rodger. Posted October 15, 2012 Report Posted October 15, 2012 Is the purpose of a plane sack to keep rust off of one's planes? If you use them, I would like your opinion. I also hear that some people use their old socks! Quote
duckkisser Posted October 15, 2012 Report Posted October 15, 2012 any old bag will work if you are that worried just add some moiisture absorbing material and you will be ok. honestly i think that is over kill if you take care of you tools and use them regular you should not have large build up of water on your tools. Quote
CessnaPilotBarry Posted October 15, 2012 Report Posted October 15, 2012 I've used old socks and real "plane sacks" to protect my planes from other tools and each other when traveling. I think they both work great against physical damage, the purpose-made versions are easier to get in sizes for jointers and smaller planes, and the drawstrings are nice. Neither seemed to do much for me related to corrosion. Camelia Oil has done a lot more for me in this respect. In the shop, I don't use the socks, as I find a dedicated shelf in a cabinet right at the bench is much more efficient. It's enjoyable and extremely efficient to be able to grab a tool, use it, and put it directly back in it's home. This technique protects the planes from being knocked around, conserves bench space, allows the blades to remain in position for use, and virtually eliminates setup and put-away time. Whenever I work away from home or take a class, I realize what a difference the wall cabinet within easy reach has made in my work. I keep renewable dessicant cans inside my cabinets and rollaways in my basement shop. 1 Quote
rodger. Posted October 15, 2012 Author Report Posted October 15, 2012 I've used old socks and real "plane sacks" to protect my planes from other tools and each other when traveling. I think they both work great against physical damage, the purpose-made versions are easier to get in sizes for jointers and smaller planes, and the drawstrings are nice. Neither seemed to do much for me related to corrosion. Camelia Oil has done a lot more for me in this respect. In the shop, I don't use the socks, as I find a dedicated shelf in a cabinet right at the bench is much more efficient. It's enjoyable and extremely efficient to be able to grab a tool, use it, and put it directly back in it's home. This technique protects the planes from being knocked around, conserves bench space, allows the blades to remain in position for use, and virtually eliminates setup and put-away time. Whenever I work away from home or take a class, I realize what a difference the wall cabinet within easy reach has made in my work. I keep renewable dessicant cans inside my cabinets and rollaways in my basement shop. Thanks. I was thinking of building a hand plane cabinet. Would you mind posting a pic of yours? Right now my planes are neatly stored in a drawer, but I like the cabinet idea better. Quote
JMort847 Posted October 15, 2012 Report Posted October 15, 2012 I've used old socks during transport and received three plane sacks as gifts. I agree that they protect against bumps and dust in the toolbox, but do little for moisture/humidity. I use camillia/jojoba oil or mutton tallow along with my well-used woobie, wiping tools off at the end of the day for moisture and dust. I keep things in a wooden rolling cabinet that doesn't have doors (yet) but I'm planning to build an anarchist chest over the winter. Quote
rodger. Posted October 17, 2012 Author Report Posted October 17, 2012 Here you go, Pug! Nice cabinet. I think I will build a similar one, but my collection of hand tools is not nearly as nice as yours! Quote
duckkisser Posted October 17, 2012 Report Posted October 17, 2012 build for the tools you want franklin eventuly you will fill all those shelves and slots. Quote
CessnaPilotBarry Posted October 18, 2012 Report Posted October 18, 2012 Thanks! It took about 18 years to build the kit, but it's been pretty stable for ~ 3-4 years now. Missing from that cabinet are carving tools, screwdrivers, hammers, mallets, and mortise chisels, which are below the cabinet in drawers, because they only come out for specific uses. What can't be seen in the photo is that all hand planes sit on nose lifts, to protect extended edges. Those gray bands on the rasps and cabinet files are Velcro cushion strips, as those tools can swing and bump when I open and close the doors. I need a better setup there. The key for me was to limit the cabinet or shelves in closest reach to only what gets used at the bench, no matter what that is... Easy out and easy in makes it difficult for Barry to not stay organized. It's so helpful to be able to put a tool where it lives, even as a temporary place. If I don't pick it up again, it's already put away. Years ago, I remember watching a silly home organization show on TV. Not silly was the hot-warm-cold storage plan a woman explained on one episode. She was using it in the context of a kitchen, but it's GREAT for the shop. The HOT stuff is used daily, like the tools in the wall cabinet and my table saw, WARM might be the sharpening bench, routers, cordless drills, and nail guns, COLD might be my HVLP rig, dovetail jig, biscuit cutter, pocket hole gear, mechanic's tools, finishing supplies, things where it really doesn't matter if it takes some time and effort to get to them... Different folks will have different needs, based on personal work habits. I don't think I'll ever be completely 100% organized, but it made a huge difference getting the warm more accessible than the cold, and the hot more accessible than the warm. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.