Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Replacement for General Finishes Arm-r-seal

Featured Replies

Arm-r-seal is not sold in California anymore. Any suggestions on a replacment?

Wow, crazy... are you able to order it online? So silly...

Since I'm driving in to WIA'12-Pasadena from Arizona where I can buy Arm-R-Seal, I think I know a way to help finance the trip... ;-)

Yup. The ever lasting march to reduce/eliminate VOC's

Check out the thread here:

hahaha i can see marc and davids next video of them at a roadside stand selling fireworks, watermellons and arm-r-seal.

I just read the statement that you can no longer get arm r seal in california. I just recently bought it a Austin

Hardwoods in Santa Ana, they had plenty on hand if that is of any help.

Polyurethane, BLO and mineral spirits, equal parts each. That's pretty much what Arm-R-Seal is.

I don't think it's equal 3rds, and there are probably other solvents in Arm-R-Seal.

I've use both, and the AS dries faster and handles differently than the shop mix. I'd guess less oil, and possibly some naptha, and/or additional chemical dryers.

Arm-R-Seal is nothing more than diluted varnish and contains no BLO as a final additive. If you create a mixture with BLO you will end up with something much closer to a Danish Oil, which is a very different animal. And if you are used to using Arm-R-Seal, you will likely be disappointed in the results.

It does contain a proprietary "oil modified urethane resin", so there is some kind of oil in it. I get much different results in respect to wood coloration/tinting with Arm-R-Seal than I do with straight up varnish (full strength or wiping) I use danish oil a lot because I think it pops grain nicely and doesn't look as flat as a straight varnish usually does. To me, Arm-R-Seal has very similar effects in respect to color as the Danish oil I mix up. Based on my exceptionally limited experience, I bet that "modified oil" is from flax seeds in some way, shape or form.

I'm also pretty sure it isn't modified with soya oil as Arm-R-Seal has a very pronounced yellowing effect that is immediate and does darken with age.

The recipe for finishes is quite complex and even with a science background, much of it is over my head. What I mean when I say that there is "no oil" is that there is no raw oil added to the final mixture, in the way most woodworkers think of it. Arm-R-Seal behaves exactly as you would expect a diluted polyurethane to behave. Add BLO to your Arm-R-Seal and it will take significantly longer to dry. There's a great test I learned from an old Flexner article describing how to determine if there is any oil in the final mixture. Just put a few drops on a glass surface or a can lid (something that won't soak it in). Varnishes will simply dry into a smooth puddle. Oil/varnish blends and oils will dry wrinkly. Both Arm-R-Seal and Seal-a-Cell turn into solid smooth circles. Add a little BLO to either concoction and both will dry with wrinkles.

The color differences you are seeing are most likely due to the resins themselves (alkyd, phenolic, poly) or the oils used to make the finish (tung, linseed...). I also think Arm-R-Seal's mixture gives a particularly nice color that is missing from other comparable finishes. But from a usability and an "oil-containing" perspective, there really isn't much difference between Minwax Wipe-on Poly and Arm-R-Seal.

All very good points. I agree about the about the color. I am working on a piece now made with some really light colored ash. I don't waste money on wipe-on ploy because it is just regular poly thinned - EXCEPT Arm-R-Seal. On some scraps I tested Minwax gloss polly (thinned with mineral spirits) and Arm-R-Seal. The Arm-R-Seal produced a much richer, slightly yellowish tone that I have only ever experienced with a "Danish oil" concoction or straight up BLO. The Minwax was very flat and didn't do much to highlight interesting grain. Also GF touts the stuff as being more than just a wipe on poly. That could be marketing hype though.

I'm going to try the "drop drying test". Not that I don't believe you, it would be interesting to see for myself.

Thanks for the explanation!

Flexner is an amazing resource and I learned a ton from his book. I am still young in my finishing journey, but have done A LOT of experimenting with many types of finishes; both off the shelf and custom blended. I think articles like this are a tad disingenuous though. Reading this would have one believe there is virtually no difference between Arm-R-Seal and Waterlox, While in durability and application they may be identical, they are visually different when applied to wood. I understand the intent of the article (labeling is all hype and one is not any more durable or easier to apply than the another) but there are more aspects to a finish than mode of application and durability. This is why the shelf in my garage looks a lot like the finishing section of my local woodcraft. The only way you are really going to know how a finish looks is to apply it.

Yeah no doubt, testing for yourself is the best way to go. Did you happen to read that 2005 article in Fine Woodworking where they tested a bunch of wiping varnishes? I'd give you a link but it's a paid article, and I try not to link to those if possible. The reason I mention it is because appearance, in my opinion, is a completely subjective attribute. There really is no way to quantify it so it's tough for any publication to talk about appearance in terms that are truly useful to the reader. Well, this test actually took a few quantifiable attributes like color (yellowing), penetration, and light reflection and used those as general traits of an attractive finish. Of course they had other attributes as part of the overall test, but would you believe Minwax Wiping Poly got both Best Overall and Best Value? As you can imagine, this ruffled lots of feathers, especially those who have been spending lots of money on "higher quality" wiping varnishes.

While I don't believe everything I read, that test certainly made me think twice about paying for the more expensive brands.

I am a paid member there and I didn't see that article. I'll have to look it up because for me that is the most frustrating part of finishing and I spend a lot if time on it. I've often thought of just sticking to one finish I like and being done with it, but sometimes there is such a drastic difference (especially in curly wood as I mentioned) that I am really glad I took the time to mess with a bunch of different finishes. I would believe that Minwax did well. The only reason I buy Arm-R-Seal over Minwax is I can only find the Minwax wipe on stuff in giant containers that go bad before I can use half of it. I could mix my own with regular old poly, but my wife already wants to know where all her leftover dishes are disappearing to,I work at home now so "I left them in the office" doesn't fly anymore. I completely understand that the topic of appearance is 100% subjective, however articles alluding to "all these are the same" should have some sort of one-liner stating appearance my vary.

Joe,

Partial cans of varnish often cure before they can be used.

Varnish is the perfect use for Bloxygen, Wine Saver, or if you're a welder, Argon gas, added to the can each time you close it. I've also added marbles and 1/4-20 nuts to varnish containers to remove the air space from varnish cans when I didn't have gas available. I rinse the nuts in alcohol and allow them to dry before I use them the first time. The fillers can be used over and over, just move them to the next can.

I've had partial cans of Waterlox and Gymseal last years if I limit the amount of air in the can.

No need to do this with lacquer or shellac, as you can simply add some solvent and get working again. I only use marbles with water base, as the nuts rust and Bloxygen is not compatible.

I am a welder and do throw some argon in from time to time, however I really only make 3 to 5 sizable projects a year. Due to my shop not being climate controlled, I am out of business from November to May. Even the past few days here already it hasn't gone above 55. That's too cold of an average temp to apply any finish or do glue-ups, so once I finish up the table I am working on (which is coming out like crap) I'm going to call it a season. A big can of poly would last me about 5 years. I've found, even stored inside with Argon, I get a year tops out of varnish. It's not the cost I worry to much about, it's safe disposal. Us woodworkers should be especially sensitive to environmental concerns. In my area, safe disposal is kind of a hassle and a little costly.

The nuts/marbles is a great tip though! I am going to try that with the can of Arm-R-Seal I just opened.

You can in fact still buy this product in California. It has to do with what county you are in. You can purchase it in the norther part of california. I do not mean the Bay Area or Santa Rosa. That is not Northern California. You can get it in Humboldt county and you might be able to purchase it from the people on the other end of this phone number 800-927-5874

You can in fact still buy this product in California. It has to do with what county you are in. You can purchase it in the norther part of california. I do not mean the Bay Area or Santa Rosa. That is not Northern California.

You sound like the people of northern New York when 'Islanders and NYC residents refer to Westchester and Putnam counties as "upstate NY". :D

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,009 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Joseph b Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.