Recommended Posts

Posted

So I got a DMT coarse/extra-coarse plate, and then a 800/4000 combo japanese water stone. I took my plane iron and flattened the back and bevel on the coarse side of my DMT and it had a shiny polish. I then take it over to my 800 grit stone and work the back and bevel but it never gets a shiny polish - it always has this cloudy look to it. I used a marker on the iron and I'm removing steel evenly, so I figured I just needed to go up to my 4000 grit stone. Same story, it never has that really nice mirror polish. Do I need to get an 8000 grit stone for that? I'm concerned because I at least had a shiny polish (not mirror, but it wasn't cloudy) using the coarse side of my DMT plate - shouldn't it only get better as I go up in grits? I spent over an hour honing the iron - and the iron is from a new WoodRiver V3 Jack plane which came out of the box pretty flat so I really would have expected to be done within a few minutes. So I'm obviously doing something wrong.

The chisel gets fairly sharp - I can edge joint some wood boards and take pretty thin shavings so I thought life was good. But recently I tried to plane the face and my plane just locks up, even on really light cuts. I actually end up moving my bench if I try pushing it really hard (granted, my bench isn't heavy enough but that's another problem).

Posted

I use a waterstone to hone to about 8000. This gives a good shine, but not a mirror. Some guys go nuts with sharpening, and go to 10 000, and then buff the blade. This will give a mirror, but its not really necessary.

If you use a microbevel, and its 8000, you have more than an excellent edge for woodoworking. It also saves steel on your plane irons and chisels, and it's much faster to hone. As you mentioned, make sure the back is lapped flat.

Hope this helps.

PS - it can be frustrating (and dangerous) to use a bench that moves when you try to plane. Make sure that you bolt your bench to the floor, or beef it up so it stays put

Posted

Hi Mike,

A mirror polish doesn't necessary equal sharp, I would not spent to much time worrying about that. Yes, a higher grit stone is a good idea and will ultimatley get better results, but only if the blade is being sharpened corectly. The behavior you describe implies that either the blade is not sharp or there is some other issue with you setup. For me a 4k stone isn't sharp enough, but it should be able to get a blade sharp enough for good use in wood that isn't particularly hard or difficult to plane. Assuming everything else (frog/chipbreaker) are positioned properly my hunch is the you "rolled" or dubbed the edge of the blade on one of your coarser stones. If this is the case it may look like you are honing the bevel, but in actuallity you may not be hitting the cutting edge - the only part that actually matters. You will know if you are honing the cutting edge if you can feel a burr on the back of the blade after honing for a little while. No burr, means you are not actually honing the edge.

If you are freehanding my first reccomendation is to go out and get an inexpensive side clamping honing guide and use this until you are confident that you know what sharp is. While I am definitly an advocate fo learning to freehand, this is always something you can learn later on.

Regardless of whether or not you are freehanding at the moment, I would also advise that you hone at a very slighly steeper angle then the primary bevel. If you are freehanidng this means that you put the primary bevel in full contact with the stone and lift up a tiny bit before you start moving the blade back anbd forth. This will create a micro bevel, pull up a burr, and give you a fresh edge in no time. Once you feel the burr go back and forth a couple times between the bevel and back until you can no longer feel a burr.

Anyway, tell us a bit more about your method for honing, and perhaps we can better help you to identify what isn't working.

Posted

So I got a DMT coarse/extra-coarse plate, and then a 800/4000 combo japanese water stone. I took my plane iron and flattened the back and bevel on the coarse side of my DMT and it had a shiny polish. I then take it over to my 800 grit stone and work the back and bevel but it never gets a shiny polish - it always has this cloudy look to it. I used a marker on the iron and I'm removing steel evenly, so I figured I just needed to go up to my 4000 grit stone. Same story, it never has that really nice mirror polish. Do I need to get an 8000 grit stone for that? I'm concerned because I at least had a shiny polish (not mirror, but it wasn't cloudy) using the coarse side of my DMT plate - shouldn't it only get better as I go up in grits? I spent over an hour honing the iron - and the iron is from a new WoodRiver V3 Jack plane which came out of the box pretty flat so I really would have expected to be done within a few minutes. So I'm obviously doing something wrong.

The chisel gets fairly sharp - I can edge joint some wood boards and take pretty thin shavings so I thought life was good. But recently I tried to plane the face and my plane just locks up, even on really light cuts. I actually end up moving my bench if I try pushing it really hard (granted, my bench isn't heavy enough but that's another problem).

Welcome to the wonderful world of sharpening--an elusive adventure of expense and frustration, in which every promise uttered works only on Mon/Fri between 3-4am....

:) Okay, it's not quite that bad......

There's a distinct difference between a rough scratch pattern that imitates a shine, as opposed to a polish. Some stones, like my Norton 4k and 8k didn't really produce a mirror finish but left rather a cloudy but "clean" finish. My Choseras, Sigmas, and Gesshin stones leave fantastic, bright mirror finishes--why, I don't know--they just do. When I use a Suehiro Rika 5000 after any of my 1000 stones, it yields a good, sharp edge but one that is rather cloudy. When I insert a 3000 stone before it, the SR5k yields a wickedly sharp edge and a bright mirror polish.

Okay, some possible explanation. If you're using King water stones, you perhaps didn't spend enough time on each stone. Make sure, first of all, that you've flattened the stone prior to sharpening! Second, keep resurfacing the stone to keep it flat FOR CUTTING THE BEVEL EDGE. Once the edge is cut, spend more time on the stone in order to achieve that polishing. On the 800 stone, be sure you work up a burr on both the blade back and bevel. Gently chase it off, with progressively light strokes (1 or 2). Preferrably, use pull strokes. Once the 800 has provided burrs all the way across the edge, move on to the 4000 side. Wet it well (actually, it benefits from a soak); flatten it, and get started. Drawing a burr on 4k and up stones is a bit more difficult--that's why it's so important to do so on the 800 stone. As the stone abraids the steel, the binder and grit break down into smaller particles (more so the longer you work) and this is what produces the mirror polish. Now, a mirror polish doesn't necessarily imply a sharp edge (we're back to spending quality time arriving at sharp on the 800 stone) but it does reflect that a stone's grit is "honing" or polishing. I like to think of sharpening as three phases--cutting, honing, and polishing, the last of which offers no more sharpness but does improve the strength and refinement of the edge. Think of honing as grinding the deeper scratches out so that there's less and less valleys between serrated knife edges. Polishing is when the stone has virtually stopped removing the ridges but is buffing them and toward a blended, hardened edge. The mirror finish is the result of how binders and grits break down and work the steel. (Okay, I'm out of my league here--so others please step in.....) Stones w/o binder cut way faster but typically yield far less mirror polishing.

BTW, if you are using Nortons, Kings, or older stones, the grit ratings are inflated over the more current rates--4000 is closer to a 3000 or a bit less; an 8000 is closer to a 5000. The newer grit ratings provide a better reflection of what a stone can produce. However, I have 3000 and 4000 stones (ceramic) that can produce really sharp, really polished edges!!!!! Going on to my 6000 and 13000 stones is just insane but fun :-)

What you've got will work--just keep the stones flat and flushed with water. Slow down the water splashing as you get toward polishing!

Posted

Thanks to all for the helpful info. It's starting to make more sense.

To answer some of the questions - I am using a Veritas MKII honing guide and I do feel the burr along the entire edge before I move up to the next grit. My stone is a "Samurai Deluxe Water Stone 800/4000" - no idea if it is ceramic or something else. I'm guessing it's not ceramic though. I probably should have mentioned that I'm planing some hard maple, cocobolo, and morado. I guess they're all pretty hard woods. I'm hoping to pick up some cherry and poplar this weekend, maybe I'll have better luck with those.

I do flatten my water stones using the DMT plate fairly often. I'll try to pick up an 8000 grit stone - I was looking to get a shapton because it's a real pain for me right now to soak the stones, but Amazon is currently out of stock.

I'll keep at it and also try to add some sand bags under my bench for weight. It's driving me nuts that it rattles but I built it in a weekend for like $100 out of 4x4s and MDF (plans off of finewoodworking.com). Marc's Roubo bench build keeps tempting me though.

Posted

You're planing some pretty tough stuff - even with a very sharp blade it can give you a workout, and since you don't have a solid bench wood like that will most definitly give you trouble. Cherry's not nearly that hard and generally is a very nice wood to work by hand, but even it can have harder more difficult areas. Poplar is about as easy of a wood to work as there is.

Since you are using a guide, pulling a burr, and removing the burr, my guess is the edge is about as sharp as your 4k stone can get it, so you probably need to go finer. An 8k stone is better, butin the meantime you could also get some honing compound and put it on a piece of FLAT hardwood or MDF and use that to take your edge up a level. A stick of honing compound costs $5-$10 and will last you forever.

Some other things to check though. Make sure the mouth omn your plane is not closed to tight and make sure your chipbreaker isn't right at the edge of the blade (or even overhanging it). Both of these things can cause clogging and would also lend to the behavior you have described.

Again though, my guess is that your problem is the result of the combine factors of trying to work VERY hard wood on a less then solid bench, with a blade that does not have a fine enough edge. Improving any one of these factors may make a big difference.

Posted

Chris,

That all makes sense. I already had the mouth on my plane open for an aggressive cut, and the chip breaker is installed properly. So I'm going to get some poplar and try it out for fun - but I'll be sourcing some finer grit stones and looking to improve my bench stability over the coming weeks.

Thanks to all for the advice and ideas!

Posted

Mike,

I recently reviewed a Woodriver #5 V3. The plane I got worked well right out of the box, but a little tuning definitely improved the performance. Check that the blade is installed bevel down. When setting the plane, start with the blade fully retracted, then gradually advance it (1/8-1/4 of a rotation to the depth adjustment knob) until the blade begins to engage.

You could also try using the blade on its own like a chisel to see if it is indeed sharp. If the blade cuts well, you can proceed to check the plane set-up. Oh, whenever I pick up a plane, I give it a shake to feel if everything is tightened down properly.

Review Part 1

Review Part 2

Posted

Chris,

I saw your review a few days ago and it's what made me start questioning my blade sharpness :) I saw that mirror polish in the blade and then the mirror like reflection on the wood and I started scratching my head because I wasn't getting results anywhere close to that. The blade bevel is down, and I did try the sharpness test by shaving some hairs on my arm but it didn't cut the hairs so I guess the blade just isn't sharp enough. I've got some higher grit shaptons on order, hopefully they'll be in soon! I've got 10 old chisels I need to flatten. The chisels were given to me by my father in law who teaches wood working in France - and the chisels were old ones from the school that they were disposing. I started honing them and all I can say is they really beat these things up, not even close to flat on the back. They'll give my DMT plate a good workout.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   1 Member, 0 Anonymous, 58 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined