Brian VanVreede Posted April 4, 2012 Report Posted April 4, 2012 So while setting up my band saw I broke part of the upper guide block assembly.(cheaply made part that broke from over tightening) So I now have only 1 guide block. While looking for a replacement assembly, I came across Carter guide bearings. They cost 180$ for new upper and lower assemblies. Is upgrading to bearings worth it, or should I just get a replacement part and stick with the blocks? Quote
Vic Posted April 4, 2012 Report Posted April 4, 2012 When they come in, go to McMaster.com and order some extras. Although I haven't had one seize in quite awhile, they do. The Carter's are a pretty good guide system. I don't think they are the best, but they work. Quote
dwacker Posted April 4, 2012 Report Posted April 4, 2012 Carters work great especially on problem saws like most 14-16 imports. If its one of the old design cast iron spine imports carters make a big difference. Don Quote
Brian VanVreede Posted April 4, 2012 Author Report Posted April 4, 2012 What do you mean, "cast iron spine"? Quote
dwacker Posted April 4, 2012 Report Posted April 4, 2012 What do you mean, "cast iron spine"? Like this. The spine being cast iron. The spine is the part that the switch attaches two. http://www.grizzly.com/products/The-Ultimate-14-Bandsaw/G0555 Quote
Brian VanVreede Posted April 5, 2012 Author Report Posted April 5, 2012 Yes, that's what I have but much older. (1990) thanks for the clarification Don. Quote
wilburpan Posted April 5, 2012 Report Posted April 5, 2012 I'm not a big fan of the Carter-style guide bearings. As the blade moves down, the bearings spin so that any dust in the area will get sucked in by the bearings and jam into the gap between the bearings and the blade, which can lead to vibration, leading to a poorer cut. My bandsaw has plain steel blocks for guides, and I get excellent resaw results with it. With the steel blocks, I did file them so that they have a very very very slight convexity to them, and I set them very close to the blade. I think I've posted this before, but here's a picture of a resaw that I did in a piece of 8/4 cherry that was over 8" wide. The resulting surface was flat enough that it took minimal work with a plane to remove the saw marks. By the way, that's a whopping 1/2 hp motor that I have on my bandsaw. Quote
Brian VanVreede Posted April 5, 2012 Author Report Posted April 5, 2012 Thanks for sharing Wilbur. That's awesome. After seeing results like that, i think ill just find the replacement part. Quote
Brian VanVreede Posted April 5, 2012 Author Report Posted April 5, 2012 Wilbur, I enjoy your Hail St Roy! Quote
dwacker Posted April 5, 2012 Report Posted April 5, 2012 I'm not a big fan of the Carter-style guide bearings. As the blade moves down, the bearings spin so that any dust in the area will get sucked in by the bearings and jam into the gap between the bearings and the blade, which can lead to vibration, leading to a poorer cut. Ive always owned bandsaws with bearings and can say that this theory is not correct. Last I check bandsaws spin clockwise with the bearing spinning downwards. Unless the debris is flying to the top of the bearing which is very unlikely since the blade is pulling the dust downward towards the dust collection port this is not going to happen. Even if it did fine dust would have to build up and cake onto the bearing in excess of the gap between the bearing and the blade. The spinning bearing remain clean 100% of the time even if they have a fresh coat of oil on them. Carter bearings make a huge difference on cheap saws with weak spines especially the ones that have excss resaw capacity like the newer ones with excess of 8" resaw capacity. FWIW Jet bearing assemblies fit mst of the imports for half the price of Carter. Don Quote
Brian VanVreede Posted April 5, 2012 Author Report Posted April 5, 2012 DON, where can I find FWIW jet bearing assemblies? For half the price, it sounds tempting... Quote
dwacker Posted April 5, 2012 Report Posted April 5, 2012 DON, where can I find FWIW jet bearing assemblies? For half the price, it sounds tempting... Dont know. We just upgraded my buddies 14" jet a few weeks ago. Got the Bearing local from Sumner woodworkers store for $69 box said fits Grizz, jet and most other imports. Also add the upgraded tension spring for $15 and a 3/4 resaw king blade. Now it cuts 8" hard maple just beautifly. Don Don Quote
Brian VanVreede Posted April 5, 2012 Author Report Posted April 5, 2012 What does FWIW stand for? Quote
dwacker Posted April 5, 2012 Report Posted April 5, 2012 What does FWIW stand for? For what its worth. Quote
wilburpan Posted April 5, 2012 Report Posted April 5, 2012 Ive always owned bandsaws with bearings and can say that this theory is not correct. Last I check bandsaws spin clockwise with the bearing spinning downwards. Unless the debris is flying to the top of the bearing which is very unlikely since the blade is pulling the dust downward towards the dust collection port this is not going to happen. Even if it did fine dust would have to build up and cake onto the bearing in excess of the gap between the bearing and the blade. The spinning bearing remain clean 100% of the time even if they have a fresh coat of oil on them. And I can say that I have seen bandsaws with bearing guides that are caked up with sawdust. The most likely source of the sawdust is sawdust carried by the blade around both wheels, coming out of the top wheel cover. As far as the gap goes, I've got my steel guides set to within 0.001-0.002" of the blade. It doesn't take much dust to jam up that gap if they were bearing guides. Michael Fortune has the same plain steel guide set up on his bandsaws, and he probably uses more bandsaws more often than any other commercial furniture maker. He also finds that there are similar issues with bearing guides. My main take away is that there are many paths to the same end. I'm sure that there are people with bearing guides on their bandsaws that get good results as well. I like the fact that if I have to do something about my blade guides, I can tune them up with nothing more than a file, which is a lot easier and cheaper than going out to get new bearings. Quote
Alan Bienlein Posted April 5, 2012 Report Posted April 5, 2012 I have bearings for guides on my band saw but have had great success in re sawing by not using the upper bearing guide. I get just over 8" of re saw capacity like this. Quote
Brian VanVreede Posted April 6, 2012 Author Report Posted April 6, 2012 I think I'm really looking for the cheapest fix at this point. Since I have never used a bandsaw before now, it may be educational to. know how it operates plain Jane. And then see if I feel like I need an upgrade. Quote
Brian VanVreede Posted April 6, 2012 Author Report Posted April 6, 2012 I'm going to call Grizzly customer service tomorrow and see if they have a replacement part. Quote
wilburpan Posted April 6, 2012 Report Posted April 6, 2012 Wilbur, I enjoy your Hail St Roy! Thanks! That came from a conversation about how people called Roy Underhill St. Roy, and then someone said if there should be a Hail Mary for woodworkers, and that's what I came up with. Quote
Brian VanVreede Posted April 6, 2012 Author Report Posted April 6, 2012 I just ordered a new upper and lower guide block holder and 4 new blocks from Grizzly. 39$ including shipping. The technician helped me determine the model I owned (there is no model # on it any where. The motor has a plate on it but only has info about the motor) and find my specific parts. Took about 10 minutes, should arrived in 3-5 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.