there are less VOC's than there would be in a more liquid poly. 

  • Author
16 hours ago, estesbubba said:

Skip the BLO and use garnet shellac which only needs to dry for an hour! Left oil-based wipe-on poly, right garnet shellac plus waterborne poly which is what Chet is talking about. 

1707_wood_003.thumb.jpg.dd47048f1fb2a240743f169bf516bb53.jpg

Thanks! Do you have a certain garnet shellac you recommend? I notice that it mostly comes in flakes. Is it easier to get the premixed liquid? 

ARS has an amber color and would have the same coloring effect as the epoxy...without turning your wood into plastic.

Nothing brings out the richness and warmth of walnut better than oil-based anything.  Period.  Sorry, I know people don't like the word "best" around here, but when it comes to walnut and oil...it's accurate.  Finish outside if you have to.

  • Author
1 hour ago, Pwk5017 said:

waterlox on walnut will give you the same appearance as your lower example of epoxy+topcoat. It ambers anything considerably. Certainly more so than endurovar. 

 

What gaps are you filling? Pin knots in the wood, glue joint gaps, tearout?

I'm working with large slabs. So there are full drying cracks that come in from the edges, plus cracks in the knots. That's it, aside from the deep grains of walnut that would be nice to smooth over for cleanliness of a dinning table. I'll add waterlox to the list of things to try.

General finishes water-based amber dye with a little cinnamon dye, you can play to change the tones. Orange shellac looks good too. 

 

General Finishes Water Based Dye Stain in Amber

 

-Ace-

  • Author

Thanks for all the productive suggestions guys. To answer one of the comments, I'm not looking for a substitute for the epoxy on the current job. I'm working towards a deadline and don't have time to experiment with stuff, so I'm going to finish the legs of this table in the same process using the epoxy. However, going forward I want to move away from the epoxy unless I am filling gouges or cracks. I think what I will do is glue up one of those sample pieces I've seen of a few different types of wood and try most, if not all, of the products suggested here and then top coat with GFHP as if it's going to be a table that will be beaten up and cleaned many times. This will be a good indicator of how all these products compare.

HP is tough. But if the piece is going to get some abuse, Enduro-var may be a way to go, also gives wood a warm color. 

 

-Ace-

 

 

5 hours ago, Dan H said:

Thanks! Do you have a certain garnet shellac you recommend? I notice that it mostly comes in flakes. Is it easier to get the premixed liquid? 

I get mine here and mix my own. Be careful buying premixed as some of it contains wax.

https://wellermart.com/t/shellac

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

  • There are no registered users currently online

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.