Eric. Posted August 25, 2017 Report Posted August 25, 2017 28 minutes ago, Jean [Fr] said: I agree with your list and the order of purchase too. But what about hand tools @Eric. ? Do you still place all the 5 powertools in the first place ? I would purchase the two "Big Three" first : powered (jointer/planer, table saw), and unplugged (hand saw, chisels, plane), which are the basics, besides to be an absolute necessity for details and adjusting. Then the bandsaw and the router table, as those won't prevent you to work if you owned the aroused ones. Descend hand tools represents a budget too. That could be a coin flip. I personally evolved from machines first so I had the Big Five before I transitioned into finer work with hand tools. I think it's a more logical progression to start with machines, get a few projects under your belt, then evolve into more of a hybrid woodworker. Learn how to mill, create joinery, surface prep, finish; gain an understanding of wood movement and construction techniques; develop a basic workflow; then move into the finesse work of hand tools. I leave the grunt work to the machines and use hand tools only for joinery and finesse work at the end of a project...I consider hand tools to be "next level" as opposed to "beginner," and they'll be much less frustrating when you start with a solid foundation of machine work rather than diving in head first with hand tools. I think premature hand tool work can be frustrating for a noob and cause them to give up or spend way too much time trying to do basic things with hand tools when machines are easier and faster. But that was just how my own journey went...everyone is different. 1 Quote
bgreenb Posted August 25, 2017 Report Posted August 25, 2017 ^^^^ What Eric said. He said it better than I did, but that's what I was getting at. Quote
Jean [Fr] Posted August 25, 2017 Report Posted August 25, 2017 1 minute ago, Eric. said: But that was just how my own journey went...everyone is different. So true. I understand your point of view. My experience was at the opposite. I learned with handtools. My grand'pa was not a power tool guy. As I was a kid, I was not concerned by doing a piece of art at first try. But I'm glad I learned to understand dealing with the grain with handtools when I work with powertools, and especially CNC. @bgreenb is right, handtools do not forgive that much, but as it is a slow process, you understand instantly the consequences of bad move. Whereas a bit turns so fast it's hard to know exactly what was wrong. And of course, I bought a set of hand tools for my childs. Note, hand tools are less scary than a yelling power tool for kids too. It's probably a different story for adults, I admit. 2 Quote
bgreenb Posted August 25, 2017 Report Posted August 25, 2017 9 minutes ago, Jean [Fr] said: And of course, I bought a set of hand tools for my childs. Note, hand tools are less scary than a yelling power tool for kids too. It's probably a different story for adults, I admit. Yup I will definitely start my kids off with hand tools. And I think that makes sense when you have someone teaching you hand tools are a lot easier (as it sounds like you learned from your grandpa). But if you're trying to be self taught (as I was and I think @Eric. was) or learning via internet videos, I think it's a lot harder to pick up hand tools without direct instruction. But yes, everyone's journey is different and there is no right or wrong progression. Quote
Popular Post Eric. Posted August 25, 2017 Popular Post Report Posted August 25, 2017 There is great value in learning hand tools first. I think in our immediate gratification society, much of the craft is lost in the reliance of power tools. Machines are more efficient and I will never mill/rip/resaw a board with a hand tool if I don't have to...but I did take the time to learn how and put that arrow in my quiver (disclaimer...I have never resawed a board by hand and never will ...but I can 6-square a board with hand plane and saw). It's a slippery slope to start with machines because you may end up one of those people who buy a Domino before they can cut a mortise and tenon with a table saw and router, not even to mention...by hand. That concept is absolutely foreign to them, but everyone should take the time to at least cut a couple joints by hand, just to learn it...then never do it again if they are not inclined to do so. The end product is probably one of equal quality, but they are doing themselves a disservice by not learning the fundamentals and are therefore inferior woodworkers. People will try to argue that's not true, but they're wrong. So I think that both machines and hand tools have their place and I don't see how any woodworker can do high-quality yet efficient work without owning both. The key is striking a balance between efficiency yet not screwing themselves out of learning the fundamental skills. 3 Quote
Jean [Fr] Posted August 25, 2017 Report Posted August 25, 2017 36 minutes ago, bgreenb said: But if you're trying to be self taught (as I was and I think @Eric. was) or learning via internet videos, I think it's a lot harder to pick up hand tools without direct instruction. I guess you're definitely right. 23 minutes ago, Eric. said: Machines are more efficient and I will never mill/rip/resaw a board with a hand tool if I don't have to... But we may consider prower tools needs time for their setup. Frequently I use hand tools because the job will be done faster, with no time to pick-up the tool and store it back. On the other hand, for quick projects (stool, shelf...) I appreciate the quietness of the unplugged shop. Mostly no noise, mostly no dust... Especially with portable power tools, I'm often surprised by the few job done vs time. 23 minutes ago, Eric. said: you may end up one of those people who buy a Domino before they can cut a mortise and tenon Absolutely, and the any size floating tenon could be placed anywhere... No matter the tool, knowledge and training are the most important. 23 minutes ago, Eric. said: So I think that both machines and hand tools have their place and I don't see how any woodworker can do high-quality yet efficient work without owning both. I share exactly the same opinion. 1 Quote
Popular Post Eric. Posted August 25, 2017 Popular Post Report Posted August 25, 2017 9 minutes ago, Jean [Fr] said: But we may consider prower tools needs time for their setup. That can be true for joinery for sure, especially if you have, say, a single drawer to dovetail. By the time you screw around with the jig and router setup and a round of test cuts, you could be done cutting them by hand and have a better looking drawer as a bonus. But you'll never win that argument when it comes to milling. There's no setup needed. The jointer is ready, the planer is ready, the drum sander is ready, the table saw is ready...by the time you surface one side of one board, I'll have an entire stack of boards prepped and ready for joinery. And noise and dust doesn't bother me. It's the byproduct of...progress. 3 Quote
Jean [Fr] Posted August 25, 2017 Report Posted August 25, 2017 You're right, stationary machines are unbeatable. And setup time can be erased when you have to do a lot of identical parts. Quote
Ronn W Posted August 26, 2017 Report Posted August 26, 2017 No question in my mind - jointer. 1 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.