Recommended Posts

Posted

One of the videos on Shannon's site discusses this question in some depth. Unfortunately, I can't find it, but I did find a reference to it that says it followed a different video that compared WoodRiver planes with those from Lie Nielsen. Maybe Shannon can supply a link to the video I think I remember?

-- Russ

Posted

One of the videos on Shannon's site discusses this question in some depth. Unfortunately, I can't find it, but I did find a reference to it that says it followed a different video that compared WoodRiver planes with those from Lie Nielsen. Maybe Shannon can supply a link to the video I think I remember?

-- Russ

Found it, Russ. Thank you! And thank you, Shannon, for a great video. That explained exactly what I needed to know. I think I got my answer...I need to save more money for more tools LOL.

Posted

Well shoot, you guys are just too fast for me. In short, I find bevel up to be a great tool for the beginner. In the long run though, bevel down offers more control and ease of use on the fly that the intermediate to advanced user will want. So do you spend hard earned cash on bevel up just to "retire" them as you become more advanced. Probably not. I used a bevel up Jack almost exclusively for several years and now I'm using a bevel down Jack. My bevel up isn't retired but is now a dedicated shooting board plane. I used a bevel down smoother for 90% of my work. That other 10% is really gnarly stuff and my bevel up 50* blade knocks it out with no tearout. Is this solution the minimalist approach? Not at all, but I feel that if I can help some of our toolmakers stay in business then all is not lost.

Posted

I think there's an important qualifier when discussing BU vs BD - Which plane and how many do you have?

For example, if you have a smoother plane and a jointer plane, I don't know that the "flexibility" that bevel up designs provide helps you much for a jack plane. If you have those 2 other planes, you are probably using the #5 for really coarse/rough work. If so, you don't really care about being able to change attack angles or slice through end grain - you can about hogging off wood. In that case, I wouldn't go with a bevel up jack plane.

Posted

As you are looking at the block planes, I bought Rabbet Block plane earlier this year, and absolutely love it. It has been a go-to tool for me since I bough it.

http://www.lie-niels...og.php?grp=1269

Yeah, there are so many to drool over. I plan to pick up some specialty planes in the future, but my budget is a little blown right now. Router plane is first on that list.

Posted

Well shoot, you guys are just too fast for me. In short, I find bevel up to be a great tool for the beginner. In the long run though, bevel down offers more control and ease of use on the fly that the intermediate to advanced user will want.

Come on man, you can't leave us hanging like that, you need to explain this statement. :D

Posted

I had a BU Veritas Jointer and Jack plane that I did not like, not sure what it was about the planes but they just did not feel good in my hands nor did I care for the set screws either. I recently rehabed on older Stanley No. 5 pre WWII not sure what type maybe 14 but I absolutely love it. I also prefer the O1 steel more than the A2 for both my planes and chisels. I know you are getting LN planes so these comments are somewhat irrelevent but the LN 62 is similar to the Veritas LA Jack and I personally would spend the extra cash and just get the LN No 5.

Posted

I think Shannon's video is a fantastic discussion on bevel up and bevel down planes.

I like bevel down planes myself. The main reasons:

1. If you rely on camber to optimize your plane for what you want it to do, you have to camber a bevel up plane blade more than a bevel down plane blade to get the same results.

2. I think sharpening and managing wear is easier to do with a bevel down plane blade. This is a relatively minor point.

3. I like the way that bevel down planes feel in use more than bevel up planes. I also like the position of the controls. This is much more of a personal preference issue.

(Warning: snarky comment ahead.)

4. If the bevel up jack plane is really all that versatile, where are all those woodworkers who have a bevel up jack plane as their only bench plane? ;)

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   2 Members, 0 Anonymous, 51 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32k
    Total Topics
    437.5k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Lenny2
    Newest Member
    Lenny2
    Joined