Recommended Posts

Posted

I'm trying to decide what to do with my bench top. Currently I have a 1 3/4" beech laminated top that was given to me. I'm thinking about adding a 4" x4" apron of hardwood around it to give me a thicker clamp area and a little more surface to work with. However because of the location of the bench (left corner of the shop) that means I really only have one side open to put a vise on.

I could do an end vise or a front vice on the right side but I'm thinking a tail vice with a shoulder will give me a few clamping options from a single screw. The down side is that it's a bit tougher to install so I don't want to go through all that and find it's not as useful as I first thought.

Here's the one I was looking at:

http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=31136&cat=1,41659

Originally I was checking out this one at the WW show but it's a big chunk of change to put down at the moment and you can't put a shoulder on it:

http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=65746&cat=1,41659

Anyone using something like this? How do you like it? Am I better off just using a front or side vise and calling it a day?

Any help would be appreciated.

Thanks

-Jim

Posted

Hi Jim,

For clamping long stuff, a tail vise is really nice. You can also clamp stuff between the jaw and the bench. I see many woodworkers planing drawer sides to fit using a tail vise. I don't currently have a tail vise but will certainly incorporate one when I build my bench.

Posted

Chris Schwarz (Popular Woodworking editor) gives much thought and writing on all things benches. In his 2nd Workbench book he goes to length to give his reasoning for not being a fan of tail vises. Of course, there are many folks who are very fond of, and often use their tail vises. If this is to be the only vise on your bench I'd definitely suggest a traditional face vise (if a twin screw is not in the budget). Many more options for clamping. On my primary workbench I have a face vise attached to the side (as well as front), with dog holes that align with bench dog holes. This allow me to pinch long (or short) pieces between dogs much as you'd use a tail vise, while also having benefit of a face vise.

One of CS's complaints of tail vises is that you have a big chunk of the bench devoted to the tail section which is not suitable for pounding on. Some tail vise folk claim that their design minimizes that issue, but on a relatively thin bench I'd say you have even more of a factor.

On my in-office workbench I only have a face vise on left-front and would appreciate an end vise at times, but like you space is tight. That bench has an apron similar to your idea. Again, CS is not a fan of aprons, thinking it limits clamping options. However, I find that I do use that as a clamping surface. Probably one of those things that it gives some options and takes away others. Guess the prime use (other than extending your bench depth), is for long boards I can put them in the face vise on right and use a clamp against the apron to the left. Not as elegant as a sliding deadman or such, but gets the job done.

  • Like 1
Posted

I use my tail vise all the time. I use it just as much as face (leg) vise.

I got the BC vise, so it takes up little in the way of excess space, and provides plenty of support. I don't know why chris thinks that makes that area of the bench weaker or un-poundable, because that seems to have far more to do with the construction and bulk of the top than with the vise. With a 4.5" roubo, I feel comfortable pounding it anywhere.

Planing stops are ok, but it is far easier to traverse at an angle with something (lightly!) pinched in the tail vise than just riding up against a stop.

Posted

I bought the quick release vice and documented my bench rebuild and vice installation on my blog:

http://digitalwoodworker.com/2011/01/19/the-most-important-tool-in-any-shop/

I've used it for a few months now and still love it. That's currently the only vice on my bench. Between that and a planing stop I can do a lot. I still need to make a sub bench to do dovetail's etc.... but thats another story.... Still dont know what I'm going to do on the front of my bench... but I'll get around to it :D

5339236493_91bfc2324e_b-640x426.jpg

Posted

See, the thing is I only have room for one vise so I was thinking a tail vise with a shoulder lets me use the shoulder the way I would use an end vise (clamping for dovetailing and whatnot) and still have the ability to do hold downs for planing or carving like a wheel vise does. Am I asking for too much from a single vice?

Alternatively I could do a front or end vise and use something like one of these to handle what a wheel vise does:

http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=63825&cat=1,41659

http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=66819&cat=1,41659

The bench is in a corner so the back and left side are touching wall and the left front is a little cramped to put a vice so I'm trying to get the most use out of the right side and right front. I could do a leg but on the right side of the bench it'd be awkward. (I'm a righty)

Thanks for you help and suggestions.

-Jim

Posted

See, the thing is I only have room for one vise so I was thinking a tail vise with a shoulder lets me use the shoulder the way I would use an end vise (clamping for dovetailing and whatnot) and still have the ability to do hold downs for planing or carving like a wheel vise does. Am I asking for too much from a single vice?

Alternatively I could do a front or end vise and use something like one of these to handle what a wheel vise does:

http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=63825&cat=1,41659

http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=66819&cat=1,41659

The bench is in a corner so the back and left side are touching wall and the left front is a little cramped to put a vice so I'm trying to get the most use out of the right side and right front. I could do a leg but on the right side of the bench it'd be awkward. (I'm a righty)

Thanks for you help and suggestions.

-Jim

Well, I definitely prefer a tail vice. But, I use it mostly for hand planing boards. You bring up a good point though, it can be used to clamp items just like a regular front vise, I just use my other clamp, more out of habit than anything else.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.