Dragoons Posted August 20, 2017 Report Posted August 20, 2017 Hey everyone, I was wondering which one of these i should consider purchasing next. I already have a planer (gift from family) and a table saw, including a jg saw and multiple hand tools, but i could really use, either a router, a band saw or a planer. Which of these three would you recommend? I mainly work for myself, making a few nick nacs for the house, but I am looking at branching out into more. Thank you for your time, Ben Quote
mat60 Posted August 20, 2017 Report Posted August 20, 2017 Welcome to the forums Ben. Do you have a jointer? Quote
Nestor Posted August 20, 2017 Report Posted August 20, 2017 Router. And a table to put it in. ______________________________________ Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Quote
Marmotjr Posted August 20, 2017 Report Posted August 20, 2017 1 minute ago, Nestor said: Router. And a table to put it in. ______________________________________ Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk If the cost of a table is off putting, DIY solutions are easy to do. Quote
Dragoons Posted August 20, 2017 Author Report Posted August 20, 2017 2 hours ago, mat60 said: Welcome to the forums Ben. Do you have a jointer? Unfortunately no, i do not. I was wondering if it would be possible to use a router, as a makeshift jointer? if not, i was thinking just the saving in wood cost from milling your own lumber would pay the jointer faster then the router? Its almost 40% cheaper to get rougher boards then just a a grade higher. Quote
Dragoons Posted August 20, 2017 Author Report Posted August 20, 2017 2 hours ago, Marmotjr said: If the cost of a table is off putting, DIY solutions are easy to do. Yeah for the router table, I would end up making myself one. Which router would you recommend? Of course a plunge router would be best of. I have been using king (table saw and jig saw) and havnt been happy with them, so I would stay away from one from them. Like i said just starting out, about 2 months ago and loving it. Quote
Jean [Fr] Posted August 20, 2017 Report Posted August 20, 2017 11 minutes ago, Dragoons said: Unfortunately no, i do not. I was wondering if it would be possible to use a router, as a makeshift jointer? if not, i was thinking just the saving in wood cost from milling your own lumber would pay the jointer faster then the router? Its almost 40% cheaper to get rougher boards then just a a grade higher. +1 for the planer : Table saw Jointer -> much more important than the planer. Planer Router table If you want to use raw wood, the first power tool you want to buy is a jointer. It creates 2 perpendicular reference sides. 1 Quote
pkinneb Posted August 20, 2017 Report Posted August 20, 2017 The one you need for your current or next project 1 Quote
Eric. Posted August 20, 2017 Report Posted August 20, 2017 It's kind of like if you were having soup and a steak for dinner and asking if you needed a spoon, fork or knife. The answer is you need them all. The one you buy next will be determined by what you need most for the next project. I'd probably buy the router first because it's the cheapest, then continue to work with S3S material until you can afford a good jointer. Then buy the bandsaw. 1 Quote
jmaichel Posted August 20, 2017 Report Posted August 20, 2017 2 hours ago, Dragoons said: Unfortunately no, i do not. I was wondering if it would be possible to use a router, as a makeshift jointer? if not, i was thinking just the saving in wood cost from milling your own lumber would pay the jointer faster then the router? Its almost 40% cheaper to get rougher boards then just a a grade higher. I think you answered your own question here. Jointer would make the most sense. Quote
Marmotjr Posted August 20, 2017 Report Posted August 20, 2017 2 hours ago, Dragoons said: Yeah for the router table, I would end up making myself one. Which router would you recommend? Of course a plunge router would be best of. I have been using king (table saw and jig saw) and havnt been happy with them, so I would stay away from one from them. Like i said just starting out, about 2 months ago and loving it. I use the Hitachi 12 something or other. Comes with a plunge and fixed base. The fixed base is mounted on my table, and the plunge covers most of the rest of the work. If it won't, then the fixed unscrews easy enough from my table. Both bases have PC compatible template guides. Did not come with an edge guide or DC shroud, but the DC shroud was easy enough to fab myself, and a edge guide should be similarly easy. To be honest though, I don't have enough experience using other routers to say how it performs, or what features I do or don't like. I do find though, that it compares very similarly to the Porter Cable's we use at work. Quote
bleedinblue Posted August 20, 2017 Report Posted August 20, 2017 Jointer. No question about it. Quote
Popular Post RichardA Posted August 21, 2017 Popular Post Report Posted August 21, 2017 16 oz mallet, so you can beat your head silly, from all the answers you're getting. 3 Quote
Dknapp34 Posted August 21, 2017 Report Posted August 21, 2017 Multi-router ftw! Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk Pro Quote
minorhero Posted August 21, 2017 Report Posted August 21, 2017 14 minutes ago, RichardA said: 16 oz mallet, so you can beat your head silly, from all the answers you're getting. heh kinda what I was thinking. Folks seem to coming down with either jointer or router. You haven't said what kind of projects you are doing and what your next project is. I think this should determine your next tool. If the next project you do absolutely no question about it needs a router well then there you are. If the next project you do could be made much better with a jointer, well there you go. Both of these tools are pretty basic in most shops, but then again if all the work you do is turning bowls you don't need either. You can use a router as a jointer for edge jointing.... however, this is not a good solution. First of all it can only be used for edge jointing and not for face planing. It also is a terrible way to joint a lot of board feet of lumber. Its slow and it will be expensive burning through router bits if you have a lot of wood to run through it. So for those reasons I would not seriously consider a router to be cheap alternative to a jointer. A router is its own separate tool that just so happens to have some very minimal overlap with other tools that exist in the shop. Another thing to consider is your budget. You can buy a router for $200 brand new and a used one can be seen online for $50 on occasion. A 6" jointer will run 600 dollars new for a cheap one and 200 for a used 6" is a decent price in my area. If you only have $200 to spend and you don't want to mess with used then that there would also be a controlling factor. Good luck! Quote
RichardA Posted August 21, 2017 Report Posted August 21, 2017 The OP said the word planer twice.... First he has a planer, {family gift] and then thought a planer should be one of the three tools to buy next........ The mallet does seem appropriate. 1 Quote
Andrew1 Posted August 24, 2017 Report Posted August 24, 2017 Router. Here's why, you can accomplish routing jointing and plaining and you will use it in every project going forward. Didn't say they will do it as good but you can still accomplish what you are looking for. Quote
Jean [Fr] Posted August 24, 2017 Report Posted August 24, 2017 I'm surprised by the number of answers which recommended the router. Let's have an overlook of a lambda project. First, you need wood and that means a square board. If you buy jointed boards or sheets (plywood, MDF...), you don't need any jointer/planer. But if you use raw wood, you need both a jointer and a planer. There's no possible other way, except empirical methods which are much time consuming, when they work. The jointer makes two squared reference surfaces. Then you use a planer to make parallel surfaces to the two reference ones. Some say you can just use the planer for the large side, and do the thin one on the table saw. You can, and probably you will on extra large boards. But the planer don't leave saw marks. Anyways you need to start with a squared piece of wood. That's the basis. On the other hand, a router is an interesting tool, that's true, and you will probably get one someday. But there's a lot of things you do with a router that can be done by other ways. Dadoes, rabbets and linear chamfers can be done on the table saw. Mortises and bores can be made with a simple chisel... Because @Dragoons just start to setup a shop, he's probably a beginner. That means his first projects will be probably simple, and won't involve advanced techniques for which the router would be crucial. On the other hand, power tools allows you to work faster (most of the time), but it does not makes you learn much about wood. My advice for a beginner would be to slow down with power tools buying and focus on how the wood reacts using hand tools. You need to know how grain direction influences the cut, how hard is a knot, and how all that means for the tool. So, for the beginner, I would recommend the table saw, a jointer, a planer, (to get squared wood with no pain) then to get reasonable quality handtools, like a saw, a chisel set, a hand plane. That hand tools will serve for life time, no matter how many power tools you'll buy. You can build anything out of wood with three tools : a saw, a chisel and a plane. 2 Quote
mat60 Posted August 24, 2017 Report Posted August 24, 2017 25 minutes ago, Jean [Fr] said: Let's have an overlook of a lambda project. First, you need wood and that means a square board. If you buy jointed boards or sheets (plywood, MDF...), you don't need any jointer/planer. I agree with most of what you said Jean except when you buy as you say jointed and planed boards I dont feel you can count on them being flat or squared at all. 1 Quote
Jean [Fr] Posted August 25, 2017 Report Posted August 25, 2017 If you get them from a store, that's mostly true, you're right @mat60 . I don't know in USA, but in Europe, you can also buy from sawmills or woodshops which can plane and cut to size for you. That's what you can do if you don't own a jointer/planer (we mostly have combined machines). Of course, freshly planed wood is more expensive. If you plan do do a lot of woodworking, a jointer/planer will pay for itself quickly. The other thing I would say about that, is the most satisfying memory I had when I started woodworking, was to get perfect boards out of the jointer/planer. There's some magic in transforming raw wood into valuable boards. Quote
Eric. Posted August 25, 2017 Report Posted August 25, 2017 The other problem with relying on S3S material is that 1) it's rarely dead flat by the time you start working on it. It's flat when it leaves the mill, but by the time it travels across the country and waits in a stack at the lumberyard for weeks or months for you to buy it...it's no longer perfect. And 2) even if you have the yard itself do the milling, usually that would just be the first round of milling out of two or three to get to final dimension with stable stock. Taking a 4/4 rough board down to 3/4 in one fell swoop is a great way to experience movement and have nothing to do about it. Milling should be done slowly in a series of steps unless you're already very close to final thickness. And 3) if you have a project that requires more than one standard thickness, you have no way of making boards thinner...yes a planer can do it but without a jointer in the mix you'll be experiencing bow and twist and you'll have no way to remedy that. So both a jointer and planer are essential tools, and while I understand not being able to have a fully equipped shop right out of the gate, they'll both have to be purchased sooner than later before higher-level woodworking can be done. I've spoken of my "Big Five" many times but I'll list them again: jointer, planer, table saw, bandsaw, router table They are all essential machines, and unless you do some kind of very specific work that does not require one of them, you really need them all to have a versatile shop that can tackle an array of projects. Of all the machines, I'd spend the biggest money on the jointer if I were on a tight budget. It's easier to "make do" with lesser versions of the other machines until you can afford to upgrade them. A small, cheap jointer is woodworking suicide. The only reason I suggested a router first is because it's the cheapest of the Big Five and it's such a versatile tool. I built a bunch of projects early on with nothing more than a table saw, router, circular saw and drill. None of the projects were great...but I built them. 1 Quote
Jean [Fr] Posted August 25, 2017 Report Posted August 25, 2017 1 hour ago, Eric. said: jointer, planer, table saw, bandsaw, router table I agree with your list and the order of purchase too. But what about hand tools @Eric. ? Do you still place all the 5 powertools in the first place ? I would purchase the two "Big Three" first : powered (jointer/planer, table saw), and unplugged (hand saw, chisels, plane), which are the basics, besides to be an absolute necessity for details and adjusting. Then the bandsaw and the router table, as those won't prevent you to work if you owned the aroused ones. Descend hand tools represents a budget too. Quote
Popular Post bgreenb Posted August 25, 2017 Popular Post Report Posted August 25, 2017 2 hours ago, Eric. said: They are all essential machines, and unless you do some kind of very specific work that does not require one of them, you really need them all to have a versatile shop that can tackle an array of projects. Of all the machines, I'd spend the biggest money on the jointer if I were on a tight budget. It's easier to "make do" with lesser versions of the other machines until you can afford to upgrade them. A small, cheap jointer is woodworking suicide. Couldn't agree more with this entire paragraph, particularly the bolded parts. To me a jointer is the most important machine in the shop and the one that I'm willing to spend more on because it's so finnicky to calibrate and keep calibrated, and without a good jointer the entire project is frustrating. There are multiple ways to skin almost every cat in woodworking, but there's only one way (with power tools) to get a flat face and square edge. 31 minutes ago, Jean [Fr] said: I agree with your list and the order of purchase too. But what about hand tools @Eric. ? Do you still place all the 5 powertools in the first place ? I would purchase the two "Big Three" first : powered (jointer/planer, table saw), and unplugged (hand saw, chisels, plane), which are the basics, besides to be an absolute necessity for details and adjusting. Then the bandsaw and the router table, as those won't prevent you to work if you owned the aroused ones. Descend hand tools represents a budget too. Yeah the only reason I shy away from telling beginners to stock up on hand tools, even though I think they're essential, is that it's very easy to get frustrated and get poor results with hand tools, and what a beginner needs is some early success to build confidence. Literally anyone can put a dado stack in a table saw and use a miter gauge to cut a tenon on a board with basically no practice or education. But it takes A LOT of practice to cut a tenon by hand (not to mention having to invest in a sharpening system on top of the actual tools). But I agree with you on their importance longer term as you get into more intermediate woodworking, the Particle Board Memorial Award for Eschewing Hand Tools notwithstanding. 4 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.