Nick2cd Posted December 24, 2011 Report Posted December 24, 2011 I consider myself a complete amateur when it comes to woodworking. i've made a few projects with some mortise and tenon joinery (i find mortises kind of tedious). i really want to buy a festool domino. however, i almost feel a sense of guilt over purchasing the domino. not because of the huge price tag, but more over the shortcut that it provides me. i know mortise and tenon joinery is at the core of fine woodworking. if i had the domino, i can pretty much guarantee my traditional mortise/tenon fabrication would fall by the wayside and i would rely heavily on the domino. With that said, do i purchase the domino anyways or do i pay my woodworking dues and cut my teeth on tradition? Quote
Eric. Posted December 24, 2011 Report Posted December 24, 2011 I wouldn't feel guilty about it if Domino money was in my budget. You can do more with it than just M&T. And it's a great joint...nothing to be ashamed of (like metal fasteners ) AND no one will ever know. I want one badly. Quote
woodwhisperer Posted December 24, 2011 Report Posted December 24, 2011 Now wait till the Domino XL comes out! Talk about guilt! lol To tell you the truth, the Domino won't replace every mortise and tenon joint you need to make. And there are many joints that rely on similar skills as the mortise and tenon. So if you don't have those skills, you're in trouble. So personally, I feel a person should be fairly proficient at making mortise and tenon joints before purchasing a Domino. Bottom line is you need those skills. Once you have them, I see nothing wrong with using specialized tools like the Domino to get the job done quickly. Frankly, you'll love it! Quote
Jfitz Posted December 24, 2011 Report Posted December 24, 2011 I agree with Marc. Once you have the skills down, the Domino would come in handy if you want to spend your time on other more critical parts of your project - whatever you want to highlight for that particular piece. Some pieces just call out for M&T, but other pieces might only need the benefit of the strength of that joint (without any visual or aesthetic appeal). Quote
tdale51@yahoo.com Posted December 24, 2011 Report Posted December 24, 2011 I personally enjoy cutting a traditional m&t. I do it because it gives me an opportunity to practice important skills such as accurate lay out. Is using a domino cheating? Allow me to answer that question with another question. Is using a table saw cheating? Quote
Nick2cd Posted December 24, 2011 Author Report Posted December 24, 2011 Now wait till the Domino XL comes out! Talk about guilt! lol To tell you the truth, the Domino won't replace every mortise and tenon joint you need to make. And there are many joints that rely on similar skills as the mortise and tenon. So if you don't have those skills, you're in trouble. So personally, I feel a person should be fairly proficient at making mortise and tenon joints before purchasing a Domino. Bottom line is you need those skills. Once you have them, I see nothing wrong with using specialized tools like the Domino to get the job done quickly. Frankly, you'll love it! this is exactly what im talking about. i certainly wouldn't call myself "proficient" at cutting these joints as i haven't done a lot of them. i would say that i can lay them out and cut them, but it takes me a while to do so....hence my domino desire. im just wondering if getting a tool like this so early in my woodworking path is in poor judgement. Quote
thewoodninja Posted December 24, 2011 Report Posted December 24, 2011 I would say that if you are making a living with your woodworking, then spring for the Domino. Otherwise, don't shortcut yourself. Learn to do the M&T correctly first. It will only strengthen the rest of your skills in the long run. Quote
woodwhisperer Posted December 24, 2011 Report Posted December 24, 2011 Well there is certainly another side to this discussion. We can't assume that everyone loves the process of making joints. Many people do woodworking because of the journey. They enjoy the process of working wood and making complicated joinery is not a chore, it is part of the fun. But for others, the destination is the ultimate goal. So how you get there is a little less important than simply achieving a high quality final product. Personally, I am a big believer in doing what makes you happy. So if you are the type of person who believes the final product is the most important aspect and that's what keeps you going into the shop every week, then I say the Domino is a perfect fit (get the pun?). But if you derive a lot of pleasure out of the process of woodworking, you certainly might be cheating yourself out of some fun times as you hone your skills. Definitely no right or wrong here, just personal goals and preferences. 1 Quote
mattvan Posted December 25, 2011 Report Posted December 25, 2011 I too am of the "doing what makes you happy" camp when it comes to woodworking. For the longest time I limited myself in projects and techniques I attempted simply because I thought either I was pushing myself to the front of the line too quickly or because I felt I SHOULDN'T be doing one thing until I accomplished a whole different list of tasks and techniques. The fact is, when you limit yourself out of guilt for what you perceive to be cheating yourself or stepping out of line in learning and mastering another set of techniques, you ARE cheating yourself...out of just being able to have fun and learning in the process. When you no longer enjoy building for any reason it doesn't matter what tools or techniques you're using. I say, if you really want to learn how to master M&T joinery. With all the time you save using the Domino, use it to practice hand cut M&T's. 1 Quote
Skunkeye Posted December 25, 2011 Report Posted December 25, 2011 Pocket screws and Dominoes make me fell cheap and dirty...but I use them all the time; shop projects, plywood bookcases my wife is going to paint, etc. They are great for actually completing a project in a weekend (or an afternoon). Cherubini (spelling?) would have us believe that nails are OK as well, even though, deep down, I know nails are evil (even the cut nails with fancy heads). Do the joinery that time allows, that makes you happy. Quote
tim0625 Posted December 26, 2011 Report Posted December 26, 2011 I personally enjoy cutting a traditional m&t. I do it because it gives me an opportunity to practice important skills such as accurate lay out. Is using a domino cheating? Allow me to answer that question with another question. Is using a table saw cheating? There is a Neanderthal spy amongst us! ....brother, I need all the help I can get! Fine joints done by hand is a little like gymnastics - they take a really hard thing and make it look quite easy...Tommy Mac on the TV in high gear....and the joints come out looking great....some of you people got some serious skills. I'm kind of like Nick....we are trying.....i guess if we just took the plunge and went 100% neanderthal for a bit, we'd drastically improve. It is interesting though how some of us have a mindset that makes us fall completely on the neanderthal side of the fence, and some of us go as mechanical as we can....and then most of us probably fall in the middle of doing some of both. Quote
dwacker Posted December 26, 2011 Report Posted December 26, 2011 If I can get the job done with a power tool then thats what I'll use. I dont find the need to take more time than needed to accomplish a task. Most M&T joinery is not exposed so I see no real need to make it look hand done whether its a table saw tenon or a domino either way the job jets done. Even if it needs to look hand done like a dovetail, I'll still use power tools as much as possible. You certainly don't need to feel bad for being efficient. I really doubt the inventor of the mortice and tenon joint would have been cutting them by hand if he would have had a domino tool. Don Quote
Joraft Posted December 26, 2011 Report Posted December 26, 2011 ==> Domino XL ... Couldn't find a release date or initial pricing... Any hints? RUMOR has it at mid 2012 with a price of $1000-$1200. Quote
tdale51@yahoo.com Posted December 26, 2011 Report Posted December 26, 2011 Timwood, I'm not a neanderthal spy. LOL What I meant to say was using a domino is no more cheating than using a table saw to rip a board. I just happen to enjoy cutting M&T joints. True they are hidden and don't need to be perfect, that's why I like to hand cut them. If I make them less than perfect nobody will ever know but I still get to learn from the experience. Besides, I can't afford a domino but from the reading I've done it's one nice tool that does a great job and makes a nice sturdy joint. Quote
Nick2cd Posted December 27, 2011 Author Report Posted December 27, 2011 Well, i have been struggling back and forth with this decision. the information and answers you guys have provided have certainly given me some much needed insight. i hadn't looked at this situation from some of the angles you gentlemen suggested. after carefully reading and considering all info provided, i had finally made my decision.....but it didn't really matter at all. "why?" you ask. because, i have a great wife who bought if for me for Christmas! It was my final gift under the tree. honestly, it caught me completely off guard. i was giddy. i can remember it was the exact same feeling i had when my parents bought me a Nintendo (when i was in the 2nd grade). Anyways, she made up my mind for me. now, im not saying im giving up on hand cut mortise and tenon joints by any means. i am still going to attempt to improve my inner neanderthal. but i am saying, i have a new toy and i can't wait to play with it!!! Quote
Eric. Posted December 27, 2011 Report Posted December 27, 2011 Dang Nick, your wife needs to have a talk with my wife. Congrats! Quote
tim0625 Posted December 27, 2011 Report Posted December 27, 2011 Congrats Nick! Eric....I'm not sure if the wives should talk. That could evolve into something we might not recover from. It's like when on NCIS, 2 of Gibbs ex wives AND Jenny came together....Dinozzo said, "Train wreck...I know I should look away but I can't". Since it seems that Nick's thread has about run its course... and TDale51 ...in your honor, The quote and Trivia Question of the day ---- "Is you is or is you ain't my con-stit-enchy?" What movie? ......... Quote
tdale51@yahoo.com Posted December 27, 2011 Report Posted December 27, 2011 WOW! I'm gonna have to get myself on the nice list before next year! Congrats. And TimWood...I had absolutely no idea where that came from...first thing I thought of was Foghorn Leghorn! I guess he's not as popular now-a-days though. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.